
Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2021 · GS Paper IV
UPSC Mains 2021 GS 4 · Q9: model answer
General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.
An elevated corridor is being constructed to reduce traffic congestion in the capital of a particular state. You have been selected as project manager of this prestigious project on your professional competence and experience. The deadline is to complete the project in next two years by 30 June, 2021, since this project is to be inaugurated by the Chief Minister before the elections are announced in the second week of July 2021. While carrying out the surprise inspection by inspecting team, a minor crack was noticed in one of the piers of the elevated corridor possibly due to poor material used. You immediately informed the chief engineer and stopped further work. It was assessed by you that minimum three piers of the elevated corridor have to be demolished and reconstructed. But this process will delay the project minimum by four to six months. But the chief engineer overruled the observation of inspecting team on the ground that it was a minor crack which will not in any way impact the strength and durability of the bridge. He ordered you to overlook the observation of inspecting team and continue working with same speed and tempo. He informed you that the minister does not want any delay as he wants the Chief Minister to inaugurate the elevated corridor before the elections are declared. Also informed you that the contractor is far relative of the minister and he wants him to finish the project. He also gave you hint that your further promotion as additional chief engineer is under consideration with the ministry. However, you strongly felt that the minor crack in the pier of the elevated corridor will adversely affect the health and life of the bridge and therefore it will be very dangerous not to repair the elevated corridor.
(a) Under the given conditions, what are the options available to you as a project manager?
(b) What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by the project manager?
(c) What are the professional challenges likely to be faced by the project manager and his response to overcome such challenges?
(d) What can be the consequences of overlooking the observation raised by the inspecting team?
Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies
Public safetyProfessional integrityPolitical pressureConflict of interest
As project manager, I have found a crack in a pier, possibly caused by poor material, and judge that at least three piers must be rebuilt, delaying the project by four to six months. The chief engineer orders me to ignore it to meet the Chief Minister's pre-election inauguration, mentions that the contractor is the minister's relative, and hints at my promotion. The case pits public safety and professional integrity against a political deadline and career interest.
1. Stakeholders
- Future commuters and residents near the corridor; the State government, the minister and the Chief Minister; the chief engineer; the contractor; the inspecting team; taxpayers; the engineering profession; and myself.
2. (a) Options available
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Obey and continue at full speed | Deadline met; promotion likely | Risk to lives; criminal liability; complicity in favouritism |
| Stop work and go to the media | Draws attention to the danger | Breach of conduct rules; politicises a technical issue |
| Record dissent; seek independent testing; propose a fast-track repair; escalate (chosen) | Safety decided on evidence; delay minimised | Superiors' displeasure; promotion at risk |
| Resign or seek a transfer | Personal integrity preserved | Danger remains; a successor may comply |
3. (b) Ethical dilemmas
- Public safety versus political deadline: lives of future users against the inauguration date.
- Professional judgement versus obedience: my duty as an engineer against hierarchical discipline.
- Career versus integrity: the hinted promotion is an inducement to stay silent.
- Public interest versus nepotism: the contractor's link to the minister creates a conflict of interest.
- Uncertainty: the crack may truly be minor, but when lives are at stake the precautionary principle requires proof of safety, not proof of danger.
4. (c) Professional challenges and my response
- Pressure and possible victimisation: I will put the inspecting team's findings and my assessment in writing and ask for written orders, since oral instructions should be recorded (T.S.R. Subramanian v UoI, 2013).
- Technical disagreement with a superior: I will propose independent third-party tests (non-destructive testing, load tests and a structural audit by an IIT or NIT), so that the decision rests on evidence, not rank.
- Delay and cost: I will keep the affected piers on hold, continue work on the unaffected spans, add shifts and use precast elements to cut the delay; recover the cost of rebuilding from the contractor under the contract's quality and defect clauses; and give the government a realistic revised date.
- Contractor's influence: I will not certify defective work or release payment for it; if pressure continues, I will inform the Secretary and, as a last resort, the vigilance authorities.
- Isolation: I will work closely with the inspecting team and the quality-control wing, so that the stand is institutional, not personal.
5. (d) Consequences of overlooking the observation
- Loss of life: a weakened pier may fail under traffic loads; the collapse of an under-construction flyover in Varanasi (May 2018) killed 18 people, and the Morbi suspension-bridge collapse (October 2022) killed 135.
- Legal liability: everyone who knowingly ignored the defect, including me, could face prosecution for causing death by negligence (Section 106 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita) and departmental action.
- Financial loss: repairing or rebuilding a finished corridor costs far more than fixing it now, besides compensation and litigation.
- Loss of trust: in public works, in the government and in the engineering profession; contractors learn that poor work goes unpunished.
Safety is non-negotiable. A corridor inaugurated on time but unsafe would be a monument to failure; by insisting on evidence, offering solutions and resisting pressure with integrity, the project manager serves both the public and, in the end, the government itself.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking