Learn with Anil · UPSC Indian Forest Service PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
The main building of the Forest Research Institute, Dehradun

Photo: Forest Research Institute, Dehradun, Mrigank Das, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Indian Forest Service (Main) 2024 · General English

UPSC IFoS Mains 2024 General English · Q4(a): model answer

General English: Essay, Letter or Report, Précis, Comprehension and Grammar · Comprehension.

Q4(a)10 marks2024 · General English

Passage

There are not many wetlands like those at Bharatpur left in northern India. Throughout the world, wetlands have been among the least protected of natural ecosystems. There are several good reasons for this. Local populations often perceive wetlands as places of danger. They breed malarial mosquitoes, poisonous snakes, and larger dangerous animals. In India, this includes the aptly named "mugger" crocodiles, tigers, rhinoceroses, leopards, and elephants. One of India's most famous wetlands, the mangrove swamps of the Sundarbans, averages between 40 and 60 human fatalities a year from tiger attacks. Beyond dangerous wildlife, wetlands are difficult terrain to travel through and are prone to such catastrophic inconveniences as flooding.

But once they are drained, wetlands are among the most productive agricultural lands available. The hundreds of millions of people who live in North India are fed by the wheat, rice, and sugarcane grown on the former wetlands surrounding the Ganga and its many tributaries. Western style "development" continues to be experienced in many parts of the world in the attempts to control, regulate, and distribute water through damming rivers and draining wetlands.

The scarcity of wetlands in northern India has resulted in a much higher concentration of birds at Bharatpur than would be considered natural in a less-modified, fragmented landscape. But then, very little about the national park is "natural". There are no large predators in the park — a tiger had wandered into the park last year, but it is uncertain how long it will stay, and the last leopard was killed over twenty-five years ago. There is a very limited assortment of non-avian fauna in the park. It does not have a natural ecosystem. These wetlands now protected in Keoladeo Ghana National Park are not the result of erosion, plate tectonics, or drainage patterns, but are the product of dams and dykes constructed on the orders of the Maharaja of Bharatpur in the 1890s.

The Maharaja was not interested in bird conservation for its own sake. On the contrary, he ordered the construction of the wetlands when he had just returned from a trip to Great Britain where he had greatly enjoyed the waterfowl shooting excursions, and he was determined to have a shooting reserve for himself. He selected a small pre-existing marsh and expanded and deepened it to make it more attractive for wintering birds and year-round bird residents, using many canals and dykes to regulate the water level. He then criss-crossed the area with walking paths so that hunters could have access throughout the wetland. You can still walk on those paths, some still paved with bricks placed there one hundred years earlier, but now visitors to the national park shoot with cameras, not guns.

The Maharaja was successful beyond his wildest dreams. Bharatpur became famed for its bird hunting, and the Maharaja entertained hundreds of visiting British and Indian dignitaries. Stone plaques in the middle of the national park that remain from earlier, bloodier days record visitors — the listings include Lord Curzon (then Viceroy of India — the first of many Viceroys to visit Bharatpur), almost all of the local Maharajas of northern India, the Prince of Wales, the crown prince of Germany, and many others. Their daily kills were stupendous, with some hunts reaching above 4000 birds killed in a single day.

In spite of these hunts, there seemed to be a never-ending supply of birds for Bharatpur. Wetlands in the rest of northern India were being drained and converted to agricultural land, driving birds wintering in those places to the remaining wetlands. Within northern India the conversion of wetlands to agricultural land is not a recent process, but it was accelerated in the twentieth century and especially after India gained independence and embarked upon a national mission for agricultural self-sufficiency. In a country of dwindling wetlands, Bharatpur became increasingly unusual as a protected and stable habitat for waterfowl.

When India achieved independence in 1947, local Maharajas signed agreements with the central government transferring power from their states to the centre. When the Maharaja of Bharatpur negotiated his deed of transfer of power, he made sure that he retained ownership and the exclusive right of shooting in the Ghana wetlands for himself and his friends. Once the initial heady rush of independence had passed, local people who had been the Maharaja's former subjects began to protest his continued privilege in reserving land for his personal pleasure. They argued that this was a clear case of a royal shooting reserve serving no purpose other than the ego-gratification of a former ruler and his friends, and which denied poor landless farmers in surrounding villages, land and water. There were no actual rights among the surrounding villagers to the resources of the wetlands, although local cattle and buffalo were allowed into the reserve on a day-to-day basis for grazing. Bharatpur, local politicians argued in 1950, should be converted to agricultural land for landless labourers, and its canals should stop diverting water from other agricultural areas.

Why are wetlands the least protected natural ecosystems?

Syllabus: Comprehension · Comprehension

Model answer · free

Wetlands have been among the least protected ecosystems because local people see them as dangerous and useless. They breed malarial mosquitoes, poisonous snakes and dangerous animals — in India crocodiles, tigers, rhinos, leopards and elephants; the Sundarbans alone see 40–60 deaths a year from tiger attacks. They are difficult to travel through and prone to floods. Moreover, once drained, they become very productive farmland, so "development" has encouraged draining them and controlling their water through dams.

The other parts of Q4

  1. Q4(b)What is not 'natural' about the Bharatpur wetlands?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  2. Q4(c)What was the motivation for the development of the Bharatpur wetlands?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  3. Q4(d)Why was there a never-ending supply of birds at Bharatpur despite large-scale hunting?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  4. Q4(e)Why did the local farmers launch a protest after independence?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149