Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
Warli tribal paintings on a city wall in Mysuru

Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2026 · Paper II

UPSC Anthropology Optional 2026 Paper 2 · Q3(c): model answer

Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Evolution of Indian Culture and Civilisation.

Q3(c)15 marks2026 · Paper II

Discuss with examples, how general comparative analogy has been used for ethnoarchaeological studies in India.

Syllabus: Evolution of Indian Culture and Civilisation · Ethnoarchaeology in India

Model answer · free

EthnoarchaeologyGeneral comparative analogyDirect historical approachTesting analogies

Ethnoarchaeology studies living communities to learn how material remains are made, used and discarded, so that the archaeological record can be read. Its inferences rest on analogy. A general comparative analogy draws parallels from societies with similar environment, technology and economy, without assuming historical links; it differs from the direct historical approach (Julian Steward, 1942), which projects back from descendants living in the same region.

1. The method

  • Cross-cultural regularities: forager group size, seasonal mobility, camp layout and the roles of men and women recur across continents and can be used as models.
  • Choosing analogues: Robert Ascher (1961) advised selecting societies with similar environment and subsistence; Lewis Binford's Nunamiut Ethnoarchaeology (1978) showed how observed behaviour leaves patterned traces, the basis of middle-range theory.
AspectGeneral comparativeDirect historical
BasisSimilar ecology, technology and economyCultural continuity in one region
Time depthAny period, even the PalaeolithicMainly protohistoric and later periods
Indian exampleForager camps used to read Acheulian and Mesolithic sitesKhambhat bead-makers used to read Harappan beads
Main riskIgnores history; foragers are not "living fossils"Assumes an unchanged tradition
General comparative analogy and the direct historical approach

2. Indian examples

  • Acheulian settlement (Hunsgi valley, Karnataka): K. Paddayya (The Acheulian Culture of the Hunsgi Valley, 1982) used ethnographic accounts of hunter-gatherers to model Acheulian sites as seasonal camps tied to water and food.
  • Foraging ecosystems (Andhra Pradesh): M.L.K. Murty (1981, 1985) studied how Yanadi and Chenchu groups forage, make tools and choose shelters, building a model for Palaeolithic and Mesolithic sites of the south-east coast and the Kurnool caves.
  • Mesolithic camps: Malti Nagar and V.N. Misra (1990) observed the Kanjars, a mobile hunting-gathering community of the Ganga valley, as a guide to camp size, hearths and food remains at the region's Mesolithic sites.
  • Neolithic ash mounds: F.R. Allchin (Neolithic Cattle-Keepers of South India, 1963) explained the Deccan ash mounds (Utnur, Kupgal) as burnt dung of seasonal cattle pens, drawing on present-day herders' camps and suggesting a ritual, perhaps purificatory, side to the burning; later excavations confirmed burnt dung.
  • Megaliths and rock art: living menhir and memorial-stone traditions of the Khasi, Munda, Ho and the Maria Gonds of Bastar are used to suggest how Iron Age megaliths of the peninsula were raised and used, and present tribal life helps read hunting and honey-gathering scenes in the Bhimbetka paintings (Yashodhar Mathpal, 1984).
Archaeological pattern needs explanation
Choose a society with similar ecology
Observe how behaviour leaves traces
Build a model of the past activity
Test it against excavated evidence
Using a general comparative analogy

3. Limitations

  • Not living fossils: Indian foragers have long traded forest produce with farmers; Richard Fox (1969) called them "professional primitives", so their behaviour reflects contact with states and markets.
  • Tyranny of the record: Martin Wobst (1978) warned that past societies may have had forms with no modern parallel.
  • Equifinality: different activities can leave similar remains, so analogies must be tested; Alison Wylie (1985) argued for relational analogies based on causal links.
  • Ethics: using living tribes as proxies for the past can stigmatise them as "primitive".

In India, general comparative analogy has enriched the study of Palaeolithic, Mesolithic and Neolithic life; joined with the direct historical approach and scientific tests, it turns India's living diversity of foragers, herders and artisans into a laboratory for the past.

The other parts of Q3

  1. Q3(a)Critically examine the salience of F. G. Bailey's study on Bisipara village of Odisha.

    20 marks · Indian Village and Peasantry · Village studies and the village as a social system

  2. Q3(b)Discuss the impact of Christianity on the tribal population of Jharkhand.

    15 marks · Religion and the Sacred Complex in India · Impact of Buddhism, Jainism, Islam and Christianity

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149