
Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2020 · GS Paper IV
UPSC Mains 2020 GS 4 · Q7: model answer
General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.
Rajesh Kumar is a senior public servant, with a reputation of honesty and forthrightness, currently posted in the Finance Ministry as Head of the Budget Division. His department is presently busy in organising the budgetary support to the states, four of which are due to go to the polls within the financial year.
This year’s annual budget had allotted ₹8300 crores for National Housing Scheme (NHS), a centrally sponsored social housing scheme for the weaker sections of society. ₹775 crores have been drawn for NHS till June.
The Ministry of Commerce had long been pursuing a case for setting up a Special Economic Zone (SEZ) in a southern state to boost exports. After two years of detailed discussions between the centre and state, the Union Cabinet approved the project in August. Process was initiated to acquire the necessary land.
Eighteen months ago a leading Public Sector Unit (PSU) had projected the need for setting up a large natural gas processing plant in a northern state for the regional gas grid. The required land is already in possession of the PSU. The gas grid is an essential component of the national energy security strategy. After three rounds of global bidding the project was allotted to an MNC, M/s XYZ Hydrocarbons. The first tranche of payment to the MNC is scheduled to be made in December.
Finance Ministry was asked for a timely allocation of an additional ₹6000 crores for these two developmental projects. It was decided to recommend re-appropriation of this entire amount from the NHS allocation. The file was forwarded to Budget Department for their comments and further processing. On studying the case file, Rajesh Kumar realized that this re-appropriation may cause inordinate delay in the execution of NHS, a project much publicized in the rallies of senior politicians. Correspondingly, non-availability of finances would cause financial loss in the SEZ and national embarrassment due to delayed payment in an international project.
Rajesh Kumar discussed the matter with his seniors. He was conveyed that this politically sensitive situation needs to be processed immediately. Rajesh Kumar realized that diversion of funds from NHS could raise difficult questions for the government in the Parliament.
Discuss the following with reference to this case:
(a) Ethical issues involved in re-appropriation of funds from a welfare project to the developmental projects.
(b) Given the need for proper utilization of public funds, discuss the options available to Rajesh Kumar. Is resigning a worthy option?
Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies
Financial proprietyWelfare vs developmentFrank adviceParliamentary accountability
Rajesh Kumar must comment on a proposal to divert ₹6,000 crore from the National Housing Scheme (NHS), which has ₹8,300 crore allotted and only ₹775 crore drawn by June, to an SEZ and a gas-processing plant vital to energy security. Diverting 72% of a welfare allocation would leave just ₹1,525 crore for nine months. The case tests financial propriety, fairness to the weaker sections and a civil servant's duty to give frank and fearless advice under pressure.
Stakeholders: poor households awaiting NHS houses and the States implementing it; the Ministries of Commerce and Petroleum, the PSU and M/s XYZ Hydrocarbons; exporters and future SEZ workers; Parliament and taxpayers; the government's credibility; and Rajesh Kumar himself.
1. (a) Ethical issues in re-appropriating funds from welfare to development
- Equity versus efficiency: development projects promise growth, but here the poor bear the cost; Rawls' difference principle and the State's duty towards the weaker sections (Article 46) favour protecting them, and the right to shelter is part of Article 21 (Chameli Singh, 1996).
- Legality and legislative intent: Parliament voted ₹8,300 crore for NHS. Re-appropriation is allowed only between units within the same grant; if NHS and the two projects fall under different ministries' grants, as is usual, moving the money needs Parliament's approval through supplementary demands (Article 115). Doing it quietly would weaken parliamentary accountability.
- Financial propriety: the General Financial Rules, 2017 demand the care a person of ordinary prudence takes with his own money; the poor should not pay for a failure to budget for approved projects.
- Political neutrality: elections in four States and the scheme's publicity in rallies should neither drive nor block the decision.
- Honouring commitments: delaying payment to an MNC chosen by global bidding would hurt energy security and India's credibility.
2. (b) Options available to Rajesh Kumar
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Endorse the proposal as it stands | Quick; pleases seniors; projects proceed | May be irregular; stalls NHS; questions in Parliament; abdicates advisory duty |
| Reject it outright | Protects NHS | SEZ losses and payment default; he may simply be overruled |
| Recommend a lawful, balanced package (preferred) | Meets urgent needs; protects NHS; respects Parliament | More work; may displease seniors who want speed |
| Seek transfer or leave | Avoids conflict | Evades responsibility; the file moves anyway |
| Resign | Clear conscience | Changes nothing; the system loses an honest officer |
3. Chosen course of action and why
- Assess real needs: estimate NHS's likely spending this year from the States' readiness and past trends; release only genuine savings, and protect sanctioned instalments to the States.
- Find lawful alternatives: where the rules allow, an advance from the Contingency Fund of India (Article 267; corpus ₹30,000 crore) for the December payment, recouped through supplementary demands in the winter session; savings from slow-moving heads; phased payment for SEZ land.
- Record a reasoned note: set out the facts, rules, risks and options on file and discuss them with his seniors; the competent authority decides.
- Implement the lawful decision: if overruled on a lawful policy choice, he implements it, with his advice on record; for anything unlawful, he seeks written orders and does not act against the rules.
- Why: it serves both development and welfare, keeps Parliament informed, and combines honest advice with neutrality.
Is resigning a worthy option? Not at this stage. The proposal is a policy choice, not a crime; his duty is to advise frankly and let the elected government decide. Resigning would be an escape that leaves the poor and the process without an honest voice. It becomes a matter of conscience only if he is repeatedly pressed to act illegally and every lawful channel has failed.
Rajesh Kumar should serve both development and welfare, finding lawful money for urgent projects without silently sacrificing the poor. Courage within the system honours public trust better than walking away from it.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking