Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
A wooden charkha, the spinning wheel of the freedom movement

Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2024 · GS Paper IV

UPSC Mains 2024 GS 4 · Q9: model answer

General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.

Q920 marks250 words2024 · GS Paper IV

With multipronged strategy of the Central and State Governments specially in the last few years, the naxalite problem has been resolved to a large extent in the affected states of the country. However, there are a few pockets in certain states where naxalite problem still persists, mainly due to involvement of foreign countries. Rohit is posted as SP (Special Operations) for the last one year, in one of the districts which is still affected by the naxalite problem. The district administration has taken a lot of developmental works in the recent past in the naxalite affected areas to win the hearts and minds of the people. Over a period of time, Rohit has established an excellent intelligence network to get the real time information regarding the movement of naxalite cadre. To instill confidence in the public and have moral ascendancy over the naxalites, a number of cordons and search operations are being conducted by the police. Rohit, who himself was leading one of the contingents got a message through his intelligence source that about ten hard core naxalites were hiding in a particular village with sophisticated weapons. Without wasting any time, Rohit reached the target village with his team and laid out a foolproof cordon and started carrying out a systematic search. During the search, his team managed to overpower all the naxalites along with their automatic weapons. However, in the meantime, more than five hundred tribal women surrounded the village and started marching towards the target house. They were shouting and demanding the immediate release of insurgents since they are their protectors and saviours. The situation on the ground was becoming very critical as the tribal women were extremely agitated and aggressive. Rohit tried to contact his superior officer, IG (Special Operations) of the state on the radio set and on mobile phone, but failed to do so due to poor connectivity. Rohit was in great dilemma since out of the naxalites apprehended, two were not only hard core top insurgents with prize money of ₹ ten lakhs on their heads, but were also involved in a recent ambush on the security forces. However, if he did not release the naxalites, the situation could get out of control since the tribal women were aggressively charging towards them. In that case, to control the situation Rohit might have to resort to firing which may lead to valuable loss of lives of civilians and would further complicate the situation.

(a) What are the options available with Rohit to cope with the situation?
(b) What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by Rohit?
(c) Which of the options, do you think, would be more appropriate for Rohit to adopt and why?
(d) In the present situation, what are the extra precautionary measures to be taken by the police in dealing with women protesters?

Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies

Model answer · free

Rule of law vs protection of lifeMinimum forceMoral courageGender-sensitive policing

Left Wing Extremism has been sharply reduced: on 30 March 2026 the Home Minister told the Lok Sabha that Naxalism had been "wiped out" from the country. Residual pockets like Rohit's district show why consolidation matters. Rohit has captured ten armed Naxalites, two of them top leaders involved in an ambush, but over 500 agitated tribal women are advancing. Cut off from his superior, he must reconcile the rule of law with the protection of life.

1. Stakeholders

  • Rohit and his team; the captured Naxalites, who are accused persons with legal rights; the tribal women and villagers; the security personnel attacked in the ambush and their families; the IG and the State; and the people of the district, whose trust in development work is at stake.

2. (a) Options available to Rohit

OptionProsCons
Release the NaxalitesAvoids immediate clashSurrenders the rule of law; demoralises forces; rewards mob pressure; injustice to ambush victims
Open fire to disperse the crowdRetains custodyCivilian deaths; alienation; undoes hearts-and-minds work; unlawful against unarmed women
Hold firm, negotiate and seek reinforcementsBuys time; avoids bloodshedCrowd may turn violent; needs restraint
Move detainees out by another route while engaging the crowdKeeps custody without forceRisky; depends on terrain and team
Release minor cadres, keep the leadersPartial de-escalationArbitrary; still yields to pressure
Options before Rohit

3. (b) Ethical dilemmas

  • Rule of law versus right to life: releasing wanted insurgents betrays justice; firing on civilians betrays the duty to protect.
  • Justice for colleagues attacked in the ambush versus compassion for misled villagers.
  • Ends versus means: a lawful goal (custody) pursued by disproportionate means loses its legitimacy.
  • Responsibility without guidance: with no contact with his superior, Rohit must decide alone and answer for it.
  • Short-term order versus long-term trust: bloodshed would undo years of development work and hand the Naxalites a propaganda victory.

4. (c) The most appropriate course: hold firm, de-escalate, secure the detainees

  • No release under pressure: the apprehended face grave charges; yielding would reward coercion and endanger future operations.
  • No firing on unarmed women: force only as a last resort, graduated and minimal.
  • Secure and separate: a small team moves the detainees, especially the two leaders, to a protected position or out by an alternative route; the rest form a cordon without provoking the crowd.
  • Dialogue: through women personnel and trusted local figures such as elders, panchayat members or teachers, explain that the detainees will be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours (Article 22(2)), will get a fair trial and that families may meet them lawfully.
  • Communication and record: relay a message to the nearest post for reinforcements, including women police; log every decision with reasons.

Why: it upholds both law and life (proportionality); refuses to sacrifice innocent civilians as a means (Kant); avoids the worst outcomes (consequentialism); and combines courage with prudence.

5. (d) Precautions with women protesters

  • Women police should handle women protesters; a woman may be searched only by a woman and, except in exceptional cases with a magistrate's prior permission, not arrested between sunset and sunrise (BNSS, as earlier the CrPC).
  • Non-lethal methods: barricades and warnings in the local language; no lathi charge or firing on women.
  • Dignity and care: no abusive language; medical aid for the injured; special care for elderly and pregnant women and children.
  • Video-record the operation for accountability and to counter false narratives.
  • Stay alert: armed cadres may use the crowd as a shield, but not every woman should be treated as hostile.
  • Follow-up: dialogue through women's self-help groups and anganwadi workers to address grievances.

Rohit's test is to be firm on law, gentle with people. Holding the insurgents without shedding civilian blood upholds both justice and humanity; the moral ascendancy the police seek is won by restraint, not by firing.

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149