Learn with Anil · UPSC Indian Forest Service PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
The main building of the Forest Research Institute, Dehradun

Photo: Forest Research Institute, Dehradun, Mrigank Das, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Indian Forest Service (Main) 2020 · General English

UPSC IFoS Mains 2020 General English · Q4(a): model answer

General English: Essay, Letter or Report, Précis, Comprehension and Grammar · Comprehension.

Q4(a)10 marks2020 · General English

Passage

An ingrained idea in the minds of Western scholars is that any Western borrowings must be equated with a loss of identity. Indeed, it is predicated upon a sort of general theory of Indian development loaded with Western clichés about modern India. It draws heavily on the fashionable Western view that Indian intellectuals, Jawaharlal Nehru included, are elitist, ape the West and have no sense of the truly Indian. Implied in this is also the thought that the West must tell us how to be true Indians. None of these westerners or expatriate Indians, it is clear, have seen the vast rural concourses that assembled to hear Nehru and have no idea of the degree of his rapport with them. In discussing economic planning, they lose sight of India's goal of real independence, free from manipulation and economic imperialism, to be found only in a substantial industrial-agricultural self-sufficiency. They set up a dramatic opposition between Gandhi and Nehru, painting one Indian and the other Western, forgetting the Western influence on the former and the Indianness of the latter—both of which ran equally deep. What is also forgotten is that despite their differences Gandhi did nominate Nehru as his successor. The Nehruvian policy of non-alignment is an extension of non-violence and the doctrine of import substitution an extension of the Charkha (spinning wheel), the Gandhian symbol of individual self-sufficiency in the pre-Independence period.

There is a lack of understanding here about the reversal process that so-called 'Westernization' brings in at the creative, intellectual level in an ancient civilization. Macaulay's educational policy sought to generate a tribe of 'brown Englishmen' and partly succeeded in doing so, but he never foresaw that they would in fact turn into a great force to liberate Indians from the British and to engage in a discovery of India. Indeed, it can be shown from the history of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries that in virtually all fields of creative endeavour, it is the so-called westernized segment which led a great movement for Indianization. It is they who turned from a European philosophy, literature and art to a rediscovery of their roots in Indian tradition. It can also be shown that those who did not go through the process of reversal became victims of cheap Western mores and are today celebrating a macabre marriage of consumerism and fundamentalism that is threatening the very integrity and unity of India, creating a new divisiveness on religious, linguistic and regional axes. Few Western scholars understand the vital need in developing countries for a successful synthesis of tradition and modernity that would trigger progress without loss of identity. An unchanged, unmediated continuity would destroy itself by its very unawareness and its consequent imitation of the most superficial aspects of Western society.

What, according to the writer, are the main prejudices Western scholars nurture about India?

Syllabus: Comprehension · Comprehension

Model answer · free

According to the writer, Western scholars believe that any borrowing from the West means a loss of Indian identity. They hold the clichéd view that Indian intellectuals, including Nehru, are elitist, imitate the West and lack a sense of what is truly Indian, and imply that the West must tell Indians how to be truly Indian. They ignore Nehru's deep rapport with the rural masses, misunderstand India's economic planning by overlooking its aim of real independence through self-sufficiency, and set up a false opposition between Gandhi as "Indian" and Nehru as "Western".

The other parts of Q4

  1. Q4(b)In what different ways did Nehru incorporate Gandhian ideas in his vision of India?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  2. Q4(c)What is known as the 'reversal process'? Explain with the help of examples the writer has given.

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  3. Q4(d)Discuss the implications of the paradox between Western elite and Indianization, as outlined by the writer.

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  4. Q4(e)Why is it important for the developing countries to find the synthesis of tradition and modernity?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149