Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
The new Parliament building in New Delhi, seen from above

Photo: New Parliament building, Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, GODL-India

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2025 · GS Paper II

UPSC Mains 2025 GS 2 · Q13: model answer

General Studies Paper II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations · Constitution and Polity.

Q1315 marks250 words2025 · GS Paper II

Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.

Syllabus: Constitution and Polity · Judiciary

Model answer · free

CollegiumJudges casesNJACSenate confirmation

Article 124(2) provides that the President appoints Supreme Court judges after "consultation" with the Chief Justice of India and such judges as he deems necessary. Through the Judges cases the Supreme Court read "consultation" to give the judiciary primacy, creating the collegium, a body not mentioned in the text. The USA follows a political model: presidential nomination and Senate confirmation (Article II, Section 2).

1. Evolution of the collegium

  • Executive phase: the supersessions of senior judges in appointing Chief Justices in 1973 and 1977 raised fears for independence.
  • First Judges case (S.P. Gupta, 1981): "consultation" did not mean concurrence, so the executive had primacy.
  • Second Judges case (1993): primacy for the CJI's opinion, formed with the two senior-most judges; a reiterated recommendation binds the government.
  • Third Judges case (1998, a Presidential Reference): a collegium of the CJI and the four senior-most judges for the Supreme Court.
  • NJAC and after: the 99th Amendment (2014) created a National Judicial Appointments Commission, but the Fourth Judges case (2015) struck it down 4:1; resolutions have been published online since 2017, and in 2023 the collegium published even the government's objections to names it reiterated.
  1. 1950 President appoints after consultation (Art 124(2))
  2. 1981 First Judges case: executive primacy
  3. 1993 Second Judges case: collegium born
  4. 1998 Third Judges case: CJI plus four judges
  5. 2014 99th Amendment creates the NJAC
  6. 2015 Fourth Judges case strikes down the NJAC
Evolution of judicial appointments in India

2. India's collegium

  • Advantages: it insulates appointments from political pressure, protects independence, draws on judges' close knowledge of candidates' work, and the seniority convention for the CJI has ended supersession.
  • Disadvantages: opacity and no written criteria; "judges appointing judges" without external accountability; charges of nepotism and poor diversity (few women, SC, ST and OBC judges); and, with the Memorandum of Procedure still not finalised, delays and friction as the government holds back names.

3. The US system

  • Advantages: democratic legitimacy through an elected President and Senate; public hearings by the Senate Judiciary Committee bring scrutiny; life tenure "during good behaviour" protects independence after appointment.
  • Disadvantages: openly ideological, partisan appointments; Merrick Garland (2016) was denied a hearing; since 2017 justices are confirmed by a simple majority after the filibuster was removed; and life tenure makes the Court's balance depend on deaths and strategic retirements.
BasisIndiaUSA
SourceArt 124(2), as read in the Judges casesArt II, Section 2
Who selectsCollegium of the CJI and four senior judgesPresident nominates
Legislature's roleNoneSenate confirms by simple majority
TransparencyLimited; resolutions published since 2017Public hearings
TenureRetire at 65Life tenure
Main riskOpacity, insularityPoliticisation
Appointing Supreme Court judges: India vs USA

4. Critical assessment

Neither model is ideal: India guards independence at some cost to transparency, while the USA secures democratic accountability at some cost to neutrality.

India needs a transparent collegium: a finalised Memorandum of Procedure with objective criteria, a permanent secretariat, time limits for both the collegium and the government, and attention to diversity, so that judicial independence commands public confidence.

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149