
Photo: Konark Sun Temple wheel, Joydeep, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2022 · GS Paper I
UPSC Mains 2022 GS 1 · Q19: model answer
General Studies Paper I: Indian Heritage and Culture, History and Geography of the World and Society · Indian Society.
Are tolerance, assimilation and pluralism the key elements in the making of an Indian form of secularism? Justify your answer.
Syllabus: Indian Society · Diversity, communalism and regionalism
Sarva dharma sambhavaPrincipled distancePluralismConstitutional secularism
Western secularism, as in France's laïcité, keeps religion and state apart. Indian secularism means equal respect for all religions (sarva dharma sambhava) with a "principled distance" (Rajeev Bhargava) that lets the state intervene for reform and equality. "Secular" entered the Preamble through the 42nd Amendment (1976); S.R. Bommai (1994) made secularism a basic feature, and Dr Balram Singh (2024) upheld its insertion. Tolerance, assimilation and pluralism are its roots, not its whole content.
1. Tolerance: the historical root
- Ashoka: Rock Edict XII urges restraint in speech and honour to other sects, warning that one who disparages others' sects harms his own.
- Akbar: sulh-i-kul (peace with all), the abolition of jizya (1564) and inter-faith debates in the Ibadat Khana (1575).
- Bhakti and Sufi saints: Kabir, Guru Nanak and Nizamuddin Auliya preached the unity of the divine across faiths.
- Gandhi: equal regard for all religions (sarva dharma sama bhava), practised in his inter-faith prayer meetings.
2. Assimilation: synthesis, not uniformity
- Composite culture: India absorbed Greeks, Shakas, Kushanas, Parsis, Jews, Syrian Christians, Turks and Afghans; Indo-Islamic architecture, Hindustani music, Urdu and the Ganga-Jamuni tehzeeb are its fruits, and Dara Shikoh's Majma-ul-Bahrain sought the meeting of Hindu and Islamic mysticism.
- Not forced assimilation: unlike France, which banned conspicuous religious symbols in state schools (2004), India protects the distinct language, script and culture of minorities (Articles 29–30). Assimilation here means mutual borrowing, not merger into a majority culture.
3. Pluralism: the constitutional core
- Freedoms: Articles 25–28 guarantee freedom of conscience, practice and propagation, autonomy for religious denominations, no tax to promote any religion and no religious instruction in wholly state-funded schools.
- Group rights: minorities may establish and administer educational institutions (Article 30), and personal laws coexist, with a uniform civil code left as a directive (Article 44).
- Judicial reading: in S.R. Bommai the Court held that the State has no religion of its own; in Aruna Roy (2002) it read secularism as sarva dharma sambhava.
4. Beyond the three: equality and reform
- Principled distance: the State abolished untouchability (Article 17), allowed laws opening Hindu temples to all castes (Article 25(2)(b)), and instant triple talaq was struck down (Shayara Bano, 2017).
- Equal citizenship: Articles 14–16 forbid discrimination on grounds of religion.
- Challenges: communal violence, hate speech and the use of religion in politics show that tolerance alone, merely putting up with others, is not enough; mutual respect and fraternity are needed.
| Feature | Western (France, USA) | Indian |
|---|---|---|
| State and religion | Strict separation | Principled distance; equal respect |
| Religion and the state | Kept out of state institutions | State recognises and accommodates all faiths |
| Reform | State stays out of religious practice | State may intervene for equality |
| Minorities | Mainly individual rights | Individual and group rights (Art. 29–30) |
| Personal law | One civil law | Coexisting personal laws; Art. 44 a directive |
- 3rd century BCE Ashoka's Rock Edict XII: respect for all sects
- 1575 Akbar's Ibadat Khana debates
- 1950 Constitution: Articles 14–16 and 25–30
- 1976 42nd Amendment adds "secular" to the Preamble
- 1994 S.R. Bommai: secularism a basic feature
- 2024 Balram Singh: insertion of "secular" upheld
Yes, tolerance, assimilation (as synthesis) and pluralism are the civilisational foundations of Indian secularism, but the constitutional model adds equality, minority rights and reform. Strengthening fraternity, as the Preamble asks, is the best guarantee of this distinctively Indian secularism.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking