Learn with Anil · APPSC Group-I PYQsPractise online →Subscribe ₹149
The Andhra Pradesh Legislative Assembly hall

Photo: Andhra Pradesh Legislative Assembly, Kdslk, CC0

APPSC Group-I Mains 2023 · Paper III

2023 Paper III · Q1(a): model answer

Polity, Constitution, Governance, Law & Ethics · The Constitution and our rights. Held in June 2023 (Notification 28/2022).

Q1(a)10 marks2023 · Paper III

Examine the scope of 'reasonable restrictions' and the 'test of reasonableness' in connection with Article 19 of the Indian Constitution.

Syllabus: The Constitution and our rights · Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles and how rights are protected

Model answer · free

Article 19Reasonable restrictionsTest of reasonablenessProportionality

Article 19(1) guarantees six freedoms to citizens: speech and expression, peaceful assembly, association, movement, residence, and profession, trade or business (the right to property was deleted by the 44th Amendment, 1978). These freedoms are not absolute. Clauses (2) to (6) allow the State to impose "reasonable restrictions" by law on specified grounds, and the courts, applying the test of reasonableness, decide whether a restriction is valid. The aim is to balance individual liberty with social control.

1. Scope of reasonable restrictions

  • Only on listed grounds: each freedom has its own grounds (see table). In Kaushal Kishore (2023) a Constitution Bench held the grounds in Article 19(2) to be exhaustive, so no new ground can be added by invoking other rights.
  • Only by law: a restriction must be imposed by a valid law, not by an executive instruction (Bijoe Emmanuel, 1986, the national anthem case).
  • Grounds widened by amendment: after Romesh Thappar (1950), the First Amendment (1951) added public order, friendly relations with foreign States and incitement to an offence, and inserted the word "reasonable"; the 16th Amendment (1963) added sovereignty and integrity of India.
  • Special situations: Article 33 lets Parliament restrict the rights of the armed forces, and Article 358 suspends Article 19 during an Emergency declared on the ground of war or external aggression.
FreedomClauseGrounds of restriction
Speech and expression19(2)Sovereignty and integrity, security of the State, friendly relations with foreign States, public order, decency or morality, contempt of court, defamation, incitement to an offence
Peaceful assembly19(3)Sovereignty and integrity, public order
Association19(4)Sovereignty and integrity, public order, morality
Movement and residence19(5)Interests of the general public, protection of Scheduled Tribes
Profession, trade, business19(6)Interests of the general public, professional or technical qualifications, State monopoly
Freedoms under Article 19 and grounds of restriction

2. The test of reasonableness

  • No fixed standard (V.G. Row, 1952): the court weighs the nature of the right, the purpose of the restriction, the extent and urgency of the evil, proportionality and the prevailing conditions.
  • Not arbitrary or excessive (Chintaman Rao, 1950): a restriction that goes beyond what its object requires is unreasonable.
  • Substance and procedure: both the law and the procedure it lays down must be reasonable; Maneka Gandhi (1978) read Articles 14, 19 and 21 together.
  • Clarity: Shreya Singhal (2015) struck down Section 66A of the IT Act as vague and overbroad, separating discussion and advocacy, which are protected, from incitement.

3. Proportionality: the modern test

Legitimate aim, backed by law
Rational connection between measure and aim
Necessity: least restrictive alternative
Balancing: benefit outweighs harm to the right
Restriction upheld
Four-step proportionality test (Modern Dental College, 2016; Puttaswamy, 2017)
  • Privacy: Puttaswamy (2017) adopted the test for the right to privacy, and the Aadhaar judgment (2018) applied it to uphold the scheme with limits.
  • Digital age: Anuradha Bhasin (2020) applied proportionality to internet shutdowns: they must be temporary, necessary, published and periodically reviewed.

AP angle: in the protective spirit of Article 19(5), the AP Scheduled Areas Land Transfer Regulation (1 of 1959, amended 1970) bars the transfer of land in Scheduled Areas to non-tribals; in Samatha (1997) the Supreme Court held leases of such land to private mining firms void.

Reasonableness is thus a judicially tested balance: freedom remains the rule and restriction the exception, and proportionality ensures that the State uses the least intrusive means to protect the public interest.

The other choice in Q1

Answer either one in the exam.

  1. Q1(b)Explain the genesis of the Inter-State Council and discuss its relevance in the context of Centre-State and Inter-State coordination and cooperation in India.

    10 marks · Centre and States: sharing power and money · Federalism: a strong Centre, Centre–State friction and cooperation

Write better answers: the Answer Writing Tool Kit

Every model answer on these pages is free to read. The Tool Kit adds four PDF books for Mains Papers I–IV: every previous question sorted by syllabus, with practice questions. It is in the ₹149 All-in-One Pass, with every previous paper of every exam on the site, practice quizzes, timed tests, mock test series and study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149