
Photo: Lepakshi Nandi, Rahmanuddin, CC BY-SA 4.0
APPSC Group-I Mains 2023 · Paper II
2023 Paper II · Q3(b): model answer
History, Culture & Geography of India and Andhra Pradesh · Medieval India. Held in June 2023 (Notification 28/2022).
'The state that was [illegible] Shivaji was not only egalitarian in conception but also a welfare state in nature.' Examine.
Syllabus: Medieval India · Mughals, Shivaji and the Marathas
SwarajyaAshtapradhanPeasant welfareReligious tolerance
Shivaji (1630–1680), crowned Chhatrapati at Raigad in 1674, carved the Maratha Swarajya out of Bijapur and Mughal territories. Historians often describe his state as inclusive and peasant-friendly. The statement can be tested against his recruitment, revenue, religious and military policies, remembering that 'welfare state' and 'egalitarian' are modern concepts applied to a 17th-century monarchy.
1. Egalitarian features
- Open recruitment: Mavale peasants and men of many castes rose through merit; Muslims held high posts, such as the commander Siddi Hilal and the admiral Daulat Khan.
- Curbing hereditary power: deshmukhs and jagirdars were brought under control, and most officers were paid in cash rather than through jagirs.
- Religious tolerance: he made grants to temples and also to mosques and dargahs; even the critical chronicler Khafi Khan noted that his soldiers were forbidden to harm mosques, the Quran or women.
2. Welfare features
- Revenue reform: Annaji Datto surveyed land with a measuring rod (kathi); assessment was fixed at about 30 per cent of produce, raised to 40 per cent when other cesses were abolished, and collected directly from peasants.
- Peasant relief: loans for seed and cattle, remission in bad seasons and incentives to cultivate waste land.
- Protecting the people: soldiers were forbidden to damage standing crops or take women to camp, and his orders told officers not to take even a blade of grass from peasants without paying.
- Ordered administration: the Ashtapradhan council ran departments, the Nyayadhish dispensed justice, each fort was held jointly by three officers of equal rank (havaldar, sabnis and sarnobat) who checked one another, and a navy with sea forts such as Sindhudurg protected the coast.
3. Limitations
- Hierarchy remained: the varna order continued; his coronation by Gaga Bhatta required a Kshatriya genealogy, and Brahmanas dominated civil posts.
- Burden on neighbours: chauth (one-fourth) and sardeshmukhi (an additional one-tenth) were levied on neighbouring territories, and Surat was raided.
- Priorities of war: survival against the Mughals and Bijapur shaped policy more than welfare.
- Dependence on the ruler: the system rested on Shivaji's personal vigilance and weakened under the Mughal onslaught after his death in 1680.
| Claim | Supporting evidence | Qualification |
|---|---|---|
| Egalitarian | Merit-based recruitment; Muslims in high posts | Varna order and Brahmana dominance of civil posts |
| Welfare state | Direct collection, loans, remissions | Chauth and sardeshmukhi on neighbours |
| Just and orderly | Nyayadhish; disciplined army | Personal, monarchical rule |
AP angle: during his Karnataka expedition (1677) Shivaji allied with Abul Hasan Qutb Shah of Golconda and visited Srisailam.
By seventeenth-century standards, Shivaji's state was markedly inclusive and peasant-oriented, a proto-welfare state, though not egalitarian in the modern sense.
The other choice in Q3
Answer either one in the exam.
- Q3(a)Discuss the features of Mughal architecture and examine the influence of Hindu elements on Mughal architecture.
10 marks · Medieval India · Mughals, Shivaji and the Marathas
Every model answer on these pages is free to read. The Tool Kit adds four PDF books for Mains Papers I–IV: every previous question sorted by syllabus, with practice questions. It is in the ₹149 All-in-One Pass, with every previous paper of every exam on the site, practice quizzes, timed tests, mock test series and study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking