Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
A wooden charkha, the spinning wheel of the freedom movement

Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2026 · GS Paper IV

UPSC Mains 2026 GS 4 · Q7: model answer

General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.

Q720 marks250 words2026 · GS Paper IV

Lata, a mother of two children, was admitted to a hospital for acute abdominal pain. Her sister-in-law, Sujatha, accompanied her. Dr. Mansi examined Lata and recommended a diagnostic laparoscopy. Lata’s consent was taken to conduct the medical procedure under general anesthesia.

During the laparoscopy, Dr. Mansi’s team discovered a tumor in Lata’s uterus. A closer examination suggested that the tumor could be malignant.

One option before Dr. Mansi was to extract a sample for biopsy. In that case, if the tumor was malignant, Lata would have to undergo another surgery for removal of the uterus. An alternative was to remove the uterus immediately. Dr. Mansi had to take a quick decision.

As Lata was under general anesthesia, Dr. Mansi explained the situation to Sujatha. Sujatha agreed with Dr. Mansi’s recommendations for a hysterectomy, wherein Lata’s uterus would be removed to avoid the risk and pain of undergoing another surgery. Dr. Mansi removed Lata’s uterus after receiving Sujatha’s consent in writing. Lata was informed of this the next day. She was very upset and felt betrayed as she had not consented to the removal of her uterus.

Lata complained to the police who tried to convince her that Dr. Mansi had acted with good intention to help a patient. Sujatha was of the same opinion, however Lata was not convinced and decided to approach the court.

(a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in this case.
(b) Discuss the moral conduct of the doctor in this situation.

Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies

Model answer · free

Informed consentBodily autonomySurrogate consentMedical paternalism

This case turns on informed consent and bodily autonomy. Lata consented only to a diagnostic laparoscopy; while she was under anaesthesia, Dr Mansi removed her uterus on the written consent of her sister-in-law. The doctor's aim was to spare Lata a second operation (beneficence), but an irreversible operation done without the patient's own consent raises serious ethical and legal questions.

1. Stakeholders

  • Lata, the patient and primary rights-holder, and her husband and children; Dr Mansi and her team; Sujatha; the hospital; the police; the court and the medical council; and the wider public, whose trust in doctors is at stake.

2. (a) Ethical issues involved

  • Autonomy and informed consent: consent is specific to a procedure; consent for diagnosis is not consent for removing an organ. In Samira Kohli v Prabha Manchanda (2008), on very similar facts, the Supreme Court held that consent for a diagnostic laparoscopy did not cover a hysterectomy, and that a relative's consent could not replace that of a competent adult patient.
  • Invalid surrogate consent: Sujatha was not Lata's legal representative, and Lata was only temporarily unconscious; she could have decided within hours.
  • Beneficence versus paternalism: the doctor decided what was "best" for Lata, ignoring that losing her uterus affects her reproductive choices, body image and emotional health, which only she can weigh.
  • No real emergency: the exception for acting without consent applies when delay threatens life or health. A suspected malignancy, not yet confirmed by biopsy, was not such an emergency; if the tumour proves benign, the harm is irreversible and unnecessary.
  • Gender and dignity: decisions about a woman's body were taken by a relative, reflecting patriarchal norms; reproductive autonomy is part of Article 21 (Suchita Srivastava, 2009; Puttaswamy, 2017).
  • Role of the police: instead of recording Lata's complaint, the police tried to persuade her; judging the doctor's intention is not their role. Jacob Mathew v State of Punjab (2005) requires an independent medical opinion before proceeding against a doctor, but the police must not discourage a citizen from seeking justice.

3. (b) Moral conduct of the doctor

OptionProsCons
Take a biopsy, close, discuss results with LataRespects autonomy; diagnosis confirmed firstA second surgery may be needed
Rapid frozen-section biopsy during surgery, if availableQuick diagnosis; better-informed choiceRemoval still needs Lata's consent
Hysterectomy on Sujatha's consent (the doctor's choice)One surgery; quick action against possible cancerNo valid consent; irreversible; may be unnecessary
Options before Dr Mansi during surgery
  • Intention: good; she sought to protect Lata from cancer and a second operation, and she took written consent, so there was no malice or gain.
  • Kantian view: the act failed to respect Lata as a rational agent and treated consent as a formality.
  • Consequentialist view: the benefit is uncertain; if the tumour is benign, the outcome is a net harm.
  • Virtue view: compassion and decisiveness were present, but prudence, humility and respect were missing.
  • Verdict: well-meaning but ethically and legally flawed; good intention cannot cure the absence of consent.

4. Course of action

  • What she should have done: take a biopsy, close, and counsel Lata on the findings and options; in future, discuss likely findings before surgery and record extended consent.
  • What she should do now: disclose the facts candidly, apologise, provide records, counselling and follow-up care, and cooperate with the court.
  • Systemic: the hospital should adopt clear consent protocols and train staff in communication; the police should register the complaint and follow due process.

Dr Mansi's conduct was benevolent but paternalistic. Medicine must heal with the patient, not merely for her; respect for autonomy is the foundation on which beneficence must rest.

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149