
Photo: New Parliament building, Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, GODL-India
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2019 · GS Paper II
UPSC Mains 2019 GS 2 · Q4: model answer
General Studies Paper II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations · Constitution and Polity.
From the resolution of contentious issues regarding distribution of legislative powers by the courts, ‘Principle of Federal Supremacy’ and ‘Harmonious Construction’ have emerged. Explain.
Syllabus: Constitution and Polity · Federalism and Centre–State relations
Seventh ScheduleFederal supremacyHarmonious constructionPith and substance
Article 246 divides legislative power through the Seventh Schedule into the Union, State and Concurrent Lists. Because no list can be drawn perfectly, entries overlap, and courts must decide whose law prevails. From these disputes two principles have emerged: federal supremacy, under which Union law prevails in a genuine conflict, and harmonious construction, under which entries are read together so that both legislatures' powers survive. Supporting doctrines such as pith and substance make the system work.
1. Principle of federal supremacy
- Text of Article 246: Parliament's power over the Union List operates "notwithstanding anything in clauses (2) and (3)", while the States' power over the State List is "subject to clauses (1) and (2)"; in an irreconcilable overlap the Union List therefore prevails.
- Concurrent List (Article 254): a State law repugnant to a Union law is void to the extent of repugnancy, unless reserved for and assented to by the President (Article 254(2)); even then Parliament may later override it.
- Tests of repugnancy: M. Karunanidhi (1979) asks whether there is a direct conflict, whether Parliament intended an exhaustive code, and whether both laws occupy the same field.
- Application: in Adhiyaman (1995) a State law on standards of technical education yielded to the AICTE Act, made under Entry 66 of the Union List.
- A last resort: courts apply it only when the entries cannot be reconciled.
2. Principle of harmonious construction
- Meaning: entries are read together so that each has effect; a general entry yields to a specific one, and no entry is read so widely that another becomes useless.
- Origin: in the C.P. and Berar Motor Spirit case (1939), the Federal Court reconciled the Centre's excise duty, a tax on manufacture, with the provinces' tax on the sale of goods.
- Specific over general: in Calcutta Gas (1962) the specific State entry on gas and gas-works was held to cover the gas industry, so the State law stood despite the Union's power over industries.
- Recent use: the Supreme Court has read the lists together in several major disputes (table).
| Case | Entries in tension | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Modern Dental College (2016) | Standards of higher education (Union List 66) vs education (Concurrent List 25) | States may regulate admissions and fees in professional colleges |
| Mineral Area Development Authority (2024) | Mines and minerals (Union List 54) vs taxes on mineral rights (State List 50) | 8:1: royalty is not a tax; States can tax mineral rights |
| Lalta Prasad Vaish (2024) | Industries (Union List 52) vs intoxicating liquors (State List 8) | 8:1: States can regulate industrial alcohol |
3. Supporting doctrines
- Pith and substance: a law is classified by its true nature, and incidental effects on another list do not invalidate it; Prafulla Kumar Mukherjee (Privy Council, 1947) upheld a Bengal money-lending law that touched promissory notes, and F.N. Balsara (1951) upheld Bombay's prohibition law though it affected imports.
- Colourable legislation: a legislature cannot do indirectly what it cannot do directly (K.C. Gajapati Narayan Deo, 1953).
4. Significance
- Unity: federal supremacy keeps national law uniform on defence, currency and standards.
- Autonomy: harmonious construction protects the States' sphere; federalism is a basic feature (S.R. Bommai, 1994), and the 2024 judgments upheld State powers where the text allowed.
Together the two principles give India a federation with a centralising tilt but a cooperative spirit: the Union prevails when it must, but courts first try to give both levels room, the essence of cooperative federalism.
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking