
Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2026 · GS Paper IV
UPSC Mains 2026 GS 4 · Q10: model answer
General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.
Vikas is a government officer with over a decade of service in public administration. He has recently moved as the District Collector (DC) of Nainipura, a remote hilly district bordering a forest. Due to Nainipura’s low levels of economic development, one of his major duties is to ensure proper functioning of the public distribution system (PDS) amongst the economically weaker sections (EWS).
During his on-site visits, Vikas was apprised of a typical administrative challenge in operating the PDS. To prevent leakages, all distributors were required to carry out real-time biometric identification of the beneficiaries, whose fingerprints were tallied with identity card records. This was creating problems as the operating system sometimes rejected fingerprint matching in the cases of growing children, manual labourers and senior citizens. The problem was further compounded in periods of low WiFi connectivity. The distributors, in such cases, resorted to personal discretion when they could identify the recipient.
Vikas had to address this problem on priority. Strictly adhering to government regulations would ensure fiscal probity but would greatly trouble the proposed beneficiary, i.e., EWS. It may even impinge on their fundamental right to life as per Article 21 of the Constitution. Conversely, leaving the resolution solely to the discretion of the distributors could lead to misuse and leakages.
(a) What are the options open to Vikas? How should he balance fiscal probity with empathy towards the designated beneficiaries?
(b) Discuss the ethics of using technology as a gatekeeper for welfare schemes.
Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies
Exclusion vs leakageRight to foodTechnology as gatekeeperFiscal probity
The National Food Security Act (NFSA), 2013 makes subsidised foodgrains a legal entitlement for about two-thirds of India's population, and they have been free since January 2023 under PMGKAY, extended for five years from January 2024. Biometric authentication at fair price shops was introduced to curb leakages, but in Nainipura fingerprint failures and weak connectivity threaten to deny food to the very people the system serves. Vikas must reconcile fiscal probity with the right to food.
1. Stakeholders
- Beneficiary families, especially children, the elderly and manual labourers; fair price shop dealers; Vikas and the district supply office; State and Central food departments; taxpayers; panchayats and vigilance committees.
2. (a) Options open to Vikas
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Strict biometric-only distribution | Fiscal probity; fewer leakages | Excludes the genuinely poor; risks Article 21 |
| Leave it to dealers' discretion | Nobody turned away | Opaque; invites misuse and leakage |
| Suspend biometric checks altogether | Easy access | Reopens leakages; against national policy |
| Biometric first, with a recorded and verified fallback | Inclusion with accountability | Needs equipment, supervision and audits |
Recommended: option 4, "biometric first, never biometric only".
- Alternative authentication: iris scanners or OTP where available, better fingerprint devices for worn fingers, nominees for the elderly and disabled, and doorstep delivery for the bedridden.
- Exception register: the Union Department of Food and Public Distribution directed States in October 2017 that no eligible household be denied rations for lack of Aadhaar or failed authentication; where biometrics fail, rations are given on the Aadhaar card with the ration card, and each case is recorded in a separate exception register.
- Verification and audit: a panchayat functionary or vigilance committee member countersigns exceptions; monthly field checks flag shops with unusually many exceptions.
- Connectivity and updates: better antennae and network, distribution on days of good signal, and camps to update biometrics of children and the elderly.
- Grievance redress: the District Grievance Redressal Officer (Section 15) and vigilance committees (Section 29) under the NFSA, a helpline and social audits.
How to balance probity with empathy
- Errors are not equal: an exclusion error can mean a hungry family; an inclusion error means a small fiscal loss. Since the Supreme Court's orders in PUCL v UoI (2001 onwards) treated food as part of the right to life, the cost of system failure must not fall on the poor.
- The least advantaged first: Rawls's difference principle and Gandhi's talisman judge a policy by its effect on the weakest.
- Probity through accountability, not denial: leakages are better checked by audits and penalties on dishonest dealers than by turning the hungry away.
3. (b) Ethics of technology as a gatekeeper
- Benefits: technology cuts ghost and duplicate cards, creates audit trails, and enables portability through One Nation One Ration Card.
- Shifting the burden: when the machine fails, the poorest must prove their identity again and again; the risk moves from the state to the citizen.
- Procedural fairness: a rejection by an algorithm, with no human review or reasons, offends natural justice and dignity.
- Digital divide: remote, hilly and forest areas have weak networks and worn fingerprints, so uniform rules hurt them most.
- Privacy and data security: biometric data needs strong protection, purpose limitation and consent.
Vikas should ensure that no eligible person goes hungry because a machine failed, while every exception is recorded and audited. Welfare technology is ethical only when it serves dignity and inclusion, with human judgement and accountability built in.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking