
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2026 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2026 Paper 2 · Q4(b): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Demographic Profile of India.
Why the classifications of Indian populations, based on somatometric and somatoscopic characteristics failed to develop a common understanding of the population diversity?
Syllabus: Demographic Profile of India · Ethnic and linguistic elements
Racial typologySomatometry and somatoscopyClinal variationPopulation genetics
From the 1901 Census, scholars tried to sort India's people into "races" using somatometric traits (measured: stature, cephalic and nasal indices) and somatoscopic traits (observed: skin colour, hair form, eye fold, nose shape). H.H. Risley, B.S. Guha, S.S. Sarkar and others produced very different schemes, and none gave a shared picture of India's population diversity.
1. The main classifications
| Scholar | Basis | Types proposed |
|---|---|---|
| H.H. Risley (The People of India, 1908) | Nasal and cephalic indices, stature; 1901 Census | Seven types, from Turko-Iranian and Indo-Aryan to Mongoloid and Dravidian |
| B.S. Guha (1931 Census) | Anthropometry of selected groups | Six main races with sub-types: Negrito, Proto-Australoid, Mongoloid, Mediterranean, Western Brachycephals, Nordic |
| S.S. Sarkar (The Aboriginal Races of India, 1954) | Re-analysis of tribal data | Australoid base; no Negrito strain on the mainland |
| D.N. Majumdar and C.R. Rao (1940s–1960) | Mahalanobis distance on UP and Bengal surveys | Groups cluster by region and social rank, not by "race" |
2. Why they failed to agree
- Continuous variation: traits change gradually across space, so any boundary is arbitrary; as Frank Livingstone (1962) put it, "there are no races, there are only clines".
- Non-concordance of traits: stature, head form, nasal index and skin colour vary independently, so each trait yields a different map and the result depends on the trait chosen.
- Subjective observation: grading skin colour, hair or nose shape by eye differed between observers, and small convenience samples were treated as typical of whole castes and tribes.
- Plasticity: Franz Boas (1912) showed that head form changed in the children of immigrants to the United States; nutrition and climate also shape stature and nasal index, so these are not fixed racial markers.
- Race confused with language and caste: "Aryan" and "Dravidian" are language labels; Risley even claimed that "the social position of a caste varies inversely as its nasal index", turning colonial census ranking into biology, a link criticised by Nicholas Dirks (Castes of Mind, 2001).
- Admixture with endogamy: long migration and mixing, followed by strict endogamy, produced a mosaic that fits no set of discrete types; disputed elements such as Guha's mainland "Negrito" showed how fragile the categories were.
3. What replaced the typologies
- New concepts: the UNESCO statements on race (1950, 1951) and Richard Lewontin's finding (1972) that about 85% of human genetic variation lies within populations ended typological thinking.
- Genetic evidence: David Reich and colleagues (2009, Nature) showed that most Indian groups descend from a mixture of Ancestral North Indians and Ancestral South Indians in varying proportions, with strong founder effects from endogamy; ancient DNA, including the Rakhigarhi genome (2019), refined this.
- GenomeIndia: whole genomes of 10,000 people from 99 communities, released in January 2025, now map diversity for medicine and history.
The older schemes failed because human variation is continuous, multi-causal and shaped by history and environment; modern anthropology studies populations and clines, while anthropometry remains useful for growth, nutrition and forensic work.
The other parts of Q4
- Q4(a)Write an account on the contribution of Verrier Elwin in developing policies for the tribal populations in post-independent India.
20 marks · Tribal Development · History of tribal administration and policies
- Q4(c)Make a critical appraisal of Niyamgiri movement against mining-induced displacement.
15 marks · Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements · Tribal movements and identity
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking