
Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2024 · GS Paper IV
UPSC Mains 2024 GS 4 · Q11: model answer
General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.
With the summer heat being exceptionally severe this year, the district has been facing severe water shortage. The District Collector has been mobilizing his subordinate officials to conserve the remaining water reserves for preventing the district from plunging into acute drinking water crisis. Along with an awareness campaign for conserving water, strict measures have been taken for stopping the over-exploitation of ground-water. Vigilance teams have been deployed to tour the villages and find the farmers who are drawing water from deep borewells or from the river reservoir for irrigation. The farmers are agitated by such action. A delegation of farmers meets the District Collector with their issues and complains that while they are not being allowed to irrigate their crops, big industries located near the river are drawing huge amounts of water through deep borewells for their industrial processes. The farmers allege that their administration is anti-farmer and corrupt, being bribed by the industry. The district needs to placate the farmers as they are threatening to go on a prolonged protest. At the same time, the District Collector has to deal with the water crisis. The industry cannot be closed as this would result in a large number of workers being unemployed.
(a) Discuss all options available to the District Collector as a District Magistrate.
(b) What suitable actions can be taken in view of mutually compatible interests of the stakeholders?
(c) What are the potential administrative and ethical dilemmas for the District Collector?
Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies
Water justiceCompeting needsImpartialitySustainable groundwater use
In a severe summer, the District Collector must protect drinking water, which the National Water Policy (2012) places first, while balancing farmers' livelihoods, industrial jobs and allegations of corruption. Clean water is part of the right to life under Article 21 (Subhash Kumar v State of Bihar, 1991). The core ethical test is fairness: restrictions must fall on all users and be seen to do so, not only on the weakest.
1. Stakeholders
- Farmers; industries and their workers; households, especially poor families and the women who fetch water; vigilance teams and district officials; the State government and groundwater regulators; panchayats; and the river and aquifers themselves, on which future generations depend.
2. (a) Options available to the District Magistrate
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Continue curbs on farmers only | Saves water quickly | Unfair; protests; crop loss; confirms bias allegation |
| Close the industries | Saves large volumes | Mass unemployment; economic loss; legally contestable |
| Lift curbs to placate farmers | Ends the protest | Drinking-water crisis; deeper depletion |
| Equitable rationing for all users, with verification of industrial extraction (chosen) | Fair, lawful, sustainable | Needs firm enforcement and resources |
- Legal tools: prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the BNSS where needed; powers as chair of the District Disaster Management Authority (Disaster Management Act, 2005) if a drought is declared; enforcement of the Central Ground Water Authority's 2020 guidelines and State groundwater law, which require permission for extraction by industry.
3. (b) Actions that serve mutually compatible interests
- Clear priorities: drinking water first, then life-saving irrigation for standing crops, then industry with mandatory cuts, announced publicly.
- Verify the farmers' complaint: inspect industrial borewells, meters and permissions; seal illegal borewells; levy environmental compensation; require water recycling and reuse of treated sewage.
- Shared sacrifice: pro-rata cuts for all bulk users; industries fund tanker supply and recharge structures in nearby villages through CSR, so jobs continue while burdens are shared.
- Relief for farmers: advisories on less water-intensive crops, micro-irrigation under PMKSY's Per Drop More Crop, crop insurance and drought relief where eligible, and wage work on tank desilting and recharge.
- Transparency: a joint monitoring committee of farmers, industry and officials; publication of the district's water budget and inspection reports; a grievance cell.
- Long term: community water budgeting on the lines of the Atal Bhujal Yojana, "Catch the Rain" recharge, and industrial water audits.
4. (c) Administrative and ethical dilemmas
- Administrative: drinking water versus livelihoods; limits on the Collector's powers over industries regulated by the CGWA and pollution control boards; weak enforcement capacity; and the law-and-order risk of a prolonged protest.
- Ethical: equity versus efficiency; jobs versus water justice; firmness of law versus compassion for distressed farmers; and present use versus the needs of future generations.
- Integrity: the allegation of bribery must be inquired into, not dismissed; if officials have colluded with industry, disciplinary and criminal action must follow, since perceived bias destroys the authority needed to enforce cuts.
Why this course: it applies the public trust doctrine (M.C. Mehta v Kamal Nath, 1997), under which the state holds natural resources as trustee for all; it protects the least advantaged first (Rawls); and it maximises welfare by saving both water and jobs.
In scarcity, fairness is the first resource. Transparent, shared rationing with drinking water first can save both the district's water and the people's trust in administration.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking