
Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2026 · GS Paper IV
UPSC Mains 2026 GS 4 · Q12: model answer
General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.
Ajit has been recently promoted as the Head of the Department of Weapon Sales (DWS) in the Ministry of Defence Production (MDP). His charter of duties includes international sales of weapons produced domestically by MDP.
In two recent wars, MDP weapons have performed admirably, resulting in many countries showing interest in buying them, particularly long-range artillery and missiles. Country A and country B have asked for these weapons. However, production constraints restrict DWS to accept only one purchase order.
Country A is a developing nation with a sound technology base. MDP is planning R&D collaboration with it for the next generation of weapons. It is not part of any security alliance and needs weapons for protection from a troublesome neighbour. It seeks a large acquisition on a long-term loan.
Country B is also a developing nation. Military strength is its priority, with the military budget often ingressing into allocations for human resources and infrastructure development. It is in security alliance with a superpower who has a large military base there and periodically allots it financial grants. It is a member of an economic bloc with which the government is currently negotiating a free trade agreement. It is not a signatory of NPT but possesses smaller nuclear weapons and delivery systems. It supports some guerrilla forces abroad. It has sought a smaller acquisition and is prepared to make some advance payment. It is currently negotiating arms purchases from another nation too.
Ajit discussed this case with his counterparts in the related departments. Therein, the significant economic benefits, employment generation and stronger diplomatic relations arising from this sale were highlighted. It was also emphasized that refusing the deal could result in country B purchasing weapons from some other supplier.
Ajit was aware that in arms sales, due diligence at each stage was pivotal to ensure conformity to national policy and international treaties.
(a) Discuss the options available to Ajit. Which option should he select and why?
(b) How can Ajit balance nation’s economic and strategic interests with ethical considerations?
Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies
Responsible arms tradeDue diligenceNational interest vs ethicsNon-proliferation
Arms exports bring revenue, jobs and influence, and India has made them a priority: its defence exports reached a record ₹38,424 crore in 2025-26 (Ministry of Defence). But weapons can also fuel conflict, repression and proliferation. Ajit must choose between Country A and Country B by weighing the national interest against the ethics of a responsible arms trade and the due diligence demanded by national policy and international regimes.
1. Stakeholders
- India (the ministry, its workers, the exchequer and diplomacy); Country A and its people; Country B and its people, whose social spending is crowded out; regions where B-backed guerrillas operate; the superpower ally; non-proliferation regimes and the international community; and Ajit as an adviser accountable to the government.
| Criterion | Country A | Country B |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Defence against a hostile neighbour | Military build-up at the cost of development |
| Proliferation risk | Low | Nuclear-armed outside the NPT; long-range missiles could add to delivery capability |
| Diversion risk | Low; in no alliance | Backs guerrilla forces abroad; hosts a foreign military base |
| Strategic value | Partner for next-generation R&D | Member of a bloc negotiating an FTA with India |
| Payment | Large order on long-term loan | Smaller order with advance payment |
2. (a) Options available to Ajit
- Sell to Country B: Pros: advance payment, goodwill in FTA talks, a rival supplier is kept out. Cons: weapons may reach guerrillas abroad; long-range missiles could strengthen a nuclear delivery system, against the guidelines of the Missile Technology Control Regime, which India joined in 2016; technology could leak through the foreign base; India would share the blame for any abuses.
- Sell to Country A: Pros: a legitimate need for self-defence (recognised in Article 51 of the UN Charter), a long-term R&D partnership and stable ties. Cons: credit risk of a long-term loan and possible tension with A's neighbour.
- Defer both orders: avoids a hard choice but loses both opportunities and India's credibility as a reliable supplier.
Recommended: sell to Country A, with safeguards.
- End-user certificate, no re-export clause and post-delivery checks; confirmation that A is under no UN arms embargo.
- Credit risk assessed with the finance ministry, with the loan structured through a guaranteed line of credit.
- A reasoned note on file: Ajit gives frank advice, and the competent political authority decides.
- With Country B: continue the FTA talks and non-lethal cooperation on their own merits, without using arms as a bargaining chip.
Why: the argument that "B will buy elsewhere anyway" does not remove India's own complicity if its weapons fuel proxy wars; India itself is outside the NPT, so the concern is not B's treaty status but the real risk of proliferation and diversion; and A offers lasting technological gains while B's order is small.
3. (b) Balancing economic and strategic interests with ethics
- Rule-based due diligence: apply the SCOMET export-control list and the WMD Act, 2005, and the norms of the Wassenaar Arrangement (joined 2017) and UNSC Resolution 1540 on non-state actors, to every sale.
- Enlightened national interest: a reputation as a responsible supplier is itself a strategic asset that builds long-term markets and trust.
- Policy coherence: India opposes cross-border terrorism, so arming a state that backs guerrilla forces abroad would undercut its own stand.
- Decouple trade from arms: FTAs should rest on economic merit, not on weapons deals.
- Sustainable jobs: expand production capacity and diversify buyers rather than accept risky deals.
Arms exports are never ethically neutral. By choosing Country A with safeguards, Ajit serves India's economic and strategic interests while honouring non-proliferation and peace, which is national interest guided by ethics.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking