
Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2025 · GS Paper IV
UPSC Mains 2025 GS 4 · Q12: model answer
General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.
Ashok is Divisional Commissioner of one of the border districts of the North East State. A few years back, Military has taken over the neighbouring country after overthrowing the elected civil government. Civil war situation is prevailing in the country especially in last two years. However, internal situation further deteriorated due to rebel groups taking over control of certain populated areas near own border. Due to intense fight between military and rebel groups, civilian casualties has increased manifold in recent past. In the meantime, in one night Ashok got information from the local police guarding the border check post that there are about 200-250 people mainly women and children trying to cross over to our side of the border. There are also about 10 soldiers with their weapons in military uniform part of this group who wants to cross over. Women and Children are also crying and begging for help. A few of them are injured and bleeding profusely need immediate medical care. Ashok tried to contact Home Secretary of the State but failed to do so due to poor connectivity mainly due to inclement weather.
(a) What are the options available with Ashok to cope with the situation?
(b) What are the ethical and legal dilemmas being faced by Ashok?
(c) Which of the options, do you think would be more appropriate for Ashok to adopt and why?
(d) In the present situation, what are the extra precautionary measures to be taken by the Border Guarding Police in dealing with soldiers in uniform?
Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies
Humanitarian dutyNon-refoulementBorder securityRule of law
At night, Ashok learns that 200–250 people, mostly women and children, some bleeding, are fleeing a civil war in the neighbouring country, with about ten armed soldiers in uniform among them. He cannot reach the Home Secretary. He must weigh humanitarian duty against national security and immigration law, on his own judgement and within minutes.
1. Stakeholders and legal position
- Stakeholders: the fleeing civilians and soldiers; local residents; border police and central forces; the State government, MHA and MEA; the neighbouring regime and rebels; and Ashok himself.
- Law: India is not party to the 1951 Refugee Convention and has no refugee law; entry is governed by the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025 (in force since September 2025). But Article 21 protects every person (NHRC v State of Arunachal Pradesh, 1996), and non-refoulement (not returning people to danger) is widely regarded as customary international law.
2. (a) Options available to Ashok
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Refuse entry to all | Apparent legal compliance; no immediate security risk | Inhuman; injured may die; against India's tradition |
| Admit everyone, including armed soldiers | Humane, quick | Serious security risk; arms enter the country |
| Admit civilians for aid; admit soldiers only after they disarm and keep them apart | Saves lives; controls risk | Strain on local resources; needs later central decision |
| Wait for instructions | Avoids personal responsibility | Delay costs lives; abdication of duty |
| Give first aid at the border without entry | Some relief | Inadequate for the badly injured; people stay exposed to fighting |
3. (b) Ethical and legal dilemmas
- Compassion vs security: saving lives against the risk that militants or weapons slip in.
- Law vs conscience: no refugee law versus the right to life and India's humanitarian tradition (Tibetans in 1959, East Pakistan refugees in 1971, Sri Lankan Tamils).
- Discretion vs hierarchy: acting without orders risks overstepping authority; waiting risks lives.
- Status of the soldiers: deserters seeking asylum or combatants? Returning them may expose them to punishment; keeping them may anger one side.
- Diplomacy vs human rights: ties with the neighbouring regime and local resource pressures versus protection of people in distress.
4. (c) The most appropriate option
Admit the civilians on humanitarian grounds, and the soldiers only after disarmament, under strict control.
- Immediate relief: a guarded holding area near the border; doctors for the injured; food, water and shelter; women police for women and children.
- Screening: search for weapons; record names, photographs and biometrics; prevent dispersal inland.
- Communication: reach the State and the MHA by police wireless, satellite phone or the central forces' network; record every decision with reasons.
- No push-back or deportation without the Central Government's decision.
Why: the right to life cannot wait; controlled, temporary entry balances humanity with security; it reflects Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam and Article 51(c); and recorded, good-faith action keeps Ashok within the rule of law.
5. (d) Extra precautions with soldiers in uniform
- Disarm at the border line: take custody of weapons, ammunition and explosives, list and seal them, and search each soldier.
- Keep them apart: separate from civilians, whom they could intimidate, and under armed guard.
- Verify identity: deserters, regular troops or disguised rebels? Joint questioning with intelligence agencies and central forces.
- Humane treatment: medical care and food; disarmed, they are out of combat and entitled to dignity under the spirit of the Geneva Conventions; by analogy with the rule for neutral states (Hague Convention V, 1907), intern them away from the conflict zone.
- No unilateral return: repatriation or asylum only by decision of the MHA and MEA, as when Myanmar soldiers who fled into Mizoram in 2023–24 took refuge with the Assam Rifles and were flown back home through official channels.
- Discipline: minimum force; no media access or contact with local armed groups.
Ashok's guide should be humanity with vigilance: open doors for the suffering, closed doors for arms, upholding both the right to life and national security.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking