
Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2023 · Paper II
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2023 Paper 2 · Q3(c): model answer
Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements.
Critically examine the impact of modern democratic institutions on contemporary tribal societies. Illustrate with suitable ethnographic examples.
Syllabus: Tribe-State Relations, Ethnicity and Movements · Tribe-state relations and integration
Customary self-governancePESA 1996Gram sabhaElite capture
Tribal societies have long governed themselves through customary institutions: Santhal manjhi–pargana councils, the manki–munda system of the Mundas and Hos, the Oraon parha, the Khasi dorbar shnong and Naga village councils. Since 1950 these have been overlaid by modern democratic institutions: adult franchise, reserved seats (Articles 330 and 332), Panchayati Raj, the PESA Act (1996), Sixth Schedule councils and Forest Rights Act (2006) gram sabhas.
1. Positive impacts
- Voice and representation: reserved seats have produced tribal legislators, ministers and Chief Ministers, and in 2022 Droupadi Murmu, a Santhal, became India's first tribal President; elections have also raised a young, educated leadership aware of constitutional rights.
- Gram sabha as self-rule: Mendha-Lekha, a Gond village in Gadchiroli (Maharashtra), decides by consensus in its gram sabha and was among the first to win community forest rights (2009) and the right to sell its bamboo (2011).
- Consent over resources: in 2013, after a Supreme Court order, twelve Dongria Kondh gram sabhas in Niyamgiri (Odisha) rejected bauxite mining.
- Women in office: reservation in panchayats has brought tribal women into public roles.
2. Negative and contradictory impacts
- Dual authority: where statutory panchayats ignore customary bodies, the pahan and parha of the Oraons lose authority and are confined to marriage and family disputes.
- Elite capture: educated, better-off families corner reserved posts and benefits, and party politics splits clans; F.G. Bailey (Politics and Social Change: Orissa in 1959, 1963) showed villagers, including those of the Kond hills, reaching the state through brokers who gained at others' expense.
- Gender within custom: Khasi dorbars traditionally excluded women despite matriliny, and Naga bodies opposed 33% reservation for women in urban local bodies, leading to violence in 2017; the elections were finally held with the quota in 2024.
- Law versus practice: several States delayed or diluted PESA rules; in the Pathalgadi movement (Khunti, Jharkhand, 2017–18), Munda villages carved PESA provisions on stone slabs and faced sedition cases, later withdrawn.
| Community | Customary body | Democratic overlay | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Santhal | Manjhi–pargana | Panchayats, parties | Parallel authority |
| Munda, Ho | Manki–munda | Panchayats, PESA | Pathalgadi assertion |
| Khasi | Dorbar shnong | Autonomous district council | Overlapping powers; women excluded |
| Naga | Village council | Urban local bodies | Women's quota contested |
3. Way forward
- Harmonise, not replace: as the Bhuria Committee (1995) and B.D. Sharma, a former Commissioner for SCs and STs, urged, customary councils should work through the gram sabha with clear roles.
- Real devolution: funds, functions and staff for gram sabhas, and accountable, gender-inclusive district councils.
Democracy has given tribes voice, rights and new leaders, but also stratification and friction with custom; it succeeds where elected bodies are rooted in tribal traditions of collective decision-making.
The other parts of Q3
- Q3(a)"Sanskritization is a culture-bound concept." Critically comment to assess the strength and limitation of this concept in developing a theoretical framework to study social change.
20 marks · Minorities and Social Change · Sanskritisation, Westernisation and modernisation
- Q3(b)Was Mesolithic culture the first step towards sedentary way of life? Illustrate your answer by citing suitable examples.
15 marks · Evolution of Indian Culture and Civilisation · Prehistoric India
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking