Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
Warli tribal paintings on a city wall in Mysuru

Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2026 · Paper II

UPSC Anthropology Optional 2026 Paper 2 · Q8(a): model answer

Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Anthropology in India.

Q8(a)20 marks2026 · Paper II

Make a critical appraisal of Surajit Sinha's line of argument that tribes and castes may not be isolated social categories, but are a part of the great Indian civilization.

Syllabus: Anthropology in India · Contributions of Indian anthropologists

Model answer · free

Tribe-caste continuumRajput myth and state formationLittle and great traditionBhumij

Surajit Sinha, drawing on Robert Redfield's civilizational approach and on N.K. Bose's "Hindu method of tribal absorption" (1941), argued that tribes and castes are not isolated categories but points on a continuum within Indian civilization. His argument rests on his study of the Bhumij of Manbhum and on papers such as "Tribal cultures of peninsular India as a dimension of little tradition" (1958), "State formation and Rajput myth" (1962) and "Tribe-caste and tribe-peasant continua" (1965).

1. Sinha's line of argument

  • Tribe as little tradition: tribal cultures of peninsular India are a dimension of the little tradition of Indian civilization, not separate worlds.
  • Ideal types: a tribe is marked by isolation from the great tradition, ethnic homogeneity, clan-based segmentary structure, close tie to territory and little hierarchy; a caste by hierarchy, interdependence and Brahmanical values. Real groups lie between these poles.
  • The Bhumij case: the Bhumij of Barabhum took Brahmin priests, Hindu deities and caste norms, and in the early 20th century a Bhumij-Kshatriya movement claimed Kshatriya status, which Sinha analysed in a 1959 paper on south Manbhum.
  • Rajput myth and state formation: tribal chiefs who built kingdoms legitimised their rule by claiming Rajput descent and patronising Brahmins and temples. Such secondary state formation drew Bhumij, Gond, Chero and Nagvanshi rulers and their subjects into the caste order.
Clan-based tribal community
Chiefdom grows into a small state
Ruling lineage claims Rajput descent; Brahmins patronised
Commoners adopt Hindu rites and caste norms
Community claims Kshatriya status
Accepted as a caste in the regional hierarchy
Tribe to caste: the path Sinha traced

2. Strengths

  • Historical and dynamic: it replaced both Verrier Elwin's picture of isolated tribes and G.S. Ghurye's label of "backward Hindus" (1943) with a process traced over centuries.
  • Empirical support: Gond kingdoms of Garha-Mandla and Chanda, the Nagvanshi rajas of Chotanagpur and the Rajput claims of many central Indian chiefs fit the model; it parallels M.N. Srinivas's Sanskritisation and F.G. Bailey's continuum based on access to land (1961).
  • Lasting relevance: it explains why many communities sit on the tribe-caste border and why scheduling is contested.

3. Criticisms

  • One-way and Hindu-centred: Hinduisation is treated as the only path; Christianisation among the Oraon and Munda, Islamisation and secular change are neglected, and "Indian civilization" is equated with the Brahmanical great tradition.
  • Neglect of agency and resistance: Virginius Xaxa (1999) argued that tribes have not dissolved into castes; they keep distinct identities, often move towards a peasant economy, and assert themselves through movements such as the Jharkhand movement and the demand for a Sarna religion code.
  • Limited reach: the model fits central India, not the Naga, Mizo, Khasi or Andaman islanders.
  • Conceptual blurring: André Béteille (1986) held that tribe and caste rest on different principles, isolation versus hierarchy, even if the boundary is historically fluid.
  • Reverse flows: de-Sanskritisation, tribal revival and some castes' demands for ST status, such as the Kurmi-Mahato in Jharkhand and West Bengal, show movement in both directions, shaped by State policy.
Scholar (work, year)Position
N.K. Bose (Hindu method of tribal absorption, 1941)Tribes absorbed gradually into caste society
F.G. Bailey (Tribe and caste in India, 1961)Continuum; tribes have direct access to land
Surajit Sinha (1958–1965)Tribe-caste and tribe-peasant continua; Rajput myth
André Béteille (The concept of tribe, 1986)Distinct categories with a historical boundary
Virginius Xaxa (1999)Tribes transformed but keep a separate identity
Supporters and critics of the continuum view

Sinha rightly showed that tribes have long been part of Indian civilization and its state systems. Today, however, tribes are better seen as distinct communities negotiating with that civilization and with the State, which calls for integration without assimilation.

The other parts of Q8

  1. Q8(b)What are the major challenges tribal communities are facing in contemporary India?

    15 marks · Problems of Tribal Communities · Land alienation, poverty and indebtedness

  2. Q8(c)What are the provisions given in the Constitution of India for the safeguard of the Scheduled Caste populations?

    15 marks · Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Safeguards · Constitutional and legal safeguards

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149