
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2024 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2024 Paper 2 · Q8(c): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Problems of Tribal Communities.
Discuss the economic, social and developmental impacts on tribal communities with special reference to mining.
Syllabus: Problems of Tribal Communities · Displacement and rehabilitation
Resource curseDisplacementFifth ScheduleBenefit sharing
India's coal, iron ore and bauxite belts overlap heavily with the Fifth Schedule tribal areas of Jharkhand, Odisha and Chhattisgarh. Mining brings revenue to the nation but often displacement and dispossession to the tribal communities who live on the land, a paradox called the resource curse. Walter Fernandes estimated that about 40% of the roughly 60 million people displaced or affected by development projects between 1947 and 2004 are tribal.
1. Economic impacts
- Loss of land and commons: acquisition of fields, forests and grazing land destroys a mixed economy of farming, forest produce and hunting; cash compensation is soon spent, and landless users of the commons often get nothing.
- Insecure wage work: few tribal people get skilled mining jobs; most become casual, contract or migrant labourers, and women lose forest-based livelihoods.
- Inflation and debt: the inflow of outsiders, money and markets raises prices and strengthens traders and moneylenders.
- Gains: roads, markets, some jobs and the District Mineral Foundation, created by the MMDR Amendment Act (2015) to spend a share of royalty on mining-affected people through PMKKKY.
2. Social and cultural impacts
- Impoverishment risks: Michael Cernea's model (1997) lists landlessness, joblessness, homelessness, marginalisation, food insecurity, ill health, loss of common property and social disarticulation, all visible in mining displacement.
- Broken kinship and institutions: resettlement scatters clans and villages and weakens customary councils and mutual aid.
- Loss of the sacred: hills, sarna groves and burial grounds anchor identity; the Dongria Kondh revere Niyamgiri as the domain of Niyam Raja.
- Health and gender: dust, silicosis and tuberculosis among quarry workers, polluted water and alcoholism; women face harassment and loss of control over resources.
- Industrial transition: L.P. Vidyarthi's study of industrialisation in tribal Bihar (1970) recorded new wage work alongside land loss and cultural strain around Chotanagpur's new industrial centres.
- Conflict: resistance at Niyamgiri and Hasdeo Arand (Chhattisgarh); the Planning Commission's Expert Group (2008) linked such alienation to the spread of Left-wing extremism.
3. Developmental impacts
- Wealth without welfare: mineral districts such as West Singhbhum (Jharkhand) and Dantewada (Chhattisgarh) remain Aspirational Districts despite large revenues.
- Ecological costs: deforestation, falling water tables and polluted rivers erode the base of future development.
- Legal correctives: Samatha (1997) barred the lease of tribal land in Scheduled Areas to private non-tribal mining firms; in Orissa Mining Corporation v. MoEF (2013) the Supreme Court let gram sabhas decide on Niyamgiri, and all twelve rejected bauxite mining.
- Anthropological critique: Felix Padel and Samarendra Das (Out of This Earth, 2010) show how mining for global markets reshapes tribal landscapes, while the Xaxa Committee (2014) identified displacement and land alienation as central causes of tribal deprivation.
| Safeguard | Promise | Gap in practice |
|---|---|---|
| PESA 1996 | Gram sabha consulted on acquisition and minor minerals | Weak State rules and token consultation |
| FRA 2006 | Forest rights settled before diversion | Claims pending; consent contested |
| Land acquisition law 2013 | Social impact assessment, consent, rehabilitation | Coal-bearing land is acquired under a 1957 Act, outside its consent and assessment rules |
| District Mineral Foundation | Royalty share for affected people | Funds often spent far from affected villages |
Mining can aid tribal development only if it moves from extraction to benefit sharing: prior informed consent of gram sabhas, land-for-land rehabilitation, tribal control of DMF funds and mine-closure restoration would make it inclusive development.
The other parts of Q8
- Q8(a)Describe the important Paleolithic sites from South India with suitable examples. What is the significance of South Indian Paleolithic cultures?
20 marks · Evolution of Indian Culture and Civilisation · Prehistoric India
- Q8(b)Distinguish a 'Theocratic State' from a secular, liberal, democratic state. Illustrate your answer with examples from tribal and contemporary societies.
15 marks · Minorities and Social Change · Linguistic and religious minorities
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking