
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2025 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2025 Paper 2 · Q4(c): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Tribal Situation in India.
Critically examine the concept of Scheduled Tribe (ST) and mention the limitations of administrator's criteria.
Syllabus: Tribal Situation in India · Classification and distribution of tribes
Article 342Lokur criteriaTribe as a social categorySelf-identification
The Constitution does not define a tribe. Article 366(25) defines Scheduled Tribes as communities deemed to be so under Article 342: the President notifies them for each state after consulting the Governor, and only Parliament can amend the list. The Lokur Committee (1965) framed the working tests used by administrators: primitive traits, distinctive culture, geographical isolation, shyness of contact with the wider community, and backwardness.
1. The concept: anthropological views
- Classical definitions: Lewis Henry Morgan (Ancient Society, 1877) saw the tribe as a stage of evolution; D.N. Majumdar stressed a common name, territory, language, marriage rules and mutual obligations.
- Tribe or backward Hindu: G.S. Ghurye (1943) called tribes "backward Hindus", while N.K. Bose (1941) described the Hindu method of tribal absorption; Surajit Sinha saw a tribe–caste continuum.
- No clear boundary: André Béteille (1986) argued that no single test separates tribe from caste in India; Virginius Xaxa stresses that tribes are distinct societies with their own identity, not merely backward groups.
- Tribe as a product of the state: Morton Fried (The Notion of Tribe, 1975) argued that many tribes are secondary formations shaped by contact with states; Indian categories grew out of colonial censuses.
- Indigeneity: India backed the UN declaration on indigenous peoples (2007) but treats all citizens as indigenous; many communities identify as Adivasi.
2. The administrative concept
- Colonial lineage: "animists" (Census 1901), "hill and forest tribes" (1921), "primitive tribes" (1931) and "backward tribes" (Government of India Act, 1935) fed into the first ST Order of 1950.
- State-specific lists: a community is scheduled only in particular states; Census 2011 counted 10.43 crore STs (8.6%) in about 705 notified communities.
3. Limitations of the administrator's criteria
- Evolutionist and condescending: "primitive traits" and "shyness of contact" echo colonial evolutionism; the 2014 Task Force under Hrusikesh Panda called the criteria obsolete.
- Vague and subjective: "primitive" or "distinctive" cannot be measured, and the Registrar General leans on old census ethnographies; self-identification plays no formal role.
- Static view of culture: education, Christianity or Hindu practices and urban life mean that many listed groups, such as the Mizo, Khasi or Meena, no longer fit a literal reading, while other isolated groups remain outside the list.
- Inconsistency across states: Santhal, Munda, Oraon and Gond workers in Assam's tea gardens are not STs there though they are in Jharkhand.
- Political pressure: demands by strong groups, such as Gujjars in Rajasthan, six communities in Assam, the Paharis of Jammu and Kashmir (listed in 2024) and the Meitei claim before the Manipur violence of 2023, often outweigh criteria.
- Blind to inequality: benefits concentrate among advanced STs while the 75 PVTGs lag, as the Xaxa Committee (2014) noted.
- Reform stalled: the Task Force proposed socio-economic backwardness, historical isolation, a distinct language, a core culture and endogamy, but the Registrar General still applies the 1965 tests.
The ST category is a politico-administrative construct resting on dated anthropology. Transparent criteria that combine evidence of distinct identity with measurable deprivation, and that respect self-identification, would make scheduling fairer.
The other parts of Q4
- Q4(a)What are the different types of caste mobility in India? Highlight the various factors responsible for it.
20 marks · Caste System · Dominant caste and caste mobility
- Q4(b)Elucidate the role of demographic and social factors for population growth in India.
15 marks · Demographic Profile of India · Population distribution and growth
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking