
Photo: Bhimbetka rock paintings, Yann, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2023 · Paper I
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2023 Paper 1 · Q8(c): model answer
Anthropology Paper I: Foundations of Anthropology, Human Evolution, Culture, Society and Human Genetics · Marriage, Family and Kinship.
Critically discuss A.L. Kroeber's contribution to kinship studies.
Syllabus: Marriage, Family and Kinship · Kinship: descent, terminology and alliance
Kinship terminologyClassificatory systemsEight principlesPsychology versus sociology
A.L. Kroeber (1876–1960), Franz Boas's first doctoral student at Columbia, reshaped the study of kinship terms with his paper "Classificatory Systems of Relationship" (1909). Rejecting the sorting of kinship systems into "classificatory" and "descriptive" in Systems of Consanguinity and Affinity of the Human Family (Lewis Henry Morgan, 1871), he analysed kin terms through a small set of universal principles (categories) found in all languages.
1. Critique of Morgan
- No system is purely descriptive: the English word "uncle" covers father's brother, mother's brother and the husbands of both aunts, and "cousin" merges many relatives, so English also classifies; it simply uses fewer distinctions than many Native American systems.
- Against evolutionary guesswork: Morgan read terms as survivals of earlier forms such as group marriage; Kroeber held that they are poor evidence of past social stages.
2. The eight principles
Kroeber showed that every terminology selects some of eight distinctions and ignores others, so systems can be compared by the principles they use.
| Principle | Distinction drawn | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Generation | Kin of different generations | Father versus son |
| Lineal or collateral | Direct line versus side line | Father versus father's brother (chacha) |
| Relative age | Elder versus younger within a generation | Telugu anna (elder brother), tammudu (younger brother) |
| Sex of the relative | Male versus female | Brother versus sister |
| Sex of the speaker | Different words used by men and women | Found in many Native American languages |
| Sex of the connecting relative | Link through a male or a female | Hindi chacha (father's brother) versus mama (mother's brother) |
| Blood or marriage | Consanguines versus affines | Father versus father-in-law (sasur) |
| Condition of the connecting relative | Living or dead, married or not | Rare; special terms after the linking relative's death |
3. The psychology versus sociology debate
- Kroeber's thesis: kin terms are primarily linguistic and reflect ways of thinking; he concluded that "terms of relationship reflect psychology, not sociology", so they can support inferences about social life only with great caution.
- Rivers's reply: W.H.R. Rivers (Kinship and Social Organisation, 1914) argued that terms are shaped by social institutions; where cross-cousin marriage is practised, the mother's brother and the father-in-law share one term.
- Later support for Rivers: A.R. Radcliffe-Brown (1941) treated terminology as part of the social structure defining rights and duties, and Louis Dumont (1953) showed that Dravidian terminology expresses marriage alliance; in Tamil and Telugu, mama denotes both mother's brother and father-in-law.
- 1871 Morgan divides systems into classificatory and descriptive
- 1909 Kroeber's eight principles; terms reflect psychology
- 1914 Rivers links terms to forms of marriage
- 1941 Radcliffe-Brown: terminology as part of social structure
- 1949 Murdock's Social Structure builds typologies on these criteria
- 1953 Dumont: Dravidian terms express marriage alliance
- 1956 Goodenough and Lounsbury develop componential analysis
4. Evaluation
- Lasting tools: G.P. Murdock (Social Structure, 1949) used Kroeber's criteria, adding polarity to make nine, for his cross-cultural typology; Ward Goodenough and Floyd Lounsbury (1956) turned them into componential analysis of kin terms as bundles of semantic features.
- Neutral comparison: freed from evolutionary ranking, the principles suit Boasian historical particularism and Kroeber's own studies of Californian and Zuni kinship (1917).
- Criticism: the approach is formal and static, deals with words rather than behaviour, underrates marriage rules and descent groups, and assumes a universal genealogical grid that David Schneider (A Critique of the Study of Kinship, 1984) later questioned.
Kroeber turned kinship terminology into a field of systematic, comparative analysis. The debate he opened with Rivers still frames how anthropologists relate language to social structure.
The other parts of Q8
- Q8(a)Critically examine Arjun Appadurai's conceptualization of global cultural economy.
20 marks · Economic Organisation · Economic anthropology and globalisation
- Q8(b)Describe the causes of structural abnormalities of chromosomes with suitable examples.
15 marks · Human Genetics · Chromosomes, mutations and genetic disorders
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking