
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2024 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2024 Paper 2 · Q3(b): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Indian Village and Peasantry.
Compare and contrast the approaches of M.N. Srinivas and L.P. Vidyarthi to social change in village India.
Syllabus: Indian Village and Peasantry · Village studies and the village as a social system
SanskritisationDominant casteSacred complexNature-Man-Spirit complex
Two influential lenses shaped the study of change in village India. M.N. Srinivas, trained under G.S. Ghurye at Bombay and at Oxford in structural-functionalism, explained change through caste mobility in a single village, Rampura. L.P. Vidyarthi, trained at Lucknow and at Chicago under Robert Redfield, used a civilisational and holistic approach that linked villages and tribes to sacred centres, ecology and industry.
1. Srinivas's approach
- Field view: he held that intensive fieldwork, not texts (the "book view"), reveals how caste actually works; his Rampura fieldwork is recalled in The Remembered Village (1976).
- Sanskritisation: introduced in Religion and Society among the Coorgs of South India, published in 1952: a lower caste or tribe adopts the rituals, diet and beliefs of a higher caste to claim higher rank, bringing positional change without structural change.
- Dominant caste: a caste with numerical strength, land, and economic and political power, such as the Okkaligas of Rampura ("The Dominant Caste in Rampura", 1959), sets local models and settles disputes.
- Westernisation and secularisation: Social Change in Modern India (1966) traced the effects of British rule, education, law and technology on caste and ritual.
2. Vidyarthi's approach
- Sacred complex: in The Sacred Complex in Hindu Gaya (1961) he showed how sacred geography, sacred performances and sacred specialists (the Gayawal priests) tie pilgrims from countless villages to a centre of the great tradition.
- Nature-Man-Spirit complex: in The Maler (1963), on the Sauria Paharia of the Rajmahal hills, ecology, social life and the spirit world form one interdependent whole, so a change in one, such as forest loss, transforms the others.
- Industrialisation and planned change: his study of tribal villages around the Hatia industrial area near Ranchi (Socio-cultural Implications of Industrialisation in India, 1970) traced land loss, migration and wage labour; he argued for an applied, problem-solving anthropology in tribal development.
| Aspect | M.N. Srinivas | L.P. Vidyarthi |
|---|---|---|
| Training | Bombay (Ghurye), Oxford | Lucknow, Chicago (Redfield) |
| Framework | Structural-functional | Civilisational, holistic, applied |
| Unit of study | One multi-caste village (Rampura) | Sacred centre, tribal hills, industrial belt |
| Key concepts | Sanskritisation, Westernisation, dominant caste | Sacred complex, Nature-Man-Spirit complex |
| Drivers of change | Caste mobility, land, numbers, education | Pilgrimage, ecology, industry, planning |
| Main subjects | Caste Hindus of south India | Tribes and pilgrims of Bihar and Jharkhand |
3. Points of convergence
- Fieldwork: both relied on long, first-hand fieldwork rather than texts alone.
- Village and civilisation: both saw the village as linked to a wider civilisation; Sanskritisation and the sacred complex are both channels between the little and great traditions of Robert Redfield, applied to India also by McKim Marriott.
- Continuity: both treated change as adaptive and gradual rather than a break with tradition.
4. Critical evaluation
- Srinivas: Yogendra Singh (Modernization of Indian Tradition, 1973) and others noted that his concepts are cultural and say little about class, conflict or structural change; Sanskritisation takes a Brahmanical model as the norm and does not explain Dalit assertion against the caste order.
- Vidyarthi: richer on ecology and applied concerns, but largely descriptive; the sacred complex stresses integration and harmony more than power and inequality.
Srinivas explained who moves up and how within the caste order, while Vidyarthi showed how villages and tribes are bound to civilisation, ecology and industry; read together, they offer a fuller picture of social change in village India.
The other parts of Q3
- Q3(a)Critically describe evidences from Rakhi Garhi and its linkages to Harappan civilization.
20 marks · Evolution of Indian Culture and Civilisation · Protohistoric and Harappan civilisation
- Q3(c)Examine the impact of Forest Policies from 1878 to 2006 on land alienation and deprivation of rights of tribal communities in India.
15 marks · Problems of Tribal Communities · Forest policy and forest rights
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking