
Photo: Konark Sun Temple wheel, Joydeep, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2019 · GS Paper I
UPSC Mains 2019 GS 1 · Q10: model answer
General Studies Paper I: Indian Heritage and Culture, History and Geography of the World and Society · Indian Society.
What are the challenges to our cultural practices in the name of secularism?
Syllabus: Indian Society · Diversity, communalism and regionalism
Indian secularismPrincipled distanceEssential religious practicesConstitutional morality
Secularism was added to the Preamble by the 42nd Amendment (1976) and held to be a basic feature of the Constitution in S.R. Bommai (1994). Indian secularism is not a wall of separation but principled distance (Rajeev Bhargava): equal respect for all faiths, with the State free to reform practices that violate rights (Article 25(2)(b)). Since Indian culture is deeply interwoven with religion, applying secularism to cultural practices creates several challenges.
1. Judges deciding what is "essential"
- The test: since Shirur Mutt (1954), only essential religious practices get the protection of Article 25; critics say this makes judges theologians.
- Contested rulings: Ismail Faruqui (1994) held that a mosque is not essential to Islam for namaz; the hijab ban in Karnataka classrooms was upheld by the High Court (2022) but produced a split verdict in the Supreme Court (October 2022).
- Constitutional morality versus faith: in the Sabarimala case (2018) the majority struck down the bar on women aged 10–50, while Justice Indu Malhotra's dissent warned courts against interfering in deep matters of faith; wider questions were referred to a larger bench in 2019.
| Case | Practice | Issue |
|---|---|---|
| Shirur Mutt (1954) | Management of a math | Origin of the essential-practices test |
| Shayara Bano (2017) | Instant triple talaq | Struck down; criminalised in 2019 |
| Indian Young Lawyers Association (2018) | Women's entry to Sabarimala | Equality versus a denomination's custom |
| A. Nagaraja (2014); Constitution Bench (2023) | Jallikattu | Animal welfare versus cultural heritage |
| Aishat Shifa (2022) | Hijab in classrooms | Split verdict; referred to a larger bench |
2. Reform versus tradition
- Gender justice: instant triple talaq was struck down (Shayara Bano, 2017) and the Bombay High Court opened the Haji Ali dargah's sanctum to women (2016); reformers welcomed these rulings, while some saw them as State intrusion.
- Animal welfare and environment: the 2014 ban on jallikattu provoked mass protests in 2017 and a new Tamil Nadu law, which a Constitution Bench upheld in May 2023; limits on firecrackers (green crackers, Arjun Gopal, 2018), idol immersion and loudspeakers are seen by some as targeting festivals.
- Personal laws: the Uniform Civil Code debate (Article 44) pits equality against community customs; Uttarakhand's UCC (in force from January 2025) exempts Scheduled Tribes.
3. Political contest over the word
- Charges of selectivity: the reversal of the Shah Bano judgment (1986 Act) led to allegations of minority appeasement, while minorities complain of pressure on their food, dress and conversions.
- Religion in public life: ground-breaking pujas, lamp-lighting, school prayers and yoga are seen as culture by some and religion by others; a challenge to the Sanskrit morning prayer in Kendriya Vidyalayas was referred to a Constitution Bench (2019).
4. Deeper social challenges
- Loss of shared practices: when identities harden, syncretic traditions, such as Hindus visiting dargahs or Muslims performing in Ramlilas, weaken.
- Tradition as backward: a narrow, Western-style reading of secularism can treat all tradition as superstition, alienating believers.
The way forward is a contextual secularism: courts should protect individual rights with restraint, reform should come through dialogue within communities, and citizens should honour their duty to value India's composite culture (Article 51A(f)).
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking