
Photo: Bhimbetka rock paintings, Yann, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2024 · Paper I
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2024 Paper 1 · Q6(c): model answer
Anthropology Paper I: Foundations of Anthropology, Human Evolution, Culture, Society and Human Genetics · Anthropological Theories.
How does Lévi-Strauss look at the Tsimshian myth of Asdiwal? Critically discuss Lévi-Strauss' theory of structuralism in the light of his study of mythologies.
Syllabus: Anthropological Theories · Structuralism and symbolic-interpretive approaches
StructuralismThe Story of Asdiwal (1958)Binary oppositionsMediation of contradictions
Claude Lévi-Strauss treated myth like language: its meaning lies not in single episodes but in the relations between them. In "La Geste d'Asdiwal" (1958), translated as "The Story of Asdiwal" (1967), he analysed a myth of the Tsimshian of the Skeena and Nass rivers in British Columbia, using Franz Boas's versions, the main one written down by the Tsimshian Henry Tate (Tsimshian Texts, 1912; Tsimshian Mythology, 1916).
1. The myth in brief
- Famine: in a winter famine on the frozen Skeena, a widowed mother from downstream and her widowed daughter from upstream meet halfway; a supernatural visitor feeds them and fathers Asdiwal.
- Sky: Asdiwal follows a white she-bear to the sky, marries Evening Star, daughter of the Sun, survives his father-in-law's tests, but grows homesick and loses her.
- Sea and death: he marries mortal women, quarrels with his brothers-in-law, is abandoned on a reef and taken to the sea lions' underground home, where he heals them; finally, hunting on a mountain without his snowshoes, he is turned to stone.
2. Lévi-Strauss's reading
- Sequences and schemata: beneath the order of events lie four codes, geographic, economic, sociological and cosmological, repeating one pattern of oppositions.
- Matrilocal marriage tested: the Tsimshian were matrilineal and preferred residence with the husband's kin, yet every marriage of Asdiwal is matrilocal and each one fails. The myth imagines the opposite of real practice in order to show that it cannot work, and so justifies the actual order.
- Transformations: the Nass river version inverts many elements; variants of a myth are logical transformations of one another.
| Code | Opposition | How the myth plays it out |
|---|---|---|
| Geographic | East–west, upstream–downstream | Journey from the river interior to the sea |
| Economic | Famine–plenty, mountain–sea hunting | Asdiwal masters both but dies on a mountain |
| Sociological | Matrilocal–patrilocal residence | All his matrilocal marriages break down |
| Cosmological | Sky–earth–underworld | Visits to the Sun and to the sea lions |
3. Structuralism in his study of mythology
- Mythemes: "The Structural Study of Myth" (1955) broke the Oedipus story into units arranged in columns, showing how myth mediates contradictions such as autochthony versus birth from two parents.
- Mythologiques (1964–71): four volumes, from The Raw and the Cooked, trace transformations across more than 800 American myths around oppositions like raw–cooked and nature–culture.
- Universal mind: myths are a "bricolage" of available materials worked by the mind's binary logic (The Savage Mind, 1962); he aimed to show "how myths operate in men's minds without their being aware of the fact".
4. Critical evaluation
- Contributions: revealed order beneath seemingly absurd stories, inspiring Edmund Leach's "Genesis as Myth" and, in India, Veena Das's Structure and Cognition (1977).
- Unverifiable and reductive: Mary Douglas (1967), commenting on Asdiwal, admired the analysis but doubted that the structure it reveals is the meaning of a myth, and noted that such analyses are hard to test.
- Mind without people: Geertz ("The Cerebral Savage", 1967) attacked its intellectualism, and Ricoeur called it "Kantianism without a transcendental subject"; it ignores narrators, performance, emotion and power.
- Ahistorical and imposed: binary pairs may reflect the analyst more than the culture; he worked from translated texts, and his reading of Tsimshian kinship has been debated; Derrida (1966) rejected a fixed structural centre.
The Asdiwal study remains the clearest demonstration of structural analysis: myth as a logical tool for living with contradictions. Though abstract and hard to verify, it deeply shaped symbolic anthropology.
The other parts of Q6
- Q6(a)Discuss the geographical distribution of Homo erectus. Taking into account its physical features, where does it fit in human evolutionary line?
20 marks · Human Evolution and Primates · Fossil hominins and human origins
- Q6(b)Discuss the applications of forensic anthropology with suitable examples.
15 marks · Applied Anthropology · Forensic and sports anthropology
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking