Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
The new Parliament building in New Delhi, seen from above

Photo: New Parliament building, Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, GODL-India

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2023 · GS Paper II

UPSC Mains 2023 GS 2 · Q17: model answer

General Studies Paper II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations · Social Justice.

Q1715 marks250 words2023 · GS Paper II

“Development and welfare schemes for the vulnerable, by its nature, are discriminatory in approach.” Do you agree? Give reasons for your answer.

Syllabus: Social Justice · Welfare schemes and vulnerable sections

Model answer · free

Protective discriminationReasonable classificationSubstantive equalityTargeting

Welfare and development schemes for the vulnerable (Scheduled Castes and Tribes, backward classes, women, minorities, persons with disabilities and the poor) necessarily single out some people for benefits. In that sense they differentiate. But the Constitution distinguishes unfair discrimination from reasonable classification under Article 14 and from protective discrimination under Articles 15(3)–(6), 16(4) and 46, which pursue substantive equality. I therefore agree only partly: such schemes are differential by nature, but not discriminatory in the constitutional sense.

1. Why they can appear discriminatory

  • Built-in differentiation: post-matric scholarships for SC students, Stand-Up India loans for SC, ST and women entrepreneurs, and PM-JANMAN for Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups exclude others by design.
  • Errors of targeting: lists based on surveys such as the SECC 2011 leave out some of the poor (exclusion errors) and include some of the better-off (inclusion errors).
  • Capture within groups: better-off families corner benefits, which is why the creamy layer applies to OBCs (Indra Sawhney, 1992) and in State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh (2024) a seven-judge bench allowed States to sub-classify SCs and STs.
  • Identity versus need: poor families outside the targeted groups feel left out, a concern behind the EWS quota of the 103rd Amendment, upheld in Janhit Abhiyan (2022).
  • Barriers in delivery: documents and biometric checks can exclude the most vulnerable, and means-testing can stigmatise.

2. Why they are not discriminatory in substance

  • Reasonable classification: Article 14 permits classification founded on an intelligible differentia that has a rational nexus with the object of the law (Anwar Ali Sarkar, 1952).
  • Equality as fairness: in N.M. Thomas (1976) the Supreme Court held that reservation is a facet of equality, not an exception to it; treating unequals equally only perpetuates inequality.
  • Constitutional mandate: Article 46 directs the State to promote the educational and economic interests of the weaker sections, and Article 38 to minimise inequalities; Dr Ambedkar saw social and economic democracy as the base of political democracy.
  • Philosophy: John Rawls's difference principle accepts inequalities that benefit the least advantaged.
  • Results: targeted programmes helped cut multidimensional poverty from 29.17% (2013-14) to 11.28% (2022-23) (NITI Aayog) and brought women and Dalits into local government.
BasisDiscriminationProtective discrimination
PurposeTo exclude or demeanTo correct disadvantage
ClassificationArbitraryIntelligible differentia with a rational nexus
Constitutional statusForbidden (Arts 14, 15(1), 16(2))Enabled (Arts 15(3)–(6), 16(4), 46)
ExampleDenial of entry on grounds of casteScholarships for SC students
EffectDeepens inequalityMoves towards substantive equality
Discrimination vs protective discrimination

3. Making welfare fairer

  • A universal floor with targeted top-ups: universal basic services, such as PM-JAY health cover for everyone aged 70 and above (2024), with extra support for the most deprived.
  • Better data: a dynamic social registry, periodic revision of beneficiary lists and data-based sub-classification.
  • Graduation: exit criteria such as the creamy layer, and a focus on capabilities so that beneficiaries move out of dependence.
  • Accountability: social audits and grievance redress to catch exclusion errors early.
Identify need with reliable data
Target the deprived, above a universal floor
Deliver with assisted access
Audit exclusion and inclusion errors
Graduate the better-off out of benefits
Designing fair welfare

Welfare schemes treat people differently in order to treat them as equals. The real problem is not their differential nature but poor targeting and capture; better design can make them instruments of social justice rather than division.

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149