
Photo: New Parliament building, Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, GODL-India
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2020 · GS Paper II
UPSC Mains 2020 GS 2 · Q4: model answer
General Studies Paper II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations · Constitution and Polity.
The judicial systems in India and UK seem to be converging as well as diverging in recent times. Highlight the key points of convergence and divergence between the two nations in terms of their judicial practices.
Syllabus: Constitution and Polity · Judiciary
Common lawJudicial reviewParliamentary sovereigntyJudicial independence
India inherited the common law tradition from Britain: binding precedent, adversarial trials and an independent judiciary. But India has a written Constitution with judicial review and a basic structure doctrine, while the UK rests on parliamentary sovereignty. Reforms in both countries over the last two decades have brought their judicial practices closer in some respects and kept them far apart in others.
1. Points of convergence
- A separate apex court: the UK's Constitutional Reform Act, 2005 moved the highest court out of the House of Lords into a separate Supreme Court (2009) and ended the Lord Chancellor's role as head of the judiciary, closer to India's separate Supreme Court (Article 124) and the separation of the judiciary from the executive (Article 50).
- Review of executive power: the UK Supreme Court held that giving notice to leave the EU needed an Act of Parliament (Miller, 2017) and that the 2019 prorogation of Parliament was unlawful (Miller/Cherry, 2019), much as Indian courts review executive action.
- Rights-based review: the Human Rights Act, 1998 lets UK courts test laws against the European Convention on Human Rights, a role similar to review under Part III in India.
- Constitutional references: the UK Supreme Court answers devolution references, as on a Scottish independence referendum (2022), comparable to India's advisory jurisdiction (Article 143).
- Openness and technology: both stream hearings live (India's Supreme Court for Constitution Bench cases since 2022) and expanded virtual hearings during COVID-19.
2. Points of divergence
- Power over legislation: Indian courts can strike down laws and even constitutional amendments (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973; NJAC case, 2015); UK courts cannot strike down an Act of Parliament and can only make a declaration of incompatibility, leaving Parliament the final word.
- Appointments: the UK uses an independent Judicial Appointments Commission (2006) with lay members; India's collegium remains judge-led after the NJAC was struck down.
- Access to courts: India's public interest litigation, letter petitions and suo motu cases (S.P. Gupta, 1981) have no parallel in the UK's ordinary standing rules.
- Contempt: the offence of scandalising the judiciary was abolished in England and Wales in 2013; India retains criminal contempt, used against Prashant Bhushan (2020).
- Juries: the UK keeps juries for serious criminal trials; India phased them out after independence.
| Practice | India | UK |
|---|---|---|
| Review of legislation | Can strike down laws and amendments | Declaration of incompatibility for Acts of Parliament |
| Appointment of judges | Collegium (judge-led) | Judicial Appointments Commission |
| Standing | PIL, letter petitions, suo motu cases | Ordinary sufficient-interest test |
| Contempt | Includes scandalising the court | Scandalising abolished (2013) |
| Juries | No jury trials | Juries in serious criminal trials |
3. Why the paths differ
- Written vs unwritten constitution: India's courts guard a supreme Constitution; UK courts serve a sovereign Parliament.
- Social role: Indian courts expanded Article 21 and PIL to reach the poor where the State failed; the UK's welfare and tribunal systems handle many such claims.
- Institutional history: the UK reformed by statute (2005), while India's reforms, such as the collegium, came largely through judgments.
- 2005 UK: Constitutional Reform Act
- 2009 UK Supreme Court begins work
- 2013 UK: scandalising the judiciary abolished
- 2015 India: NJAC struck down; collegium continues
- 2022 India: live-streaming of Constitution Bench hearings
The two systems converge in judicial independence, openness and closer review of the executive, but diverge on the courts' power over Parliament. India can learn from the UK's transparent appointments and restraint in contempt, while the UK's debates show the value of codified rights that India's courts already enforce.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking