
Photo: New Parliament building, Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, GODL-India
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2020 · GS Paper II
UPSC Mains 2020 GS 2 · Q12: model answer
General Studies Paper II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations · Constitution and Polity.
Judicial Legislation is antithetical to the doctrine of separation of powers as envisaged in the Indian Constitution. In this context justify the filing of large number of public interest petitions praying for issuing guidelines to executive authorities.
Syllabus: Constitution and Polity · Judiciary
Separation of powersJudicial legislationPublic interest litigationArticle 142
The Constitution does not adopt a rigid separation of powers, but each organ has a core domain: Parliament makes laws, the executive implements them and the courts interpret them (Ram Jawaya Kapur, 1955). Separation of powers is part of the basic structure (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973). When courts issue binding guidelines on petitions filed as public interest litigation (PIL), they appear to legislate; yet most such petitions arise because the other organs have failed to protect rights.
1. Why judicial legislation is criticised
- Democratic legitimacy: judges are not elected or answerable to voters; in Aravali Golf Club v. Chander Hass (2007) the Supreme Court itself warned courts against encroaching on the legislature and the executive.
- Institutional competence: courts lack the data, expertise, consultation and budgets that policy needs, so guidelines may be hard to implement, as States' partial compliance with Prakash Singh (2006) on police reform shows.
- Rigidity and uncertainty: guidelines lack legislative debate and cannot be revised easily when circumstances change.
- Self-correction: after State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor (April 2025) set timelines for assent, the Presidential Reference opinion (November 2025) held that courts cannot fix timelines or deem assent.
2. Why so many PILs seek guidelines: the justification
- Legislative vacuum: Vishaka (1997) laid down rules on sexual harassment at work, which applied until the POSH Act, 2013; Common Cause (2018) allowed living wills, and the procedure was simplified in 2023.
- Executive failure that violates rights: D.K. Basu (1997) on custodial violence, Lalita Kumari (2013) on registering FIRs, Arnesh Kumar (2014) against routine arrests, and Tehseen Poonawalla (2018) on mob lynching.
- Constitutional mandate: Article 32 is itself a fundamental right; the Court's law binds all (Article 141), and Article 142 allows orders for complete justice.
- Access for the voiceless: relaxed standing (S.P. Gupta, 1981) let the poor and prisoners reach the Court, as in Hussainara Khatoon (1979).
- Stopgap, not substitute: most guidelines apply only until the legislature acts, and Parliament has often then enacted laws.
| Case | Gap | Guideline | What followed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vishaka (1997) | No law on workplace sexual harassment | Complaints committees | POSH Act, 2013 |
| D.K. Basu (1997) | Custodial violence | Safeguards on arrest | Later written into criminal procedure law |
| Prakash Singh (2006) | Politicised policing | Security commissions, fixed tenure | Partial compliance by States |
| Common Cause (2018) | No law on passive euthanasia | Living wills | Procedure simplified (2023) |
| Tehseen Poonawalla (2018) | Mob lynching | Preventive and remedial steps | Mob lynching made an offence in the BNS (2023) |
3. Striking a balance
- Restraint: Balwant Singh Chaufal (2010) laid down guidelines against frivolous "publicity interest litigation"; guidelines should be a last resort.
- Dialogue, not dictation: courts can identify the violation and give the government time to act, keeping supervision through continuing mandamus (Vineet Narain, 1997).
- Legislative responsibility: Parliament should legislate promptly on issues the courts flag, after committee scrutiny.
Judicial guidelines are not usurpation when they fill a constitutional vacuum to enforce fundamental rights; they become overreach when they replace legitimate policy choices. Separation of powers in India means checks and balances: judicial restraint, executive responsiveness and timely legislation together protect both rights and democracy.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking