
Photo: Bhimbetka rock paintings, Yann, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2025 · Paper I
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2025 Paper 1 · Q4(c): model answer
Anthropology Paper I: Foundations of Anthropology, Human Evolution, Culture, Society and Human Genetics · Religion.
Critically examine James Frazer's theory of evolutionism. Elucidate the place of religion in modernity.
Syllabus: Religion · Magic, science and religion
Classical evolutionismSympathetic magicSecularisationDesecularisation
Sir James Frazer, a Cambridge "armchair" scholar, set out in The Golden Bough (1890; twelve volumes by 1915) an evolutionary scheme in which human thought passed from magic to religion to science. Like E.B. Tylor and L.H. Morgan, he assumed the psychic unity of humankind and relied on the comparative method.
1. Frazer's theory
- Magic: a mistaken association of ideas, "a false science as well as an abortive art". Sympathetic magic has two forms: homoeopathic (like produces like, as in harming an effigy) and contagious (things once in contact stay linked, as in sorcery with hair or nail clippings).
- Religion: "a propitiation or conciliation of powers superior to man", adopted when people realised that magic failed.
- Science: a return to the idea of an ordered nature, now governed by correct, tested laws.
- Other themes: the priest-king of Nemi, divine kingship and dying-and-reviving gods; Totemism and Exogamy (1910).
2. Critical examination
- Armchair method: he used missionaries' and travellers' reports torn from context; Malinowski's fieldwork replaced this.
- Coexistence, not sequence: Malinowski (Magic, Science and Religion, 1925) showed Trobrianders relying on skill in the safe lagoon but adding magic for dangerous open-sea fishing; magic relieves anxiety rather than marking an earlier stage.
- Other rationalities: Evans-Pritchard (Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande, 1937) showed witchcraft beliefs to be logical within their premises, and later (Theories of Primitive Religion, 1965) mocked the "if I were a horse" guesswork of intellectualists; Wittgenstein's remarks on Frazer found him narrower than the peoples he described.
- Religion as social: Durkheim (The Elementary Forms of Religious Life, 1912) traced religion to collective life; R.R. Marett proposed animatism before animism.
- Ethnocentrism: placing European science at the summit justified colonial hierarchy.
- Lasting value: his classification of magic is still used, and neo-evolutionists revived evolutionism in universal (Leslie White) and multilinear (Julian Steward) forms.
3. Place of religion in modernity
- Secularisation thesis: Max Weber's "disenchantment of the world" predicted religion's retreat; Peter Berger (The Sacred Canopy, 1967) agreed but later (The Desecularization of the World, 1999) admitted religion had revived.
- Religion in public life: José Casanova (1994) traced its return to politics; Charles Taylor (A Secular Age, 2007) saw belief as one option among many; Talal Asad (2003) showed the secular itself to be a historical construct.
- New forms: guru movements, televangelism, online darshan and e-puja, and mass pilgrimages such as the Kumbh Mela managed with modern technology.
- Magic persists: Jean and John Comaroff (Modernity and Its Malcontents, 1993) found occult beliefs thriving in market economies; in India, witch-hunting continues, prompting laws such as Maharashtra's anti-black-magic Act (2013), passed after Narendra Dabholkar's murder.
- Coexistence: scientists praying before launches and sacred groves protecting biodiversity show science and religion working side by side.
| View | Thinker and work | Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Secularisation | Weber; Berger (1967) | Rationalisation erodes religion |
| Desecularisation | Berger (1999) | Religion revives and globalises |
| Deprivatisation | Casanova (1994) | Religion re-enters public life |
| Secular age | Taylor (2007) | Belief becomes one option among many |
| Occult modernity | Jean and John Comaroff (1993) | Magic adapts to markets |
Frazer was right that thought changes but wrong to arrange magic, religion and science as a ladder. Modernity has transformed rather than replaced religion, which persists as identity, ethics and community.
The other parts of Q4
- Q4(a)Anthropology provides a multidimensional understanding of human beings by bridging the gap between science and humanities. Elucidate.
20 marks · Foundations of Anthropology · Relationship with other disciplines
- Q4(b)Write a note on Mousterian tool tradition, Mousterian culture and its makers.
15 marks · Prehistoric Archaeology · Palaeolithic, Mesolithic and Neolithic cultures
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking