Learn with Anil · UPSC Indian Forest Service PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
The main building of the Forest Research Institute, Dehradun

Photo: Forest Research Institute, Dehradun, Mrigank Das, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Indian Forest Service (Main) 2021 · General English

UPSC IFoS Mains 2021 General English · Q4(d): model answer

General English: Essay, Letter or Report, Précis, Comprehension and Grammar · Comprehension.

Q4(d)10 marks2021 · General English

Passage

According to the Arthasastra merchants travelling from place to place paid small road tolls which were collected by an officer called Antapala, who was responsible for the upkeep of the road and its safety. If we are to believe the text these taxes formed a sort of insurance, for the Antapala was expected to make good any loss suffered by the merchants from thieves. It is doubtful whether this system was regularly adopted in later times, when kingdoms were less well organized, but something like it must have prevailed in the Mauryan period. Tolls were also levied at the city gates on incoming merchandise, on a varying ad valorem tariff. The Arthasastra suggests that essential goods such as grain, oil, sugar, pots and cheap textiles should be taxed at one-twentieth of their value, and other goods at rates varying from one-fifteenth to one-fifth. Various market dues were also levied, but the ten per cent sales tax recorded by Megasthenes is nowhere mentioned in an Indian source.

All craftsmen were expected to devote one or two days' work per month to the king, but this tax was probably often commuted to a sort of income tax on average daily earnings. There was also liability to forced labour (visti), though this does not seem always to have fallen very heavily upon the masses. Services in labour and gifts of provisions were expected by the king and his officers when on tour, and this might put small rural communities into serious difficulties. Such obligations of forced labour and service prevailed in some Indian States until very recent times.

So complex a system of taxation could not be maintained without surveying and accountancy. The Jataka stories refer to local officers as "holders of the [surveyor's] cord" (rajjugahaka), and the officers called in the Asokan inscriptions rajjuka may have been the same; Megasthenes records that the land was thoroughly surveyed. Land was only transferred to a new owner after reference to the local land records, and this fact, with the name of the record keepers who had certified its transferability, was often noted in the copper-plate title deeds. The better organized kingdoms evidently kept full and up-to-date records of land ownership corresponding to the English Domesday Book. Unfortunately they were written on perishable materials, and all have long since vanished.

Taxation was burdensome, especially in times of bad harvest or under rapacious kings. There are numerous references in Jataka stories to the harsh exactions of local officers, and to peasants emigrating en masse from their villages to escape crushing taxation. In later South Indian inscriptions we read of something like the rent-strikes of later times, and of a whole village council being imprisoned for failure to pay tax. One inscription records an appeal to the Cola emperor Rajaraja I, in protest against the looting of a village in punishment of tax default; in this case the king upheld the action of his local officers. A defaulting taxpayer was liable to eviction, though he might be given a year's grace or more in case of real need.

The textbooks on statecraft invariably stress the danger of unduly heavy taxation. Nobody can hold honey in his mouth without tasting some of it, and it is to be expected that local officers will claim more tax than their due, but really extortionate collectors are a great danger to the king's safety. Certain admirable general principles are laid down in our sources — taxation should never act as a check on trade and industry; the king should tax as a bee sucks honey, without hurting the flower; taxes should be fixed so as always to allow a profit to the taxpayer; articles of commerce should not be taxed more than once; increases in taxation should not be imposed without due warning. No doubt the better monarchs tried to maintain these principles in their fiscal policy.

What kind of punishments were given to the tax defaulters in the ancient times?

Syllabus: Comprehension · Comprehension

Model answer · free

Tax defaulters faced harsh punishment. South Indian inscriptions mention whole village councils being imprisoned for failing to pay tax, and the looting of a village as punishment for tax default — an action that the Chola emperor Rajaraja I upheld when villagers appealed. A defaulting taxpayer was also liable to eviction, although he might be given a year's grace or more in genuine need. Harsh exactions sometimes drove peasants to leave their villages en masse.

The other parts of Q4

  1. Q4(a)What, according to the Arthasastra, was the role and responsibility of Antapala?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  2. Q4(b)What, according to the Arthasastra, was the rate of taxation on essential goods and services?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  3. Q4(c)Who maintained land records in ancient India and how?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

  4. Q4(e)What were the principles of taxation followed by good monarchs?

    10 marks · Comprehension · Comprehension

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149