
Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2025 · GS Paper IV
UPSC Mains 2025 GS 4 · Q2(b): model answer
General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Public Service Values and Probity.
Keeping the national security in mind, examine the ethical dilemmas related to controversies over environmental clearance of development projects in ecologically sensitive border areas in the country.
Syllabus: Public Service Values and Probity · Ethical concerns and dilemmas in government
National security vs ecologyEnvironmental clearanceHimalayan fragilitySustainable security
India's land frontiers in the Himalaya, from Ladakh to Arunachal Pradesh, and island frontiers such as Great Nicobar, are also among its most ecologically sensitive areas. The build-up of roads, airfields and dams across the Line of Actual Control has pushed India to fast-track strategic infrastructure, often with relaxed environmental clearance. This creates a genuine dilemma, because national security and ecological security both protect the nation and its people.
1. Context: controversies over clearances
- Exemptions by law: the Forest (Conservation) Amendment Act, 2023 exempts forest land within 100 km of international borders, the LoC or the LAC from prior clearance for strategic linear projects of national importance.
- Char Dham roads: in Ministry of Defence v Citizens for Green Doon (December 2021) the Supreme Court allowed wider roads on three strategic feeder roads, saying it could not second-guess the armed forces' needs, but set up an oversight committee under Justice A.K. Sikri.
- Great Nicobar project: a port, airport and township near the Malacca Strait, with strategic value but large forest diversion and concerns for coral reefs, turtle nesting and the Shompen, a PVTG.
- Siang Upper Multipurpose Project: the proposed 11,200 MW dam in Arunachal Pradesh, a water-security buffer against China's project on the lower Yarlung Tsangpo, is still at the pre-feasibility stage, its site not yet fixed, amid protests by sections of the Adi community over the loss of ancestral land and livelihoods (as of October 2026).
2. The ethical dilemmas
- Security vs sustainability: the state's first duty is to defend its territory, but Articles 48A and 51A(g) and intergenerational equity demand protection of fragile ecosystems. Joshimath's subsidence (2023) and the South Lhonak glacial-lake burst that destroyed the Teesta-III dam (October 2023) show that ecological damage also endangers strategic assets.
- Secrecy vs transparency: strategic projects need confidentiality, but secrecy weakens scrutiny, and "national security" can become a blanket shield.
- Speed vs due diligence: splitting the Char Dham project into segments under 100 km avoided a full Environmental Impact Assessment, ignoring cumulative impacts.
- National interest vs local rights: border communities hold rights under the Forest Rights Act, 2006 and customary laws, and are the eyes and ears of the frontier; alienating them weakens security itself.
- Utilitarian vs rights-based reasoning: the security of the many is weighed against irreversible losses borne by a few.
| Security argument | Ecological or ethical concern | Balancing measure |
|---|---|---|
| All-weather roads for troop movement | Landslides on young, unstable slopes | Slope stabilisation, tunnels, expert oversight |
| Exemption from forest clearance near borders | Loss of forests and biodiversity | Strategic EIA, compensatory afforestation, time-bound review |
| Confidentiality of defence projects | Weak public scrutiny | Closed-door appraisal by independent experts |
| Dams as water-security buffers | Submergence, seismic risk, displacement | Consent of communities, basin-wide impact studies |
3. Towards sustainable security
- Cumulative assessment: study the carrying capacity of whole valleys, even when individual projects are exempt.
- Independent expert oversight: confidential expert review, as by the Char Dham committee, reconciles secrecy with scrutiny.
- Better engineering: tunnels, scientific muck disposal and drainage make roads safer and more durable.
- Community partnership: consultation, fair compensation and local jobs, as the Vibrant Villages Programme intends, keep border people invested in security.
Security and ecology are not rivals: a landslide that cuts a border road is as much a threat as an adversary. The ethical path is sustainable security: build what is strategically necessary, in the least damaging way, with transparency to experts and respect for border communities.
The other part of Q2
- Q2(a)Carl von Clausewitz once said, “War is a diplomacy by other means.” Critically analyse the above statement in the present context of contemporary geo-political conflict.
10 marks · 150 words · Moral Thinkers and Philosophers · Moral thinkers and quotations
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking