
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2023 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2023 Paper 2 · Q7(b): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Problems of Tribal Communities.
Critically examine how the displacement of tribal communities due to hydroelectric river dam projects has affected the women in local context. Illustrate with suitable ethnographic examples.
Syllabus: Problems of Tribal Communities · Displacement and rehabilitation
Development-induced displacementGendered impoverishmentCernea's IRR modelSardar Sarovar
Large dams are among the biggest causes of development-induced displacement in India, and Walter Fernandes estimates that tribal people make up about two-fifths of all those displaced since Independence. For tribal women the loss is double: they lose the river, forest and commons on which their work and status rested, while compensation is built around a male "head of household". Michael Cernea's Impoverishment Risks and Reconstruction model (1997) shows how each risk weighs more heavily on women.
1. Loss of the economic base
- Commons: tribal women gather fuel, fodder, fish, minor forest produce and medicinal plants; submergence and distant resettlement colonies cut them off from these sources of food and cash.
- Titles in men's names: land and cash compensation go to recorded owners, usually men, so women's customary use rights vanish; Bina Agarwal (A Field of One's Own, 1994) showed how such privatisation erodes women's claims to land.
- From producer to wage worker: many women become casual labourers or migrants, while cash in men's hands is often lost to debt or drink.
| Risk | Effect on women |
|---|---|
| Landlessness | Compensation in men's names; use rights lost |
| Joblessness | Forest work replaced by casual wage labour |
| Homelessness | Crowded colonies, loss of privacy and safety |
| Marginalisation | Lower standing in household and community |
| Food insecurity | Women eat last; gathered foods disappear |
| Increased morbidity | Anaemia, unsafe water, heavier workload |
| Loss of common property | No fuel, fodder or forest produce nearby |
| Social disarticulation | Kin and natal-village support broken |
2. Social and cultural effects
- Broken networks: scattering of villages and clans weakens the kin support on which women rely in childbirth, illness and widowhood.
- Violence and insecurity: alcohol abuse, domestic violence, harassment near construction camps and trafficking increase in uprooted settings.
- Sacred loss: submergence of shrines, groves and burial grounds weakens rituals in which women have roles, and women are seldom consulted on rehabilitation.
3. Ethnographic illustrations
- Sardar Sarovar (Narmada): Amita Baviskar's In the Belly of the River (1995) on the Bhilala of Alirajpur shows how a forest and river economy was destroyed; the Narmada tribunal treated adult sons, but not adult daughters, as separate families for land, a gap criticised by feminist scholars.
- Kariba Dam (Zambia): Elizabeth Colson's study of the resettled Gwembe Tonga (1971) found relocation straining family and kin ties, and her later work urged a gendered view of the uprooted; Scudder and Colson's four-stage model (1982) shows stress peaking during transition.
- Koel-Karo (Jharkhand): Munda villagers, women among them, resisted this project for decades; after police firing at Tapkara (2001) killed eight protesters, it was shelved in 2003.
- Polavaram (Godavari): Koya and Konda Reddi villages of the Godavari Agency tracts face submergence, raising the same concerns about women's access to podu fields and forest produce.
4. Critical assessment and safeguards
- Not one-sided: some women gain roads, schools and health centres, and women have shown agency in movements such as the Narmada Bachao Andolan; Lyla Mehta and Bina Srinivasan, in a gender review for the World Commission on Dams (report 2000), argued that dam planning overlooks gendered costs.
- Law: the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 counts widows, divorcees and deserted women as separate families, treats every adult as a separate family, and needs gram sabha consent in Scheduled Areas; the Forest Rights Act, 2006 bars relocation before rights are settled.
Dams turn tribal women from producers into dependants unless resettlement is gender-just. Joint land titles, land-for-land, women's voice in gram sabhas and gender-disaggregated social impact assessment are the minimum safeguards.
The other parts of Q7
- Q7(a)Elucidate the shifting terrains of India's tribal policies in colonial and post-colonial periods.
20 marks · Tribal Development · History of tribal administration and policies
- Q7(c)Elucidate the role of anthropology in nation building. Illustrate with suitable examples.
15 marks · Tribal Development · Role of NGOs and anthropology in development
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking