
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2024 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2024 Paper 2 · Q7(c): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements.
Elucidate the resurgence of ethno-nationalism from an anthropological lens.
Syllabus: Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements · Ethnicity, regionalism and political movements
Ethno-nationalismEthnic boundariesImagined communitiesIdentity politics
Ethno-nationalism is the claim that a people defined by shared descent, language, religion or culture should have its own political community — autonomy, statehood or dominance within a State. Modernisation was expected to dissolve such loyalties, yet from the break-up of Yugoslavia and the Rwandan genocide (1990s) to the Catalan referendum (2017) and conflicts in India's North-East, it has seen a resurgence. Anthropology explains it through ethnicity as a socially maintained boundary (Fredrik Barth, Ethnic Groups and Boundaries, 1969).
1. Anthropological lenses
- Primordialism: Clifford Geertz ("The Integrative Revolution", 1963) described attachments to blood, language, religion and custom as deeply felt "givens" that new States struggle to integrate; this explains the emotional intensity of ethnic claims.
- Instrumentalism: Abner Cohen (Custom and Politics in Urban Africa, 1969) and Paul Brass (Ethnicity and Nationalism, 1991) show elites mobilising ethnicity to compete for land, jobs and power.
- Constructivism: Benedict Anderson's "imagined communities" (1983), Ernest Gellner's Nations and Nationalism (1983) and Hobsbawm and Ranger's The Invention of Tradition (1983) show nations being made through print, schooling and symbols.
- Ethno-symbolism: Anthony D. Smith (The Ethnic Origins of Nations, 1986) argues that modern nations rework older myths, memories and homelands, which is why some identities resonate.
- Boundary approach: for Barth, the boundary matters more than the "cultural stuff" inside it; boundaries harden when groups compete for scarce resources.
2. Why the resurgence?
- Globalisation and insecurity: Arjun Appadurai (Fear of Small Numbers, 2006) argues that global flows breed uncertainty, turning majorities against minorities; Thomas Hylland Eriksen sees identity politics as a response to rapid change.
- Migration and demography: fear of outsiders over land, jobs and culture drives "sons of the soil" movements (Myron Weiner, 1978), such as the Assam movement (1979–85); the final NRC list in Assam (2019) left out about 19 lakh people.
- Uneven development: relative deprivation fuels demands for autonomy, as in the Jharkhand movement (State formed 2000) and Bodoland.
- Recognition politics: contests over ST status and territory, as in Manipur's Meitei–Kuki-Zo conflict since May 2023, and the Pathalgadi movement in Jharkhand (2017–18) asserting gram sabha authority.
- Digital media and elections: social media spreads myths of origin and grievance, and electoral competition rewards ethnic appeals.
| Movement | Identity marker | Demand | Response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mizo | Ethnicity, language, religion | Independence, later statehood | Mizo Accord 1986; State in 1987 |
| Naga | Tribal ethnicity, territory | Sovereign, integrated "Nagalim" | Ceasefire 1997; Framework Agreement 2015; talks continue |
| Bodo (Assam) | Language, tribal identity | Separate State | Accords 2003 and 2020; Bodoland Territorial Region |
| Catalonia (Spain) | Language, history | Independence | 2017 referendum declared illegal; autonomy retained |
| Former Yugoslavia | Religion, ethnicity | Separate nation-states | War and break-up in the 1990s |
3. Evaluation
- Constructive side: recognition through linguistic States, the Sixth Schedule and peace accords has accommodated many movements, as Mizoram's lasting peace shows.
- Destructive side: exclusive identities can lead to majoritarianism, ethnic cleansing and displacement of minorities.
- Anthropological lesson: identities are multiple and situational; essentialising them, by States or movements, deepens conflict.
Ethno-nationalism is thus a modern response to insecurity, not a survival of the past. Federal accommodation, dialogue and equal citizenship, rather than suppression, are the anthropologically informed answer.
The other parts of Q7
- Q7(a)Critically examine existing paradigms of holistic health for the marginalised sections of society drawing inferences from COVID-19 pandemic.
20 marks · Problems of Tribal Communities · Health, nutrition and education
- Q7(b)Discuss the theories on origin of caste system and its criticism in India. Differentiate between caste, class and race.
15 marks · Caste System · Theories of the origin of caste
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking