
Photo: Andhra Pradesh Legislative Assembly, Kdslk, CC0
APPSC Group-I Mains 2023 · Paper III
2023 Paper III · Q6(b): model answer
Polity, Constitution, Governance, Law & Ethics · Running the government: administration, policies and civil services. Held in June 2023 (Notification 28/2022).
It is observed that much of present-day Indian bureaucracy is a result of British administration. In this connection, explain the evolution of Civil Service in India.
Syllabus: Running the government: administration, policies and civil services · What public administration is and its history (Kautilya to British rule)
Steel frameICSMerit systemAll India Services
The term "civil service" comes from the East India Company, whose covenanted servants handled civil, as distinct from military, work. Present-day Indian bureaucracy, with its district Collector, hierarchy, merit-based open competition, generalist elite and Public Service Commissions, is largely a British legacy, adapted after 1947 to a democratic Constitution. Sardar Patel called the All India Services the "steel frame" of the nation.
1. Company period (1757-1857)
- Collector: Warren Hastings created the post of Collector in 1772, which became the pivot of district administration.
- Lord Cornwallis (1786-93): the "father of the civil services in India" raised salaries, banned private trade and separated revenue from judicial work.
- Covenanted services: senior posts were reserved for servants who signed covenants with the Company, almost all of them Europeans.
- Training: Fort William College in Calcutta (1800) and Haileybury College in England (1806) trained recruits.
2. Merit and Indianisation under the Crown
- Open competition: the Charter Act of 1853 ended patronage; the Macaulay Committee (1854) shaped the examination, first held in London in 1855.
- First Indian: Satyendranath Tagore entered the ICS in 1863.
- Restructuring: Lytton's Statutory Civil Service (1879) gave way, on the Aitchison Commission's (1886-87) advice, to Imperial, Provincial and Subordinate services.
- Examinations in India: after the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms, simultaneous examinations began in 1922; the Lee Commission (1923-24) led to a Public Service Commission in 1926; the Government of India Act, 1935 created Federal and Provincial PSCs.
- 1772 Warren Hastings creates the post of Collector
- 1786-93 Cornwallis's reforms: higher pay, no private trade
- 1853 Charter Act introduces open competition
- 1855 First ICS examination in London
- 1926 Public Service Commission set up
- 1935 Federal and Provincial PSCs
- 1951 All India Services Act
- 1966 Indian Forest Service created
- 2020 Mission Karmayogi
3. After independence
- Continuity with change: the ICS gave way to the IAS and the Indian Police to the IPS; Sardar Patel defended them as essential for unity.
- Constitutional base: Article 312 (All India Services), Articles 315-323 (UPSC and State PSCs) and the All India Services Act, 1951.
- Reforms: the Kothari Committee (1976) shaped the present three-stage examination; the Second ARC (2008) and Mission Karmayogi (2020) shifted focus to performance and capacity.
| British feature | Present-day form |
|---|---|
| Collector of the district (1772) | District Collector and Magistrate |
| Covenanted ICS, generalist elite | IAS and other All India Services |
| Open competitive examination (1853) | UPSC Civil Services Examination |
| Public Service Commission (1926) | UPSC and State PSCs (Articles 315-323) |
4. Continuities and changes
- Continuities: hierarchy, generalist dominance, the Collector's central role, rule-bound procedure and secrecy are colonial inheritances.
- Changes: the services now serve elected governments, focus on development and welfare rather than revenue and order, and have become socially diverse through reservation under Article 16(4).
AP angle: the Madras Service Commission (1929), the first provincial commission, also served the Andhra region; the APPSC was formed in 1956 under Article 315.
The colonial legacy of control must now yield to a citizen-centric, accountable service, moving, in Mission Karmayogi's words, from rule to role.
The other choice in Q6
Answer either one in the exam.
- Q6(a)'The concept of the welfare state had been crystallised in Kautilya's ideas long before it came to be envisioned in Western Europe' - Examine this statement.
10 marks · Running the government: administration, policies and civil services · What public administration is and its history (Kautilya to British rule)
Every model answer on these pages is free to read. The Tool Kit adds four PDF books for Mains Papers I–IV: every previous question sorted by syllabus, with practice questions. It is in the ₹149 All-in-One Pass, with every previous paper of every exam on the site, practice quizzes, timed tests, mock test series and study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking