
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2024 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2024 Paper 2 · Q6(a): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Problems of Tribal Communities.
Custodians of natural resources are the tribals, but they are the most deprived. Critically examine how climate change will impact their survival in future.
Syllabus: Problems of Tribal Communities · Forest policy and forest rights
Custodians of natureClimate vulnerabilityTraditional ecological knowledgeClimate justice
India's Scheduled Tribes (10.43 crore, 8.6% of the population, Census 2011) live mostly in forests, hills, drylands and islands, where sacred groves, rotational farming and community rules have conserved the landscape. Yet they lag on almost every indicator of well-being: in 2011–12, 45.3% of rural STs were below the poverty line (Tendulkar method). This paradox of custodianship leaves them highly exposed to climate change, which they did little to cause.
1. Custodians, yet deprived
- Conservation ethic: the Dongria Kondh revere the Niyamgiri hills as the domain of Niyam Raja; Khasi villages protect sacred forests such as Mawphlang; the Baiga refused to plough "Mother Earth" (Verrier Elwin, The Baiga, 1939).
- Dispossession: colonial forest laws turned commons into State property, and dams and mines displaced tribal people; Amita Baviskar's In the Belly of the River (1995) traced this for the Bhilala of the Narmada valley.
- Unfinished recognition: the Forest Rights Act 2006 admitted a "historical injustice", but community forest rights remain far from fully recognised.
2. How climate change threatens survival
- Food and livelihood: tribal farming is largely rain-fed; erratic monsoons, droughts and heatwaves cut yields of millets, pulses and paddy.
- Forest produce: shifts in the flowering and fruiting of mahua, sal and tendu, and more frequent forest fires (Similipal, 2021), shrink incomes and diets.
- Water and pastures: drying springs in the Himalaya and north-eastern hills, and erratic snowfall and shrinking pastures for pastoralists such as the Changpa of Ladakh and the Gaddi.
- Health: heat stress and the spread of malaria and other vector-borne diseases in belts already burdened by anaemia, sickle cell disease and undernutrition.
- Islands and coasts: sea-level rise and cyclones threaten the Nicobarese and other island communities, as the 2004 tsunami showed.
- Culture: distress migration to brick kilns and cities loosens ties with sacred sites, language and ecological knowledge.
3. The added risk of climate "solutions"
- Green grabbing: compensatory plantations, large hydropower dams, solar parks and mining of critical minerals can take tribal commons in the name of mitigation, and carbon projects may bypass gram sabhas.
| Region | Communities (examples) | Main stress |
|---|---|---|
| Central Indian plateau | Gond, Santal, Munda, Kondh | Drought, heat, erratic monsoon, forest fires |
| North-East hills | Khasi, Garo, Naga, Mizo | Extreme rain, landslides, drying springs |
| Himalaya and Ladakh | Changpa, Gaddi, Bhotia | Glacial retreat, erratic snow, pasture loss |
| Western Ghats | Soliga, Irula, Kurumba | Rainfall shifts, human–wildlife conflict |
| Islands | Nicobarese, Onge, Jarawa | Sea-level rise, cyclones, coastal erosion |
4. Critical appraisal
- Not passive victims: traditional ecological knowledge — diverse seeds and millets, Apatani rice–fish farming, community fire lines — is recognised by the IPCC (Sixth Assessment, 2022) as vital for adaptation.
- Against romanticism: Kent Redford's critique of the "ecologically noble savage" (1991) warns that conservation is livelihood-based, not innate; Guha and Martinez-Alier call it an "environmentalism of the poor".
- Structural roots: vulnerability springs as much from insecure land rights, poor services and exclusion from decisions as from climate itself; infrastructure schemes such as PM-JANMAN (2023, ₹24,104 crore for PVTGs) and DAJGUA (2024, ₹79,156 crore) need a climate-adaptation lens.
Tribal people are front-line victims but also knowledge holders. Securing community forest rights, gram sabha consent under PESA and tribal-led adaptation would turn custodianship into climate justice.
The other parts of Q6
- Q6(b)Elucidate the difference between secularism, religiosity, religious fundamentalism and spiritualism from an anthropological perspective.
15 marks · Religion and the Sacred Complex in India · Sacred complex and nature-man-spirit complex
- Q6(c)Discuss the contribution of P.K. Bhowmick in decriminalising the status of the Lodha tribe.
15 marks · Anthropology in India · Contributions of Indian anthropologists
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking