Learn with Anil · UPSC Civil Services PYQsMains PYQs →Subscribe ₹149
Prehistoric rock paintings at Bhimbetka, Madhya Pradesh

Photo: Bhimbetka rock paintings, Yann, CC BY-SA 4.0

UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2023 · Paper I

UPSC Anthropology Optional 2023 Paper 1 · Q6(a): model answer

Anthropology Paper I: Foundations of Anthropology, Human Evolution, Culture, Society and Human Genetics · Research Methods in Anthropology.

Q6(a)20 marks2023 · Paper I

Critically discuss the controversies related to fieldwork of Bronislaw Malinowski and Margaret Mead.

Syllabus: Research Methods in Anthropology · Fieldwork and ethnography

Model answer · free

Participant observationMalinowski's DiaryMead–Freeman controversyReflexivity

Bronislaw Malinowski (Argonauts of the Western Pacific, 1922) and Margaret Mead (Coming of Age in Samoa, 1928) made long, first-hand fieldwork the hallmark of anthropology. Both later faced controversies over the objectivity, ethics and authority of the ethnographer, which helped give rise to reflexive anthropology.

1. Controversies around Malinowski

  • The Diary (1967): his private field diaries of 1914–18, published posthumously as A Diary in the Strict Sense of the Term, revealed loneliness, irritation, sexual fantasies and contemptuous, even racist, words about the islanders. This clashed with his image as the empathetic participant observer; Clifford Geertz replied that understanding the native's point of view comes from interpreting symbols, not from fellow-feeling.
  • Colonial setting: an Austrian subject caught in Australia by the First World War, he worked with the consent of the colonial administration. His functionalism painted a timeless Trobriand society that ignored colonial rule, missions and traders; Talal Asad's Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter (1973) linked such silences to colonial power.
  • Male bias: Annette Weiner's restudy (Women of Value, Men of Renown, 1976) showed that women's banana-leaf bundles and skirts, exchanged at mortuary rites, were major wealth that Malinowski had largely missed.
  • Textual authority: James Clifford (1983) and Geertz (Works and Lives, 1988) showed how Argonauts builds authority through vivid scenes of "being there".

2. Controversies around Mead

  • Short, interview-based fieldwork: aged 23, Mead spent about nine months in American Samoa (1925–26), mostly on Ta'ū, lodged with an American naval family and relied on interviews with adolescent girls.
  • Freeman's attack: Derek Freeman (Margaret Mead and Samoa: The Making and Unmaking of an Anthropological Myth, 1983), published after her death, argued that Samoans prized virginity (the taupou system) and knew much rivalry, punishment and violence. He claimed her stress-free adolescence served Boas's cultural determinism.
  • The "hoaxing" claim: in The Fateful Hoaxing of Margaret Mead (1999) he relied on a 1987 interview in which Fa'apua'a Fa'amū said she and a friend had jokingly fed Mead tall tales about night-time affairs.
  • Defence of Mead: Lowell Holmes, who restudied Ta'ū in 1954 (Quest for the Real Samoa, 1987), judged her broadly right though she overstated sexual freedom. Paul Shankman (The Trashing of Margaret Mead, 2009) showed that her conclusions rested on far more than that joke, while Freeman drew on Western Samoa decades later.
AspectMalinowski (Trobriand Islands)Mead (Samoa)
Fieldwork1915–16 and 1917–18; long residence, local language1925–26; about nine months, mainly interviews
Classic textArgonauts of the Western Pacific (1922)Coming of Age in Samoa (1928)
What sparked the debateHis own posthumous Diary (1967)Freeman's books (1983, 1999)
Main chargeLack of empathy, colonial blindness, male biasWrong facts, theory-driven findings, being hoaxed
Main replyGeertz: understanding through interpretation; Weiner adds women's wealthHolmes and Shankman: broadly valid, partly overstated
The two controversies at a glance

3. Critical assessment

  • Restudies differ: as with Robert Redfield (1930) and Oscar Lewis (1951) on Tepoztlán, different periods and informants yield different pictures, which Karl Heider (1988) called the "Rashomon effect".
  • Theory and ideology: Freeman claimed to defend falsifiable, biologically informed science; critics saw a nature–nurture crusade. Both cases show ethnography to be positioned, partial knowledge.
  • Indian parallel: M.N. Srinivas wrote The Remembered Village (1976) from memory after his Rampura field notes burned at Stanford in 1970, showing that ethnography rests on memory and selection.

The controversies did not discredit participant observation; they matured it through reflexivity, restudies and ethics codes. Fieldwork is now seen as a dialogue shaped by power, gender and the observer's self, whose authority rests on transparency and ethical responsibility.

The other parts of Q6

  1. Q6(b)Discuss the impact of globalization on the economic systems of indigenous communities.

    15 marks · Economic Organisation · Economic anthropology and globalisation

  2. Q6(c)Describe the practical applications of DNA technology in the current scenario.

    15 marks · Applied Anthropology · Applications of physical anthropology

Every model answer here is free

The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.

₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking

Get it for ₹149