Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
Warli tribal paintings on a city wall in Mysuru

Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2024 · Paper II

UPSC Anthropology Optional 2024 Paper 2 · Q7(b): model answer

Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Caste System.

Q7(b)15 marks2024 · Paper II

Discuss the theories on origin of caste system and its criticism in India. Differentiate between caste, class and race.

Syllabus: Caste System · Theories of the origin of caste

Model answer · free

Origin of casteRacial theoryEndogamyCaste, class and race

Caste (jati) is a hereditary, endogamous and ranked group linked to occupation and to ideas of purity and pollution. G.S. Ghurye (Caste and Race in India, 1932) listed its six features: segmental division, hierarchy, restrictions on feeding and social intercourse, civil and religious disabilities and privileges, restricted choice of occupation and restrictions on marriage. Its origin is debated, and no single theory explains it.

1. Theories of origin and their criticism

  • Traditional (varna) theory: the Purusha Sukta (Rig Veda X.90) derives four varnas from the cosmic being. Criticism: it explains varna, not thousands of jatis, and legitimises hierarchy.
  • Racial theory: H.H. Risley (The People of India, 1908) used the nasal index to argue that caste ranks followed an Aryan–non-Aryan racial gradient; Ghurye traced caste to Indo-Aryan Brahmins' concern with purity. Criticism: Ghurye found the correlation only in the north, and Iravati Karve's measurements in Maharashtra found castes closer to regional neighbours than to equally ranked castes elsewhere; the nasal index is no measure of race. Genome studies (Reich et al., 2009; Moorjani et al., 2013) show mixed ancestry followed by long endogamy, not separate races.
  • Occupational theory: John Nesfield (1885) saw castes as occupational groups ranked by the prestige of their work. Criticism: castes of different rank share occupations, and occupation cannot explain endogamy or untouchability.
  • Ritual theories: A.M. Hocart (Caste, 1950) traced caste to hereditary roles in royal sacrifice; Louis Dumont (Homo Hierarchicus, 1966) built it on the opposition of pure and impure. Criticism: Gerald Berreman saw in it a Brahmanical view from above that ignores power and exploitation.
  • Mana theory: J.H. Hutton (Caste in India, 1946) linked caste to tribal taboos on food and marriage and belief in mana. Criticism: mana is a Melanesian idea, and such taboos exist without caste elsewhere.
  • Endogamy theory: B.R. Ambedkar ("Castes in India", 1916) argued that caste arose when endogamy was superimposed on exogamy, enforced through sati, enforced widowhood and child marriage. Criticism: it explains how caste was maintained better than how it began.
  • Other and multi-factor views: Émile Senart (1896) traced caste to ancient family and marriage rules, and Denzil Ibbetson (1883) to tribes and guilds hardened by Brahmin influence; Hutton and Karve (Hindu Society: An Interpretation, 1961) conclude that race, occupation, ritual, politics and the absorption of tribes worked together over centuries.

2. Caste, class and race distinguished

  • Comparisons: Oliver C. Cox (Caste, Class and Race, 1948) treated them as distinct systems; Gerald Berreman (1960) found caste in India and race in the American South alike: rigid and birth-ascribed.
  • Changing caste: groups rise through Sanskritisation (M.N. Srinivas, 1952), and caste, class and power, once aligned, drift apart, as André Béteille found in a Tanjore village (Caste, Class and Power, 1965).
  • Race today: biological anthropology treats race as a social construct, not a valid biological division.
AspectCasteClassRace
BasisBirth, ritual purity, hereditary occupationEconomic position: wealth, income, occupationSupposed common descent and physical traits
MembershipAscribed for lifeAchieved; can changeAscribed; boundaries socially drawn
MobilityVery limited; group mobility via SanskritisationIndividual mobility possibleVery limited where racial lines are enforced
MarriageStrict endogamyNo rule, though class endogamy is commonEndogamy enforced only under racist laws
LegitimationPurity, karma and dharmaMarket, property, educationPseudo-scientific racism
ExampleJatis of an Indian villageIndustrial workers, middle classApartheid South Africa, segregated American South
Caste, class and race compared

Caste is best seen as the product of multiple historical processes, hardened by endogamy. Today it adapts to class and politics rather than vanishing, which is why constitutional safeguards against caste discrimination remain essential.

The other parts of Q7

  1. Q7(a)Critically examine existing paradigms of holistic health for the marginalised sections of society drawing inferences from COVID-19 pandemic.

    20 marks · Problems of Tribal Communities · Health, nutrition and education

  2. Q7(c)Elucidate the resurgence of ethno-nationalism from an anthropological lens.

    15 marks · Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements · Ethnicity, regionalism and political movements

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149