
Photo: Bhimbetka rock paintings, Yann, CC BY-SA 4.0
UPSC Civil Services (Main) 2023 · Paper I
UPSC Anthropology Optional 2023 Paper 1 · Q3(b): model answer
Anthropology Paper I: Foundations of Anthropology, Human Evolution, Culture, Society and Human Genetics · Religion.
How did Clifford Geertz look at religion? Differentiate between anthropological and psychological approaches to the study of religion.
Syllabus: Religion · Theories of religion
Religion as a cultural systemClifford Geertz (1966)Symbols and meaningPsychological approach
Clifford Geertz (1926–2006), the leading figure of interpretive (symbolic) anthropology, set out his view in the essay "Religion as a Cultural System" (1966), reprinted in The Interpretation of Cultures (1973). He shifted attention from the origins and social functions of religion to its meaning for believers, to be grasped through "thick description" of their symbols and practices.
1. Geertz's view of religion
- Definition: religion is "a system of symbols which acts to establish powerful, pervasive, and long-lasting moods and motivations in men", by picturing a general order of existence and surrounding it with such an aura of factuality that these moods seem uniquely realistic.
- "Model of" and "model for": sacred symbols both describe reality and shape conduct; they fuse a people's ethos (moral and aesthetic style) with its world view (picture of how things are).
- Problem of meaning: religion helps people face what threatens order: bafflement (events beyond explanation), suffering (pain beyond endurance) and evil (injustice beyond moral sense).
- Ritual: in ritual the world as lived and the world as imagined become one; in Bali, the dramatic combat of Rangda and Barong makes cosmic struggle real for performers and audience.
- Ethnography: The Religion of Java (1960) described the abangan, santri and priyayi variants, and Islam Observed (1968) contrasted mystical Indonesian Islam with saint-centred Moroccan Islam.
2. Criticism
- Talal Asad (Genealogies of Religion, 1993) argued that a universal definition reflects a modern, Protestant idea of religion as inner belief and ignores the power and discipline that produce religious dispositions.
- Others found the approach hard to verify and inclined to read culture as a text, neglecting material and political conditions.
3. Anthropological and psychological approaches
- Classic division: Evans-Pritchard (Theories of Primitive Religion, 1965) sorted earlier theories into psychological ones (intellectualist and emotionalist) and sociological ones.
- Psychological approaches locate religion in the individual mind: E.B. Tylor's animism (Primitive Culture, 1871) saw it as early reasoning about dreams and death; R.R. Marett stressed awe and emotion; Sigmund Freud (Totem and Taboo, 1913; The Future of an Illusion, 1927) treated it as wish-fulfilment rooted in childhood and guilt; Carl Jung traced it to archetypes of the collective unconscious; and Malinowski (Magic, Science and Religion, 1925) saw ritual as relieving anxiety, as in Trobriand magic for risky open-sea fishing.
- Anthropological (socio-cultural) approaches locate religion in group life and shared culture: Émile Durkheim (The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life, 1912) saw the sacred, through Australian Arunta totemism, as society worshipping itself; Radcliffe-Brown (The Andaman Islanders, 1922) stressed ritual's role in cohesion; Evans-Pritchard (Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande, 1937) showed witchcraft as a coherent logic of misfortune; Victor Turner and Geertz read ritual as symbol. In India, M.N. Srinivas's study of Coorg religion (1952) and L.P. Vidyarthi's "sacred complex" of Gaya (1961) follow this line.
| Basis | Psychological approach | Anthropological approach |
|---|---|---|
| Unit of study | Individual mind | Group, society and culture |
| Source of religion | Emotion, anxiety, unconscious drives | Collective life, social structure, shared symbols |
| Key question | Why do individuals believe? | What does religion do and mean in a society? |
| Method | Clinical study, introspection, correlation | Fieldwork, participant observation, comparison |
| Main thinkers | Tylor, Marett, Freud, Jung, Malinowski | Durkheim, Radcliffe-Brown, Evans-Pritchard, Turner, Geertz |
| Weakness | Reduces belief to psychology | May neglect inner experience |
The two approaches are complementary: Melford Spiro (1966) combined the psychological and social functions of religion. Geertz's lasting contribution was to make religion a matter of meaning, now extended by psychological anthropology and the cognitive science of religion.
The other parts of Q3
- Q3(a)What is hominization process? Discuss the major trends in human evolution with the help of suitable examples and illustrations.
20 marks · Human Evolution and Primates · Fossil hominins and human origins
- Q3(c)What is mixed-longitudinal method of studying human growth? Discuss its merits and demerits.
15 marks · Human Growth, Nutrition and Demography · Growth and development
The ₹149 All-in-One Pass opens the rest of the site for 12 months: UPSC Prelims GS Paper I and CSAT with explanations, practice quizzes and timed tests, UPSC CAPF and EPFO, the previous papers of every APPSC, TSPSC, police and SSC exam, every mock test series and the study books.
₹149 · valid for 12 months from the day you pay, on every exam · pay by UPI, card or net banking