Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
A wooden charkha, the spinning wheel of the freedom movement

Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2022 · GS Paper IV

UPSC Mains 2022 GS 4 · Q12: model answer

General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.

Q1220 marks250 words2022 · GS Paper IV

You are appointed as an officer heading the section in Environment Pollution Control Board to ensure compliance and its follow-up. In that region, there were large number of small and medium industries which had been granted clearance. You learnt that these industries provide employment to many migrant workers. Most of the industrial units have got environmental clearance certificate in their possession. The environmental clearance seeks to curb industries and projects that supposedly hamper environment and living species in the region. But in practice, most of these units remain to be polluting units in several ways like air, water and soil pollution. As such, local people encountered persistent health problems.

It was confirmed that majority of the industries were violating environmental compliance. You issued notice to all the industrial units to apply for fresh environmental clearance certificate from the competent authority. However, your action met with hostile response from a section of the industrial units, other vested interest persons and a section of the local politicians. The workers also became very hostile to you as they felt that your action would lead to the closure of these industrial units, and the resultant unemployment will lead to insecurity and uncertainty in their livelihood. Many owners of the industries approached you with the plea that you should not initiate harsh action as it would compel them to close their units, and cause huge financial loss, shortage of their products in the market. These would obviously add to the sufferings of the labourers and the consumers alike. The labour union also sent you representation requesting against the closure of the units. You simultaneously started receiving threats from unknown corners. You however received supports from some of your colleagues, who advised you to act freely to ensure environmental compliance. Local NGOs also came to your support and they demanded the closure of the polluting units immediately.

(a) What are the options available to you under the given situation?
(b) Critically examine the options listed by you.
(c) What type of mechanism would you suggest to ensure environmental compliance?
(d) What are the ethical dilemmas you faced in exercising your option?

Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies

Model answer · free

Environmental complianceRight to healthLivelihoodsPolluter pays

As head of the compliance section of the Pollution Control Board, I have found that most small and medium units, though holding clearances, pollute air, water and soil, causing persistent health problems for local people. Enforcement has provoked owners, workers, a section of politicians and anonymous threats, while NGOs demand immediate closure. The case sets the right to a healthy environment (Article 21; Subhash Kumar, 1991) against the right to livelihood of migrant workers, also part of Article 21 (Olga Tellis, 1985).

Stakeholders: residents, workers, owners, consumers, politicians, NGOs, my colleagues and future generations.

1. (a) Options available and (b) their critical examination

OptionMeritsDemerits
Withdraw the notices; status quoJobs and production continue; no conflictHealth damage continues; dereliction of duty; unlawful
Close all violating units at once (NGOs' demand)Pollution stops quickly; strong deterrentMass unemployment; shortages; litigation; unfair to units able to comply
Graded, time-bound enforcement (preferred)Protects health and jobs; due process; legally soundNeeds monitoring capacity; some pollution during transition
Act selectively under political pressureAvoids conflict with the powerfulArbitrary and discriminatory (Article 14); invites corruption
Seek a transfer because of threatsPersonal safetyEscapism; violators win
Options before the compliance officer
  • The preferred course in practice: classify units by pollution potential (CPCB's red, orange, green and white categories) and by compliance; after a hearing, close at once only units causing serious harm, using Section 33A of the Water Act, 1974 and Section 31A of the Air Act, 1981; give the rest a time-bound action plan backed by bank guarantees; and levy environmental compensation on the polluter-pays principle (Vellore Citizens, 1996).
  • Protect people: health camps and safe drinking water for affected villages; with the Labour Department, secure workers' dues and help them move to compliant units.
  • Handle pressure: report threats in writing to the police and seniors, keep every decision reasoned and recorded, and explain to workers that the goal is compliance, not closure.

2. (c) Mechanism to ensure environmental compliance

Consent with clearconditionsContinuous onlinemonitoringInspections andthird-party auditsGraded penaltiesand directionsPublic disclosureof complianceReview and renewalof consentEnvironmentalcompliance cycle
  • Real-time monitoring: online continuous emission and effluent monitoring, which CPCB has required of 17 categories of highly polluting industries since 2014, linked to the Board's servers, with drones and satellite imagery for hidden discharges.
  • Shared infrastructure: common effluent treatment plants and cleaner technology for small and medium clusters, with credit and subsidies.
  • Deterrent penalties: environmental compensation scaled to the harm and to repeat violations; since the Jan Vishwas Act, 2023 replaced imprisonment with monetary penalties for many violations of the Air and Environment (Protection) Acts, the amounts must be large enough to deter.
  • Transparency and participation: compliance status and monitoring data published online, complaint apps, local vigilance committees and partnerships with NGOs.
  • Capable, independent regulators: enough staff and laboratories, freedom from political pressure, and recourse to the National Green Tribunal (2010).

3. (d) Ethical dilemmas in exercising the option

  • Environment versus livelihood: the health of residents versus the jobs of migrant workers.
  • Rule of law versus pragmatism: strict enforcement versus a gradual, negotiated path.
  • Present versus future: today's production versus intergenerational equity and sustainable development.
  • Duty versus personal safety: acting despite threats versus protecting oneself and one's family.
  • Independence versus pressure: impartial regulation versus political and industry influence, and the NGOs' demand for instant closure.

Compliance and livelihoods are not enemies. Graded, transparent enforcement, backed by technology, shared treatment plants and protection for workers, can deliver clean air and water as well as jobs, making sustainable development real.

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149