
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2026 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2026 Paper 2 · Q2(a): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Traditional Indian Social System.
What are the major debates related to the concept of jajmani system?
Syllabus: Traditional Indian Social System · Jajmani system
JajmaniReciprocity vs exploitationRitual vs material basisPatron–client ties
Jajmani denotes hereditary, non-market exchange in which patron households (jajman, usually landholders) receive economic and ritual services from service castes (kamin or praja), who are paid mainly in grain at harvest and in gifts at festivals and life-cycle rites. William Wiser gave the term its sociological meaning in The Hindu Jajmani System (1936), based on Karimpur in Uttar Pradesh. Since then its nature, basis and very existence have been debated.
1. Integrative or exploitative?
- Reciprocity view: Wiser stressed mutual service, with each caste both serving and being served; Pauline Kolenda (1963) modelled it as a functional system that gave security and shared risk.
- Exploitation view: Oscar Lewis and Victor Barnouw (1956), in Rani Khera near Delhi, and Thomas Beidelman (1959) argued that it rested on landholders' power; Beidelman called it feudal.
- View from below: Joan Mencher (1974) showed that untouchable labourers in Tamil Nadu experienced it as coercion, not harmony.
- Patronage turning into exploitation: Jan Breman (Patronage and Exploitation, 1974) traced how the hali tie in south Gujarat lost its protective side as markets expanded.
2. Ritual order or material power?
- Ritual basis: Louis Dumont (Homo Hierarchicus, 1966) read jajmani as an expression of the hierarchy of pure and impure: priests, barbers and washermen remove pollution, and grain shares follow religious values rather than market logic; Harold Gould ("The Hindu Jajmani System", 1958) likewise traced the ties to the divide between pure and impure castes rather than rich and poor.
- Material basis: Beidelman and later critics placed land, grain and power at the core, with ritual service only a part.
- Centrality, not only hierarchy: Gloria Goodwin Raheja (The Poison in the Gift, 1988) found in Pahansu (western UP) that the dominant Gujar landholders stood at the centre of gift-giving, passing inauspiciousness to Brahmins and service castes through dan.
| Issue | One position | Opposing position |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Reciprocity and security (Wiser 1936; Kolenda 1963) | Dominance of landholders (Lewis and Barnouw 1956; Beidelman 1959) |
| Basis | Purity and hierarchy (Dumont 1966) | Land, grain and power (Beidelman; Mencher 1974) |
| Centre | Brahmin at the top of purity | Dominant caste at the centre of gifts (Raheja 1988) |
| Existence | One integrated village system | A model built by scholars (Fuller 1989) |
| Time | Ancient and enduring | Shaped by changing labour and land conditions (Commander 1983) |
3. Was it ever a "system"?
- Fuller's critique: C.J. Fuller ("Misconceiving the Grain Heap", 1989) argued that harvest shares, ritual fees and customary dues were wrongly fused into a single pan-Indian system by anthropologists.
- Historical contingency: Simon Commander (1983) showed that its form in north India varied with labour supply and agrarian conditions over two centuries; regional forms such as Maharashtra's balutedari differ in detail.
4. Decline or persistence?
- Erosion: cash crops, factory goods, mechanisation, education, migration and Dalit assertion turned most ties into wage contracts; T. Scarlett Epstein (1962) found older ties surviving longer in irrigated Wangala than in diversified Dalena.
- Residues: barbers, priests and drummers still serve at weddings and funerals for customary payments.
The debates show that jajmani is best seen not as a timeless harmony but as a changing bundle of patron–client relations, shaped by ritual values and material power alike; its study remains a key test of theories of caste.
The other parts of Q2
- Q2(b)'Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan aims to meet some of the Sustainable Development Goals'. Discuss.
15 marks · Tribal Development · Tribal development plans, schemes and PESA
- Q2(c)What are the evidences available regarding crops and domesticated animals of Indus Valley Civilization? What are the views of the scholars regarding Indus script?
15 marks · Evolution of Indian Culture and Civilisation · Protohistoric and Harappan civilisation
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking