
Photo: Forest Research Institute, Dehradun, Mrigank Das, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Indian Forest Service (Main) 2025 · General English
UPSC IFoS Mains 2025 General English · Q3: model answer
General English: Essay, Letter or Report, Précis, Comprehension and Grammar · Précis.
Passage
Places are synthetic compositions of meaning, social relations, and nature. These elements often combine into a nearly seamless web in our experience of place, but a theoretical understanding of place requires that they be kept analytically separate in order to understand how each component contributes to the functioning of place in relation to human projects. Their origins as human constructions are often hidden by the mere fact that places are "always there". It is during extreme and traumatic moments that their contingent nature becomes evident. To what kind of trauma does place destruction lead? How does one narrate the trauma of what may be referred to as "place annihilation"? What is the form of trauma that one can associate with the destruction of place in natural disasters?
Natural disaster fits within a category of events that would seem in, and of themselves, to be culturally traumatic; but, because cultural trauma is made, no events "qualify automatically". However, certain aspects of natural disasters and their cultural interpretations make such events categorically distinct from other potentially traumatic occurrences and, to a certain extent, less likely candidates as sources of cultural trauma.
One of the consequences of place annihilation is a sense of individual and collective insecurity in relation to an indifferent nature. Such a potential loss threatens in a manner that exposes the fragility and contingency of that which humans rarely question — that is, the continuity of the physical landscapes, built environments, social rules, and cultural meanings that give both visible and invisible order to the rhythms of everyday existence. Such situations would seemingly have consequences for individual and collective identity and thus would be an important part of cultural trauma. Indeed, in the specific circumstance in which place annihilation is interpreted broadly to include the usurpation of place of one group replacing another, the result can have immediate, dramatic, and lasting consequences for collective identity.
When, however, the cause of the destruction is seen to be a natural process, or interpreted as if it were a natural process, its relation to collective identity is not as clear. Concomitantly, the likelihood of its becoming an element of cultural memory is relatively low. Natural events rarely touch on the collective sense of the sacred in ways similar to humanly caused events. Nor do they have the same connection to a strong negative affect, such as guilt or shame. In the modern era, the cultural value given to the remembrance of trauma created by natural catastrophes is relatively low. Another possible reason for this forgetfulness is that such events lack the hope of collective edification through remembering. There are indeed many lessons to be learned from such events, but these have become culturally categorized as lessons for political leaders, social managers, and experts — in other words, for those charged with protecting and manipulating the natural realm in the construction of places for communal projects. The emphasis is thus in the realm of the instrumental as opposed to the affective.
Write a precis of the following passage in about 165 words, one-third of the original length. Do not give it any title.
Syllabus: Précis · Précis
PlaceNatural disasterCultural traumaCollective memory
Précis
Places combine meaning, social relations and nature. In daily life they seem permanent and natural, but disasters that destroy them reveal that they are human creations. Natural disasters seem traumatic in themselves, yet cultural trauma is socially made, and some features of natural disasters make them less likely to become cultural traumas than other events.
The destruction of a place makes people feel insecure before an indifferent nature and shows how fragile the landscapes, buildings, rules and meanings that order daily life really are. This can deeply affect individual and collective identity, especially when one group's place is taken over by another.
When the destruction is seen as natural, however, its link with collective identity is weak, and it seldom enters cultural memory. Natural events rarely touch the sense of the sacred or arouse guilt or shame, and remembering them seems to offer no collective moral lesson. Their lessons are treated as practical matters for leaders and experts, not as matters of feeling.
(163 words)
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking