Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
A wooden charkha, the spinning wheel of the freedom movement

Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2025 · GS Paper IV

UPSC Mains 2025 GS 4 · Q10: model answer

General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.

Q1020 marks250 words2025 · GS Paper IV

Rajesh is a Group A officer with nine years of service. He is posted as Administrative Officer in an Oil Public Sector undertaking. As an Administrative Officer he is responsible for managing and coordinating various administrative tasks to ensure smooth functioning of office. He also manages office supplies, equipment etc.

Rajesh is now sufficient senior and is expecting his next promotion in JAG (Junior Administrative Grade) in the next one or two years. He knows that promotion is based on examination of ACRs/Performance Appraisal of last few years (5 years or so) of an officer by a DPC (Departmental Promotion Committee) and an officer lacking requisite grading of ACRs may not be found fit for promotion. Consequences of losing promotion may entail financial and reputational loss and set-back for career progression. Though he also puts his best efforts in official discharge of his duties, yet he is unsure of assessment by his superior officer. He is now putting extra efforts so that he gets thumping report at the end of financial year.

As Administrative Officer, Rajesh is regularly interacting with his immediate boss, who is his reporting officer for writing his ACR. One day he calls Rajesh and wants him to buy computer-related stationery on priority from a particular vendor. Rajesh instructs his office to initiate action for procuring these items. During the day, the dealing Assistant brings an estimate of Rupees Thirty Five Lakhs covering all stationery items from the same vendor. It is noticed that as per delegated financial powers, as provided in the GFR (General Financial Rules) as applicable in that Organisation, expenditure for office items exceeding Rupees Thirty Lakhs requires sanction of the next higher authority (boss in the present case). Rajesh knows that immediate superior would expect all these purchases should be done at his level and may not appreciate such lack of initiative on his part. During discussions with office, he learns that common practice of splitting of expenditure (where large order is divided into a series of smaller ones) is followed to avoid obtaining sanction from higher authority. This practice is against the rules and may come to the adverse notice of Audit.

Rajesh is perturbed. He is unsure of taking decision in the matter.

(a) What are the options available with Rajesh in the above situation?
(b) What are the ethical issues involved in this case?
(c) Which would be the most appropriate option for Rajesh and why?

Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies

Model answer · free

Financial proprietySplitting of ordersIntegrity vs careerMoral courage

Rajesh's reporting officer wants computer stationery bought "on priority" from a particular vendor. The estimate of ₹35 lakh exceeds Rajesh's delegated power of ₹30 lakh, and the office's "common practice" is to split the order so that the boss's sanction is not needed, a practice the General Financial Rules expressly forbid and Audit would object to. With his promotion resting on the same officer's ACR, Rajesh must choose between career interest and financial propriety.

1. Stakeholders

  • Rajesh; his reporting officer; the named and other vendors; office staff; the PSU, its shareholders and taxpayers; Audit and the Chief Vigilance Officer.

2. (a) Options available to Rajesh

OptionProsCons
Split the order to stay within ₹30 lakhQuick; boss pleased; "common practice"Violates GFR; audit and vigilance risk; Rajesh is personally liable
Submit the full ₹35 lakh demand for the boss's sanction, through competitive procurementLawful, transparent, value for moneyBoss may see it as lack of initiative; risk to ACR
Delay and hope the matter fadesAvoids confrontationWork suffers; dishonest evasion
Report the boss to the CVO at onceStrong stand on integrityPremature; the vendor preference may be innocent
Buy only urgently needed items within his powers; process the restMeets urgent needsAcceptable only if the needs are truly separate; otherwise splitting in disguise
Options before Rajesh

3. (b) Ethical issues involved

  • Integrity vs self-interest: the fear of a poor ACR tempts Rajesh to bend rules for career gain.
  • Financial propriety and rule of law: splitting a demand to avoid a higher sanction defeats the delegation of financial powers, which exists to ensure scrutiny of large spending.
  • Favouritism: a boss naming one vendor for a ₹35 lakh purchase raises questions of fairness and possible conflict of interest; public procurement must be open and competitive, as CVC guidelines require.
  • Normalisation of deviance: a "common practice" does not make a wrong right; conformity and groupthink erode institutional integrity.
  • Power asymmetry: the ACR can become a tool of pressure; equally, the reporting officer has a duty to appraise fairly.
  • Accountability: Rajesh, not his boss, would sign the split orders and face the audit and vigilance consequences.

4. (c) The most appropriate option

Submit the full demand for sanction, through a transparent procurement process, while handling the boss with tact.

  • Verify and aggregate: confirm the genuine requirement and quantities, and treat the whole demand as one purchase.
  • Follow due procedure: obtain competitive prices through the Government e-Marketplace or a tender, as the rules applicable to the PSU require; if the named vendor offers the best value, it may win fairly.
  • Show initiative within the rules: prepare the file quickly, with a clear note explaining why the boss's sanction is needed and proposing a fast-track timeline to meet the urgency.
  • Speak to the boss personally: present the step as protecting him and the organisation from audit objections; most superiors respect a subordinate who saves them from trouble.
  • If pressure continues: ask for written instructions, record his view on file and, only if the irregularity persists, inform the next higher authority or the CVO.
  • Fix the system: suggest annual rate contracts and demand aggregation, ending the need to "split".
Verify genuine need; treat the demand as one
Competitive procurement (GeM or tender)
Speaking note: sanction of boss required
Personal, tactful explanation to the boss
Written orders and escalation only if pressed
Rajesh's course of action

Why this option:

  • Integrity is non-negotiable: a promotion earned by breaking rules is a liability that audit or vigilance may expose later.
  • Universalisability: if every officer split orders, delegation of powers would become meaningless.
  • The ACR system offers protection: entries must be communicated so that an officer can represent against unfair grading (Dev Dutt v UoI, 2008).
  • Means matter: Gandhi's insistence on pure means applies to small purchases as much as to great causes; courage and prudence, the virtues of a good officer, are both served.

A career built on integrity outlasts any single appraisal. By processing the purchase lawfully and tactfully, Rajesh shows that initiative within rules is the true mark of an efficient and trustworthy officer.

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149