Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
Warli tribal paintings on a city wall in Mysuru

Photo: Warli paintings, Mysuru, Prof tpms, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2023 · Paper II

UPSC Anthropology Optional 2023 Paper 2 · Q2(a): model answer

Anthropology Paper II: Indian Anthropology: Indian Society, Caste, Village and Tribal India · Anthropology in India.

Q2(a)20 marks2023 · Paper II

"Tribes are backward Hindus." Critically comment with reference to the contributions of G. S. Ghurye.

Syllabus: Anthropology in India · Contributions of Indian anthropologists

Model answer · free

G.S. GhuryeBackward HindusAssimilationTribe–caste continuum

G.S. Ghurye (1893–1983), who headed the Department of Sociology at Bombay University and founded the Indian Sociological Society (1951), approached tribes through Indology, census data and history. In The Aborigines "So-called" and Their Future (1943; retitled The Scheduled Tribes in later editions) he argued that most tribes were "backward Hindus", imperfectly integrated sections of Hindu society, and pleaded for assimilation against Verrier Elwin's protective approach.

1. Ghurye's argument

  • No separate "aboriginal" category: he criticised British censuses for listing "animism" or "tribal religion" apart from Hinduism, a line drawn by administrators rather than by social reality.
  • A difference of degree: tribes worshipped Hindu deities, kept Hindu festivals, used Hinduised priests and borrowed caste norms, as census and gazetteer evidence showed.
  • Historical absorption: over centuries some tribal chiefs became Rajputs while many groups entered caste society, so tribes belonged to one civilisation.
  • Policy: he opposed the Excluded and Partially Excluded Areas of the Government of India Act, 1935 and Elwin's "national park" proposal, and sought education, economic uplift and protection from moneylenders and landlords.

2. His contributions

  • Documentation: he assembled census, gazetteer and ethnographic evidence of tribal–Hindu interaction, an early systematic treatment of the question.
  • Exploitation highlighted: he linked tribal distress to land alienation and debt, problems later commissions confirmed.
  • Wider legacy: Caste and Race in India (1932) and students such as M.N. Srinivas, Irawati Karve and A.R. Desai shaped Indian sociology and anthropology.
PositionView of tribesPrescriptionMain criticism
Ghurye: assimilationBackward HindusMerge through developmentDenies distinct identity
Elwin: protectionDistinct peoples harmed by contactShield from outsidersSeen as keeping "museums"
Nehru: integrationDistinct, yet part of the nationDevelop "along the lines of their own genius"Uneven implementation
Three positions in the tribal policy debate

3. Critical assessment

  • Elwin's opposing view: in The Loss of Nerve (1941) Elwin argued that Hinduisation brought caste disabilities and the loss of dormitories, dances and women's freedom.
  • Absorption as subordination: N.K. Bose (Hindu Method of Tribal Absorption, 1941) showed groups such as the Juang entering Hindu society mainly at its lower rungs.
  • Continuum, not identity: F.G. Bailey (Tribe, Caste and Nation, 1960) and Surajit Sinha ("Tribe-caste and tribe-peasant continua in Central India", 1965) placed tribe and caste at two ends of a continuum; some groups moved towards caste, others did not.
  • Regional exceptions: most tribes of the North-East, such as the Nagas, Mizos and Khasis, are Christian or follow indigenous faiths (Donyi-Polo, Seng Khasi).
  • Self-identity and law: the Jharkhand Assembly's 2020 resolution for a Sarna religion code, and the Hindu Marriage Act (1955) and Hindu Succession Act (1956), which apply to STs only if the Centre notifies, recognise distinct custom; Virginius Xaxa (1999) argued that tribes should be defined by their own societies, not by distance from caste Hindus.
  • Overlooked institutions: clan land, bride price and women's relatively higher status do not fit a "backward caste" model.

4. Relevance today

  • The middle path won: the Fifth and Sixth Schedules, Article 46, PESA (1996) and the Forest Rights Act (2006) protect distinct ways of life while integrating tribes.
  • A valid insight: Ghurye rightly saw long interaction with Hindu society, as Sanskritisation and the tribe–caste continuum confirm.

Ghurye's thesis was historically informed but assimilationist; anthropology today accepts interaction while respecting tribal self-identification, as the Constitution's integration approach intends.

The other parts of Q2

  1. Q2(b)"Indus Valley was the first settlement of the big civilization." Comment critically.

    15 marks · Evolution of Indian Culture and Civilisation · Protohistoric and Harappan civilisation

  2. Q2(c)Discuss the basic tenets of Jainism and its impact on Indian society.

    15 marks · Religion and the Sacred Complex in India · Impact of Buddhism, Jainism, Islam and Christianity

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149