
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2025 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2025 Paper 2 · Q7(c): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements.
Critically evaluate the concept of Nation-State and describe its impact on indigenous societies.
Syllabus: Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements · Tribe-state relations and integration
Nation-stateImagined communitiesIndigenous peoplesState-nation
A nation-state is a sovereign state whose people are assumed to form one nation, sharing culture, language or history, so that political and cultural boundaries coincide. The model grew in Europe after the Peace of Westphalia (1648) and the French Revolution and, through decolonisation, became the world's standard political unit. For indigenous peoples it has meant both protection and loss.
1. The concept
| Thinker and work | View |
|---|---|
| Max Weber, Politics as a Vocation (1919) | The state holds a monopoly of legitimate force over a territory |
| Ernest Gellner, Nations and Nationalism (1983) | Industrial society needs one shared culture; nationalism creates nations |
| Benedict Anderson, Imagined Communities (1983) | The nation is imagined through print, census, maps and museums |
| Hobsbawm and Ranger, The Invention of Tradition (1983) | Many national traditions are recently invented |
| Anthony D. Smith, The Ethnic Origins of Nations (1986) | Nations grow out of older ethnic cores |
2. Critical evaluation
- Myth of homogeneity: Walker Connor ("Nation-Building or Nation-Destroying?", 1972) showed that very few states are ethnically homogeneous, so nation-building often meant suppressing minorities.
- Simplifying people: James C. Scott (Seeing Like a State, 1998) shows how states make people "legible" through census, cadastral maps and fixed names; his The Art of Not Being Governed (2009) describes upland peoples of Southeast Asia (Zomia) who long kept states at a distance.
- Order without the state: Evans-Pritchard's The Nuer (1940) and Pierre Clastres (Society Against the State, 1974) show stateless societies keeping order, questioning the state's universality.
- Strengths: The nation-state provides citizenship, rights, a common market and the machinery for welfare and protection.
- Alternative: India is better described as a state-nation (Stepan, Linz and Yadav, Crafting State-Nations, 2011), which accommodates many cultural nations within one state.
3. Impact on indigenous societies
- Territory and resources: Eminent domain, forest laws (Indian Forest Acts of 1878 and 1927) and mining turned commons into state property; elsewhere the doctrine of terra nullius justified dispossession until Australia's Mabo judgment (1992).
- Borders dividing peoples: Nagas and Kuki-Zo-Chin peoples live across the India–Myanmar border and Santals across the India–Bangladesh border; fencing and curbs on the Free Movement Regime (2024) strain their kinship and trade.
- Assimilation: National languages, schools and religions press on indigenous cultures; Canada's Truth and Reconciliation Commission (2015) called its residential schools cultural genocide. In India, Verrier Elwin's early protectionism (The Loss of Nerve, 1941) contrasted with G.S. Ghurye's view of tribes as "backward Hindus" (1943).
- Classification and citizenship: Census categories and ST lists fix fluid identities, and citizenship verification unsettles border communities.
- Militarisation: Insurgency and laws such as AFSPA (1958) have shaped life in parts of the North-East.
- Protection and recognition: The same state offers safeguards (Fifth and Sixth Schedules, PESA, FRA) and international norms such as ILO Convention 107 (ratified by India in 1958) and UNDRIP (2007); India voted for UNDRIP but holds that all its citizens are indigenous, using the category Scheduled Tribes instead.
The nation-state is a powerful but historically recent form that rarely fits the cultural map. For indigenous societies it has been a source of both dispossession and protection; plural, federal state-nation arrangements with self-governance and free, prior and informed consent offer a fairer balance.
The other parts of Q7
- Q7(a)Identify the contemporary limitations in the process of tribal development. How can anthropological knowledge contribute in this process?
20 marks · Tribal Development · Role of NGOs and anthropology in development
- Q7(b)Discuss the rising ethnic conflicts in India and propose their possible remedial measures.
15 marks · Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements · Ethnicity, regionalism and political movements
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking