
Photo: Charkha, Janak Bhatta, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2020 · GS Paper IV
UPSC Mains 2020 GS 4 · Q10: model answer
General Studies Paper IV: Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude · Case Studies.
You are a municipal commissioner of a large city, having the reputation of a very honest and upright officer. A huge multipurpose mall is under construction in your city in which a large number of daily wage earners are employed. One night, during monsoons, a big chunk of the roof collapsed causing instant death of four labourers including two minors. Many more were seriously injured requiring immediate medical attention. The mishap resulted in a big hue and cry, forcing the government to institute an enquiry.
Your preliminary enquiry has revealed a series of anomalies. The material used for the construction was of poor quality. Despite the approved building plans permitting only one basement, an additional basement has been constructed. This was overlooked during the periodic inspections by the building inspector of the municipal corporation. In your enquiry, you noticed that the construction of the mall was given the green signal despite encroaching on areas earmarked for a green belt and a slip road in the Zonal Master Plan of the city. The permission to construct the mall was accorded by the previous Municipal Commissioner who is not only your senior and well known to you professionally, but also a good friend.
Prima facie, the case appears to be of a widespread nexus between officials of the Municipal Corporation and the builders. Your colleagues are putting pressure on you to go slow in the enquiry. The builder, who is rich and influential, happens to be a close relative of a powerful minister in the state cabinet. The builder is persuading you to hush up the matter, promising you a fortune to do so. He also hinted that if this matter is not resolved at the earliest in his favour there is somebody in his office who is waiting to file a case against you under the POSH Act.
Discuss the ethical issues involved in the case. What are the options available to you in this situation? Explain your selected course of action.
Syllabus: Case Studies · Case studies
IntegrityConflict of interestRule of lawMoral courage
Four labourers, two of them minors, died when a mall's roof collapsed. My preliminary enquiry has found poor-quality material, an unauthorised second basement missed in inspections, and a permission, given by my predecessor (a senior and a friend), despite encroachment on a green belt and a slip road. Colleagues want me to go slow, and the builder, a relative of a powerful minister, offers a fortune and threatens a false complaint under the POSH Act. The case tests integrity, impartiality and moral courage.
Stakeholders: the dead workers' families and the injured; other workers and future users of the mall; citizens who lose the green belt and slip road; the builder and the minister; the building inspector, the former Commissioner and other officials; the Municipal Corporation and the government; and my family and I.
1. Ethical issues involved
- Right to life and safety: poor material and illegal construction cost lives (Article 21), and employing minors breaks the child-labour law.
- Integrity versus inducement: offering a bribe is itself an offence under Section 8 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, as amended in 2018.
- Friendship versus duty: my friendship with the former Commissioner is a conflict of interest that must be disclosed, never allowed to bend the enquiry.
- Esprit de corps versus accountability: colleagues' loyalty to one another cannot override loyalty to the public.
- Rule of law: the builder's political connections must not decide the outcome.
- Planning and environmental ethics: encroachment on a green belt and slip road harms the whole city.
- Misuse of a protective law: threatening a false POSH complaint abuses a law meant to protect women and amounts to intimidation.
2. Options available
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Accept the offer and hush up | Money; threats end | Crime; betrayal of the victims; more collapses later |
| Go slow; blame only the building inspector | Protects friend and colleagues | Cover-up; scapegoating; the nexus survives |
| Withdraw from the enquiry | Avoids conflict and danger | Escapism; the enquiry may be derailed |
| Fair, time-bound enquiry; report bribe and threat; disclose friendship (preferred) | Justice; deterrence; integrity intact | Hostility; transfer; a false complaint |
3. My course of action and why
- Victims first: treatment for the injured; compensation under the Code on Social Security, 2020 and ex gratia relief; the site sealed and similar buildings audited.
- Evidence-based enquiry: laboratory tests of materials, plans, inspection records and site measurements; responsibility fixed on the builder (criminal negligence, employing minors), the building inspector (suspension pending disciplinary proceedings) and others, without fear or favour.
- Disclosure: inform the government in writing of my friendship with the former Commissioner and suggest that another officer assess his decision; recommend referring the nexus, with the prior approval required by Section 17A of the Prevention of Corruption Act, to the vigilance or anti-corruption bureau.
- Bribe and threat: refuse firmly; report both in writing at once to the Chief Secretary and the anti-corruption bureau; meet the builder only in office, with a record.
- The POSH threat: having reported it in advance, cooperate fully with any inquiry by the competent committee; the Act (Section 14) provides for action against malicious complaints, and the truth is my defence.
- Systemic reform: review all permissions that violate the master plan, restore the green belt and slip road after due process, and introduce online plan approvals, geo-tagged inspection photographs and third-party quality audits.
Why this course: it upholds the rule of law and the dignity of those who died (duty); it prevents future tragedies (consequences); and it reflects the courage expected of an upright officer (virtue). Friendship is honoured by fairness, not by favour.
Silence would make me a partner in the next collapse. Integrity with courage, backed by a written record and transparent procedure, protects both the public interest and the honest officer.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking