
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2023 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2023 Paper 2 · Q4(b): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Demographic Profile of India.
Critically compare Risley's and Sarkar's approaches to the classification of peoples of India.
Syllabus: Demographic Profile of India · Ethnic and linguistic elements
Racial classificationAnthropometryNasal and cephalic indexAustraloid substratum
Early physical anthropology tried to sort India's people into racial types. H.H. Risley, Census Commissioner for 1901, did so through anthropometry in The People of India (1908), tying race to caste. The physical anthropologist S.S. Sarkar proposed a different scheme in The Aboriginal Races of India (1954), giving the Australoid tribes the place of India's oldest population.
1. Risley's approach
- Data and method: measurements of head, nose and stature collected from the late 1880s, chiefly the nasal index and cephalic index, read against caste and region.
- Seven types: Turko-Iranian, Indo-Aryan, Scytho-Dravidian, Aryo-Dravidian, Mongolo-Dravidian, Mongoloid and Dravidian; he treated the Dravidian, Indo-Aryan and Mongoloid as primary stocks and most others as crosses.
- Race explains caste: he held that a caste's rank fell as its nasal index rose, and traced caste to Aryan conquerors' contact with darker natives; his 1901 Census ranking of castes set off petitions for higher status.
2. Sarkar's approach
- Method: the 1954 scheme rests mainly on the cephalic index; his team's later work added ABO blood groups and dermatoglyphics.
- Six elements: Australoid, Indo-Aryan, Irano-Scythian, Mundari-speaking, Far Eastern and Mongolian.
- Key claims: Australoids (many tribes of central and southern India) form the earliest substratum; the Mundari-speakers of Chota Nagpur are a distinct group with eastern links; and his team's study of the Kadar (1959) found no Negrito element, unlike B.S. Guha's scheme (1935).
| Aspect | Risley (1908) | Sarkar (1954) |
|---|---|---|
| Setting | Colonial census and administration | Post-independence physical anthropology |
| Main traits | Nasal index, cephalic index, stature | Cephalic index; blood groups in later work |
| Number of types | Seven | Six |
| Place of tribes | Within a broad Dravidian type | Australoid substratum; Munda separate |
| Negrito element | Not identified | Rejected for mainland India |
| Link with caste | Caste explained by race | Caste not reduced to race |
3. Critical comparison
- Common ground: both were typological, treated averages as fixed types and mixed racial with linguistic labels.
- Risley's weaknesses: uneven samples, a racial theory of caste and a colonial purpose; Franz Boas (1912) showed that head form changes within a generation in a new environment, undermining the cephalic index, and Nicholas Dirks (Castes of Mind, 2001) showed how such census work hardened caste.
- Sarkar's advance: his team later added blood-group and dermatoglyphic evidence, and he recognised the tribal substratum and the separate identity of Munda-speakers, a point echoed by later genetic work linking the paternal lineages of Austroasiatic speakers to Southeast Asia.
- Sarkar's limits: cephalic index stayed central, the "Far Eastern" element was vague, and race remained the unit of analysis.
- 1908 Risley: seven types, The People of India
- 1935 Guha: six races from Census 1931 data
- 1954 Sarkar: six elements, Australoid substratum
- 1972 Lewontin: most human variation lies within populations
- 2009 Reich et al.: Ancestral North and South Indian components
4. Present position
- Clines, not races: Richard Lewontin (1972) found that most human genetic variation lies within populations, and Reich and colleagues (Nature, 2009) described Indian groups as mixtures of Ancestral North Indian and Ancestral South Indian components, kept distinct by long endogamy rather than by race.
Risley's scheme is now of historical interest, while Sarkar's recognition of the tribal substratum and later use of blood groups pointed towards population genetics; both remind us that classifying people must never imply a racial hierarchy.
The other parts of Q4
- Q4(a)Elucidate the problems faced by Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups and the major challenges in the formulation of special programmes for their development.
20 marks · Tribal Development · Particularly vulnerable tribal groups (PVTGs)
- Q4(c)Is caste mobility a recent phenomenon? Discuss in the light of Indological and Empirical context.
15 marks · Caste System · Dominant caste and caste mobility
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking