
Photo: Paddy fields near Eluru, iMahesh, CC BY-SA 4.0
APPSC Group-I Mains 2020 · Paper IV
2020 Paper IV · Q11(b): model answer
Economy & Development of India and Andhra Pradesh · Infrastructure: roads, power, digital and cities. Held in December 2020 (Notification 27/2018).
Explain the Marginal Cost Pricing Rule for Public Utilities. What are the problems associated with this rule?
Syllabus: Infrastructure: roads, power, digital and cities · Paying for infrastructure: PPP and pricing of public utilities
Marginal cost pricingNatural monopolyAllocative efficiencyTwo-part tariff
Public utilities such as electricity, water, railways and gas are natural monopolies: their fixed costs (plants, grids, pipes, tracks) are very high and their running costs low, so one supplier serves the market most cheaply. How such a utility should price its output is a classic problem. The Marginal Cost Pricing (MCP) rule, associated with Hotelling (1938), says a utility should charge a price equal to the marginal cost of supply (P = MC).
1. The rule explained
- Efficiency: at P = MC, what consumers will pay for the last unit equals the cost of producing it. Output is allocatively efficient, with none of the deadweight loss of monopoly pricing (P > MC).
- Signal to users: consumers use more only when the value to them exceeds the cost to society, so scarce capacity is not wasted.
- Peak-load pricing: a variant that charges more at peak times, so that peak users bear the cost of capacity built for them. For example, an extra unit of electricity at night costs little because plants are idle, while at the evening peak it may need costly generation.
2. Problems with the rule
- Losses: when average cost (AC) falls as output rises, MC is below AC, so P = MC means a loss, covered by subsidies from distortionary taxes.
- Measurement: joint costs and lumpy investments make MC hard to estimate; short-run and long-run MC can differ widely.
- Second best: if other sectors do not price at MC, applying the rule in one sector may not raise welfare (Lipsey–Lancaster, 1956).
- Equity: the rule ignores ability to pay, so poor households may be priced out of essentials such as water.
- Investment: no surplus is left for maintenance and expansion, and subsidies weaken cost discipline.
3. Practical alternatives
- Average-cost pricing: the utility breaks even, at some loss of efficiency.
- Two-part tariffs: a fixed charge recovers capacity costs, and a per-unit charge close to MC keeps the efficiency signal.
- Ramsey pricing: higher mark-ups where demand is less elastic.
- Time-of-day tariffs: mandatory for commercial and industrial consumers from April 2024.
| Rule | Price | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marginal cost | P = MC | Allocative efficiency | Losses need subsidy |
| Average cost | P = AC | Utility breaks even | Some deadweight loss |
| Two-part tariff | Fixed charge + per-unit charge near MC | Efficient and viable | Fixed charge burdens small users |
| Ramsey pricing | Mark-up higher where demand is inelastic | Least distortion while covering cost | Can be inequitable |
| Time-of-day | Higher at peak hours | Shifts demand, saves capacity | Needs smart meters |
Andhra Pradesh angle: The AP Electricity Regulatory Commission sets two-part tariffs with cross-subsidies, and the State budget funds free farm power. The Tariff Policy, 2016 seeks tariffs within ±20% of the average cost of supply.
The best approach combines efficiency (MC signals), viability (fixed charges) and equity (targeted subsidies).
The other choice in Q11
Answer either one in the exam.
- Q11(a)Describe some of the key initiatives taken and incentives provided by the government of Andhra Pradesh to promote agro and food processing industry.
10 marks · Industry and business (India and AP) · AP's industrial policy, incentives, corridors, MSMEs and exports
Every model answer on these pages is free to read. The Tool Kit adds four PDF books for Mains Papers I–IV: every previous question sorted by syllabus, with practice questions. It is in the ₹149 All-in-One Pass, with every previous paper of every exam on the site, practice quizzes, timed tests, mock test series and study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking