
Photo: Bhimbetka rock paintings, Yann, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2026 · Paper I
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2026 Paper 1 · Q3(a): model answer
Anthropology Paper I: Foundations of Anthropology, Human Evolution, Culture, Society and Human Genetics · Political Organisation and Social Control.
How do the concepts of power, authority, legitimacy and social control change with changing political organization? Discuss in detail giving suitable examples.
Syllabus: Political Organisation and Social Control · Power, authority and legitimacy
Power and authorityLegitimacyBand, tribe, chiefdom, stateSocial control
Power is the ability to make others act as one wishes, even against resistance; authority is power accepted as rightful, and legitimacy is the belief that makes it rightful (Max Weber, Economy and Society, 1922). Social control covers the sanctions, informal and formal, that keep conduct within norms. Along Elman Service's (1962) sequence of band, tribe, chiefdom and state, each of these changes in source, scale and form.
1. The concepts
- Political process: Swartz, Turner and Tuden (Political Anthropology, 1966) stressed that legitimacy, more than force, sustains power.
- Sanctions: A.R. Radcliffe-Brown separated diffuse sanctions (gossip, ridicule, ostracism) from organised ones (fines, courts, punishment); E.A. Hoebel (The Law of Primitive Man, 1954) found law wherever a recognised authority may legitimately use force.
| Type | Basis of legitimacy | Anthropological example |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional | Custom, descent, age | Lineage elders, hereditary chiefs |
| Charismatic | Extraordinary personal qualities | Prophets, big men, leaders of revitalisation movements |
| Legal-rational | Impersonal rules and office | Bureaucrats, judges, elected leaders |
2. Band societies
- Power and authority: small, mobile, egalitarian foragers such as the !Kung San, the Inuit and the Chenchus have leaders who advise but cannot command; influence rests on age, skill and generosity.
- Legitimacy and control: rests on kinship and consensus; disputes end through gossip, ridicule, sharing or the group splitting, and Inuit song duels let rivals shame each other before the camp (Hoebel).
3. Tribal and segmentary societies
- Dispersed authority: there is no permanent central office; authority lies with lineage elders, age-sets or achieved leaders. Melanesian big men gain followers by giving feasts but cannot pass on their position (Marshall Sahlins, 1963).
- Ritual legitimacy: the Nuer leopard-skin chief mediates feuds through ritual standing, not coercion (E.E. Evans-Pritchard, The Nuer, 1940); order rests on balanced opposition between lineage segments.
- Control: bloodwealth in cattle, feud, oaths, ordeals, witchcraft accusations and supernatural sanctions; in India, Santal village councils under the manjhi and wider pargana councils impose fines or outcasting.
4. Chiefdoms
- Centralised power: a hereditary, ranked office controls the redistribution of surplus, as among Polynesian and Trobriand chiefs; potlatch feasts on the Northwest Coast validated rank.
- Sacred legitimacy: Polynesian chiefs held mana and were protected by tapu; Khasi syiems ruled their himas with the advice of clan-based councils (dorbars).
- Control: the chief's court, fines and fear of tapu. Edmund Leach (Political Systems of Highland Burma, 1954) showed the Kachin moving back and forth between hierarchical gumsa and egalitarian gumlao forms, so change is not always one-way.
5. The state
- Monopoly of force: Weber defined the state by its monopoly of legitimate physical force over a territory; Morton Fried (The Evolution of Political Society, 1967) linked its rise to stratification.
- New legitimacy: divine kingship and dharma give way to constitutions, elections and courts.
- Formal control: codified law, police and prisons; Michel Foucault (Discipline and Punish, 1975) argued that modern power also works through surveillance and self-discipline.
- Indian blend: Article 371A protects Naga customary law, Sixth Schedule district councils and PESA (1996) recognise traditional bodies, while the Lushai Hills chiefs lost their rights under a 1954 Act.
| Type | Power and authority | Legitimacy | Main social control | Example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Band | Informal, situational leader | Kinship, consensus, skill | Gossip, ridicule, song duel, fission | !Kung San, Inuit, Chenchu |
| Tribe | Elders, big men, lineage heads | Descent, age, generosity | Feud, compensation, oaths, ordeals | Nuer, Melanesia, Santal |
| Chiefdom | Hereditary chief controlling surplus | Sacred descent, mana | Chief's court, tapu, fines | Polynesia, Trobriand, Khasi |
| State | Bureaucracy with monopoly of force | Divine kingship, then constitution | Codified law, courts, police | Early kingdoms, modern India |
As scale grows, power moves from persons to offices, legitimacy from kinship and the sacred to law, and social control from diffuse to organised sanctions. Kachin oscillation and India's legal pluralism show that this change is neither linear nor complete.
The other parts of Q3
- Q3(b)Human evolution is a product of both biological and cultural factors. Elaborate.
15 marks · Human Evolution and Primates · Theories of organic evolution
- Q3(c)Give the distribution of Palaeolithic sites around the Himalayan and Sub-Himalayan areas, highlighting the typo-technologies of the tools.
15 marks · Prehistoric Archaeology · Palaeolithic, Mesolithic and Neolithic cultures
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking