Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
The new Parliament building in New Delhi, seen from above

Photo: New Parliament building, Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, GODL-India

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2019 · GS Paper II

UPSC Mains 2019 GS 2 · Q15: model answer

General Studies Paper II: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International Relations · Constitution and Polity.

Q1515 marks250 words2019 · GS Paper II

Individual Parliamentarian’s role as the national law maker is on a decline, which in turn, has adversely impacted the quality of debates and their outcome. Discuss.

Syllabus: Constitution and Polity · Parliament and State legislatures

Model answer · free

Anti-defection lawParty whipExecutive dominanceQuality of deliberation

In the Westminster model the individual MP legislates, deliberates on policy and holds the executive to account. In India, the anti-defection law (Tenth Schedule, 1985), the executive's control of the House's agenda and frequent disruptions have reduced most MPs to votes cast on the party whip. PRS data for the 17th Lok Sabha (2019–24) show the result: only 274 sittings, just 16% of Bills referred to committees, and 35% of Bills passed with less than an hour of debate.

1. Why the individual MP's role has declined

  • The whip on every vote: defying the whip on any motion, even an ordinary Bill, invites disqualification, so MPs cannot vote by conscience or constituency interest; Kihoto Hollohan (1992) upheld the law.
  • Executive control of time: government business takes precedence; only 14 private members' Bills have ever become law, the last in 1970.
  • Fewer sittings: the Lok Sabha sits far less than in the 1950s, below the minimum of 120 days a year suggested by the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2002).
  • Bypassing Parliament: ordinances, wide delegated legislation and the Money Bill route, as for the Aadhaar Act, 2016, reduce scrutiny.
  • Incentives and capacity: constituency service and patronage reward MPs more than law-making, and MPs have little research support.
Indicator17th Lok Sabha (2019–24)
Sittings274
Bills referred to committees16% (71% in the 15th Lok Sabha)
Bills passed with under an hour of debate35%
Budget voted without discussion (2019–23)About 80%
Deputy SpeakerNot elected
Signs of declining deliberation (PRS)

2. Impact on the quality of debates and their outcome

  • Hasty laws: the three farm laws of 2020 were passed without committee scrutiny and repealed in 2021 after prolonged protests.
  • Litigation and repeated corrections: the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 re-enacted provisions the Supreme Court had struck down, and the Court struck them down again in 2025.
  • Weak financial scrutiny: most demands for grants are guillotined, so the budget is barely debated.
  • Ritual debates: speeches follow party lines, amendments moved by individual MPs rarely succeed, and disruptions consume Question Hour.
  • Weaker accountability: less questioning of ministers strengthens executive dominance and lowers public trust in Parliament.

3. Not a uniform decline

  • Committees: departmentally related standing committees (1993) still allow detailed, bipartisan scrutiny behind closed doors, where the whip does not apply.
  • Private initiative: the Rajya Sabha passed Tiruchi Siva's private member's Bill on the rights of transgender persons in 2015, and Zero Hour lets MPs raise local issues.
Whip binds every vote
MPs vote on party lines
Debate becomes ritual; Bills bypass committees
Poorly drafted laws and litigation
Executive dominance grows
How a strict whip hollows out debate

4. Way forward

  • Narrower whip: confine disqualification to voluntarily giving up party membership and to confidence and no-confidence votes, as the Dinesh Goswami Committee (1990) proposed.
  • Mandatory scrutiny: refer all major Bills to committees and follow the Pre-Legislative Consultation Policy (2014).
  • Time and support: a minimum number of sittings and research staff for every MP.

Restoring the individual MP's voice is essential for deliberative democracy: Parliament should be the place where laws are tested, not merely passed.

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149