
Photo: Bhimbetka rock paintings, Yann, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2025 · Paper I
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2025 Paper 1 · Q3(b): model answer
Anthropology Paper I: Foundations of Anthropology, Human Evolution, Culture, Society and Human Genetics · The Nature of Culture and Society.
Critically examine the drawbacks in assuming culture as an 'integrated-closed' system in understanding of contemporary society.
Syllabus: The Nature of Culture and Society · Concept and characteristics of culture
HolismBounded cultureGlobal flowsAgency and power
Classical anthropology often pictured each society as an integrated whole and a closed, bounded unit. Malinowski's functionalism treated institutions as interlocking parts meeting needs, and Ruth Benedict's Patterns of Culture (1934) gave each people a single configuration. This holism produced rich ethnography, but as a model of contemporary society it has serious drawbacks.
1. Merits of the model
- Interconnection: it showed how institutions fit together, as the Trobriand kula linked trade, magic, politics and prestige (Argonauts of the Western Pacific, 1922).
- Relativism and fieldwork: it supported cultural relativism and long fieldwork in small, fairly isolated groups.
2. Drawbacks
- Static and ahistorical: the "ethnographic present" froze societies in time. Eric Wolf (Europe and the People Without History, 1982) criticised the image of cultures as separate "billiard balls" and traced centuries of trade, colonialism and migration.
- Hides conflict and inconsistency: Edmund Leach's Kachin (Political Systems of Highland Burma, 1954) oscillated between egalitarian gumlao and hierarchical gumsa forms; Max Gluckman showed conflict built into custom.
- Homogenises: treating culture as equally shared hides differences of gender, age, caste and class; Lila Abu-Lughod's "Writing against Culture" (1991) argued that the concept freezes difference and creates "others".
- Ties culture to territory: Akhil Gupta and James Ferguson (1992) showed that people, places and cultures no longer coincide; Arjun Appadurai's Modernity at Large (1996) described global flows of people, media, technology, money and ideas.
- Denies agency and hybridity: practice theory (Bourdieu, Sherry Ortner) and Marshall Sahlins (Islands of History, 1985) showed people remaking culture through action; Ulf Hannerz described cultural creolisation.
- Harmful policy uses: Oscar Lewis's "culture of poverty" was read as blaming the poor, and colonial images of "isolated tribes" justified segregation.
| Aspect | Integrated-closed model | Contemporary open view |
|---|---|---|
| Boundaries | Fixed and territorial | Porous: migration, diaspora, media |
| Change | Rare, imposed from outside | Constant, internal and external |
| Sharing | Uniform across members | Contested by gender, class, caste, age |
| Integration | Tight functional fit | Partial and loose |
| Method | Single-site holistic study | Multi-sited ethnography (George Marcus, 1995) |
3. Indian evidence
- Tribes were never sealed: N.K. Bose's "Hindu method of tribal absorption" (1941) and Surajit Sinha's tribe–caste continuum show long interaction; the Elwin–Ghurye debate on isolation or assimilation rested on these assumptions.
- Open, hybrid cultures today: Gond painting in global art markets, Naga Christianity alongside the Hornbill Festival, Gulf migration reshaping Kerala households and tribal youth on social media.
4. A balanced view
- Pattern is real: the Toda buffalo-dairy complex studied by W.H.R. Rivers (1906) tied economy, ritual and rank together, so integration should not be denied altogether.
- Partial integration: Clifford Geertz compared culture to an octopus, loosely integrated rather than a seamless web; the task is to study pattern together with process, power and connection.
A closed, integrated notion of culture cannot explain a world of globalisation, mobility and contested identities; anthropology now treats culture as open, historical and negotiated.
The other parts of Q3
- Q3(a)How anthropologists assess the nutritional status of a community? Discuss the significance of intersectionality of ecology, culture, and social inequality in the study of nutritional anthropology.
20 marks · Human Growth, Nutrition and Demography · Nutrition and health
- Q3(c)Differentiate between pedigree and genealogical analyses. Discuss the history and application of these methods in anthropological studies.
15 marks · Human Genetics · Methods and principles of human genetics
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking